Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Beech problems

Posts

Beech problems

#1

Beech problems

Dave Winters

>We're having problems with some doors we had built in Beech. I'm not sure the problem is with the species per se, but I have seen a lot of doors and have never had this problem to this extent. Specifically, a lot of surface checking and even veneer bubbles on both stiles and rail and panels, which are all made with engineered cores and veneered.

The problem is to such an extent that the door manufacturer sent their rep to inspect the problems first hand, and basically he says they won't stand behind them as far as a warranty claim, citing jobsite storage and moisture problems...

Anybody else have any similar experiences??

I'll post some pics.

BTW; how does one post multiple pics in one post??

Thanks.


img

Re: Beech problems

#2

More Pics 

Dave Winters

>


img

Re: Beech problems

#3

Re: Beech problems 

Dave Winters

>


img

Re: Beech problems

#4

Re: Beech problems

Bill Sams

>Dave, sorry you are having this problem. Is it american beech or european steamed beech?

American beech, I have worked with and it is prone to movement. So as to a guess, you are getting cross movement of the engineered laminations and the veneer. Depending upon the thickness of the veneer, the veneer might have absorbed the moisture from the glue and then shrunk back causing the splitting.

For full size doors a typical thickness of veneer in this application is 3/8"+.

As stated just guessing as to what might be the issue.

Re: Beech problems

#5

Multiple pics

Dan Donaldson

>The only way to post multiple pictures in one post at present time is to host them on another server somewhere and link to them with html tags. There are some free services out there, but you have to be careful as some of them limit the number of views or do not allow direct links to the pics. I have not used any of them, but others have and I am sure they can tell you which ones work ok for this. If you do it, there is some info in the FAQ's about formats, tags, etc.

Re: Beech problems

#6

Re: Beech problems

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>Dave, I don't think this is your problem, and maybe you should get an attorney to put a little pressure on the manufacture. You may need a professional wood scientist to analyze the problem on your behalf if it goes to court.

I can't tell how thick the veneers are, but I think it is either a glue starved, or incompatibility problem.

Re: Beech problems

#7

Re: Multiple pics

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Dan,

Would it work to insert pictures and verbage into MS Word and then copy and paste it into a post?

Marv

Re: Beech problems

#8

Re: Beech problems

jan derr

>i think you might have substrate movement, but I could very well be wrong about this because i'm looking at photos. My assumtion is made from the photo of the split veneer seam on the stile. my experience with this engeneered wood, though played up to be the best substrate for interior doors, has been one of splitting and checking when exposed to either moisture or sun, and worse when both. you mentioned they claim you stored the door in the wrong conditions. did they provide a disclaimer for damages for such conditions? ask their tech reps what the heck species of wood they used for the substrate and what the engeneer specs are for that wood; those specs are availlable from their suppier.

Re: Beech problems

#9

Re: Beech problems

Fred Davis

>Dave,

since your door vendor seems to be dragging their feet on customer relations and if your reasonably sure your job site storage and MC were in acceptable limits and the doors were factory finished, ask them to supply you with one or two identical doors as replacements at your expense.

If you get a return of the problem, talk to your attorney about his writing them a letter if they continue to speak to you in forked tongue English .

If the doors are fine and stay that way , then I would guess it's on you.

FredD

Re: Beech problems

#10

Re: Beech problems

jan derr

>never! all the information you need to find out what happened is at your finger tips. go to their suppliers and get the technical info on their materials. why would you buy anything else from them?

Re: Beech problems

#11

Agree with this

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca,

>Man, what a cheesy way to get out of fixing a problem. Did you store these in a spa or something? I would have to believe that there is a batch problem in the engineered substrates or something. At the very least they would/should take a door back to investigate WHY their door can't take extreme environmental swings before saying it's your fault.

Re: Beech problems

#12

Re: Beech problems

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>There appears to be stain which seeped into a check and out onto the glue-line causing the splotches. Is that what I am seeing. This would indicate a split and glue problems before the veneer opened.

Also, If the light color in the back of the split is the glue. You might get a feel for what type of glue was used under the veneer. If you can feel of it with an awl or knife blade, and it is not rigid, or is rubbery, there might be a clue of what glue they used.

I don't think the problem is with the substrate. Why would it be expanding faster than the face veneer, when the face would be expanding first, being on top?

Does your camera have a macro mode? on most cameras, it uses the icon of a flower. If you put it on that setting, you should be able to get closer for finer resolution.

Re: Beech problems

#13

More pics of a different problem..

Dave Winters

>Guys, thanks for all the great responses! Some good perspectives.

There are other problems with these doors that I didn't mention at first because I didn't want to confuse the issue.

These are issues that the manufacturerer did cop to.

One is what I think is veneer tape residue on the panels in places. The other, I'm not sure of, but I think is from a hand held roller going across grain at a veneer seam and burnishing the wood, which when stained dark reared it's ugly head. The rep kept trying to say that it was in the wood, like ray fleck or something. We actually had words over this issue and I straighted him out on it. I'll post some pics of both these issues and I'd welcome comments on them.....

As always, thanks!


img

Re: Beech problems

#14

Pics 

Dave Winters

>


img

Re: Beech problems

#15

Pics 

Dave Winters

>


img

Re: Beech problems

#16

Pics 

Dave Winters

>


img

Re: Beech problems

#17

If they used contact cement,...

Ellils Walentine

>...and you weren't aware that they were doing it, I'd demand a refund in no uncertain terms and then go buy your doors from someone who knows what they're doing. You don't use a roller for anything but contact cement, as far as I know.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Beech problems

#18

Re: If they used contact cement,...

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>Ellis is saying what I suspected as well, and was trying to lead you to finding out by feeling of the glue through the split in the first photo that you posted. If it feels like rubber, they have used contact, which will not hold standard thickness veneer if it wants to move.