Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Posts

Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#1

Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi,

I need the collective brain trust here to giveme some honest feedback on my current thinking about buying a MACBook Pro 15/2.4/2X1GB/200/256V laptop. I have been a long time Dell user and I am looking at getting my own personal LT to use aside from my ancient Dell Dimension 4400 DT.

I have looked the MAC and tried it out at the local Apple store, it seems to be set out wit a lot of well thought ideas over whatI see Dell offering in the same Inspiron models.

Just wondering if any of you have been through this purchasing effort lately and what you chose. I do not "game", but I would be interested in some applications where I can down load and burn to DVD from my digital movie camera.

So, do I go MAC or DELL?

Thanks for your thoughts,

Take care,

Jim

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#2

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Dan Donaldson

>How about Linux?

(ducking and running);-)

Depends on the applications that you want to run. If you have MS office for example, and want to move it rather than repurchase, you need Windows. Vista may be better than when it first came out, but I was not too impressed with it when I played with it on the last computer I bought. (I changed it to Linux). Given the choices you listed, I think I would take the MAC.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#3

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Jim, our daughter has used a Mac for years and has been responsible for getting her work place to change to Macs. She is a photographer and graphic artist who does a lot of computer work. My husband also made the change to a Mac laptop. there was a little bit of a learning curve but you couldn't get him to go back to a PC.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#4

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Thanks Barbara,

The photographic features are of interest to me as well. I want a display screen that can clearly present my work either on screen or on a larger LCD display. The owner of the gallery I have my pens in has been able to get me into a larger artisian show in September and I have been working on upgrading my display and the presentation of my work. The MACpro looks like a nice screen to also watch a slide show or DVD presentation on. I have been working on a digital film presentation on the pens I make for this show.

Thanks,

Jim

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#5

Gremlins and pixies

Tom Dunlap

>About three years ago I was in a similar place. I listened to my brother and got an iBook G4. From then on work on the computer has been much more pleasant.

I still have my desktop PC but I rarely use it anymore. There are few things that are easier on the PC.

My understanding about what happens on the other side of the keyboard is limited. As far as I'm concerned gremlins and pixies are there. On my Mac the pixies have control and keep order. It is rare that I have to reboot. When I do, it takes less than two minutes to do a hard reboot.

When the gremlins gain control on the PC, which happens too often, it takes well over three minutes to get back to the same place where things locked up. Also, the PC requires me to be there to click on lots of toggles, the Mac just shuts down and reboots by itself.

There are very few things that I can't do easier on the Mac. Just yesterday I did find one issue though. I needed to find a free cut list program for a shelving unit that I'm building. The only free download that I could find was for the PC. Compatiblity issues aren't the reason for not buying a Mac like it was in the past.

My brother advised me to buy a reconditioned G4 for about a 15% savings. Mac hardware has a record of being error free. So buying one that did have a problem reduced the error rate even further since the problem was fixed. Now, over three years later, my G4 is still problem free. I use my PC as often as I use a Crescent wrench since I have complete sets of metric and standard combination wrenches.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#6

Re: Gremlins and pixies

Dan Donaldson

>I have an install of XP in a virtual machine on my linux boxes for the few times that I have to use Windows for some unique application. There are a couple of virtualization programs for the MAC that will let you do the same. On my box, XP runs better in the virtual machine than it does native and I don't have to reboot to use it. You can also set up the newer INTEL based MACs to dual boot Windows if necessary.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#7

that's a good plan

Ron Griffin

>For the work you mention, primarily graphics & display, the MacBook Pro should be great. iPhoto & iDvd work very well together for easily making slide shows. I have a 1.5 year old model of that machine. Stick with the 15" screen like you're planning. I'm a mac fan, so it can be said that I'm biased.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#8

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

DickL

>After 20 years of fighting with Windows (anyone remember Windows 3.0?), I got a MacBook Pro in April. Couldn't be happier. If you just have to run some Windows programs, get Parallels Desktop for Mac - run XP better than my desk top PC. Also will run Vista. You won't look back. You might check Mac Connection for prices.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#9

Consider refurbished

paul in AZ

>There is no price variation in 'stock' models out there. Apple controls prices.

Be aware that if you want more RAM [always a good thing] or a larger HD, Apple will bleed you dry. Get these from a third party -I've used newegg.com and crucial- at half Apple's prices. I think adding RAM to a book is easy and seem to recall that HDs are difficult to change but you'd better check that. Large external HDs for backup and bulk storage are dirt cheap now.

Go to the Apple website and look for a refurbished computer. These have been fully checked out, have the full year warrantee and are eligible for Applecare. You will save a few hundred bucks in many instances.

I've not used a book but my current Mac is a refurb Pro.

It will take a short time to unlearn Windoze and from there you will never look back.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#10

Re: Consider refurbished

Thomas S Stockton

>About a year ago I bought a refurbished i-mac saved a ton of money and am real happy with it. I've always had Macs so I'm biased but the fact that in system x that only the program your working on is the one to freeze up if there are problems and you can force quit out of it is really nice. About the only program that freezes up on me is safari and it is usually caused by a web site that has video on it that hasn't totally downloaded when I close that window. My son has a laptop with vista on it and it takes forever to start and shutdown the mac is does it much faster.

Tom

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#11

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Chuck Kettler Greenwood IN

>I found the migration from windows to MAC world not as easy as I thought it would be and am thus somewhat disappointed. Nice thing about MAC is the fact that there are fewer folks writing viruses etc for the MAC operating system. They update often and the implementation of wireless was completely seamless. Whichever system you run with, get the biggest hard drive available and get a back up external. I lost my hard drive 4 months in and lost many pictures.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#12

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

John in Calgary

>You'll note that everyone here is already biased towards the Mac (me included). I got fed up with trying to keep our Windows machine at home running properly 4 years ago and we decided to buy a Mac G4 desktop. In December, we bought an intel Macbook. As long as you are doing the normal stuff (email, photos, simple spreadsheet stuff, etc.), they are great. I especially like the low maintenance (it just runs) and thoughtfullness of how it works (I've caught myself using two fingers on one of the work laptops to do the scrolling trick!). Our G4 is just now starting to struggle with the latest OSx updgrade, but it probably only needs $100 worth of memory upgrade and it will continue to work fine.

You can buy Word/Excel for OSx, but its pretty pricey (we bought it for compatibility with work). We've used iPhoto extensively (19000 photos and counting) and I've heard Aperture is pretty good too, try the free demo if you get a Mac.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#13

Mac Office software

Joe Pack

>Unless you anticipate upgrading everytime Microsoft offers an "improved" version of Office, buy the "Student" version of Office for Mac. The only difference between the student and regular versions, or so I have been told, is that the student version is not upgradable. Big deal. If upgrades become necessary, the new student version still costs less than or the same as buying the upgrade.

Boot Camp, a free Mac program, allows you to install XP or other Microsoft systems on your Mac, just in case you ever really need it.

You'll love the Mac. Be sure to buy the 3 year help plan, just in case. You speak with a real person in minutes, and they know what they are doing! Apple customer service is first class, unlike what I have experienced with Dell, Gateway, Microsoft, Best Buy......the "take your money and run" folks. Apple will be there AFTER you buy.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#14

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Don at Central Illinois

>At the local Circuit City last week and noticed a $80 program that allows you to run Windows apps on Mac. I have seen it work at various photo seminars and you don't have to rebuy programs for Mac.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#15

photographic features

David Yoho

>Jim, my youngest son is in his senior year majoring in graphic design. We purchased a MacBook Pro with an Intel processor when it first came out and he loves it. The only thing I would recommend is to get it with 2 gigabytes of memory, as this will help with graphics, photo work, and video work.

Once you get past the learning curve of a MAC, you'll never look back. The display on the MBP is as clear as anything I've seen and your photos will look great. I'm confident you'll find all you're looking for and then some with the new MAC.

David

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#16

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

wilbur

>Another vote for getting a Mac, for many of the reasons above.

If you are worried about compatibility, I use a MacBook Pro at work as my primary computer, in an environment that is almost exclusively Windows. I have a program called Parallels that allows you to run a Windows environment in its own window, but it's honestly been months since I've needed to use it.

One other important difference between OS X and Windows is that OS X doesn't rely on a registry, as Windows does, to maintain order on your computer. Both systems need to keep data regarding how the various programs and the operating system run.

With OS X, each program maintains its own data set with a file, usually a text file. This is based on the Unix underpinnings of OS X. Add a new program, get a new file. As a result, you'll wind up with lots of little files, each containing data for each program running on your Mac.

This may sound like a bit of a mess, until you look at how Windows manages this. In Windows, there's the registry. The registry is one big file that all programs access to store their own data set. It's as if all the little data files that OS X uses were merged into one big text file.

The problem is, as time goes on, Windows computers will develop registry bloat, as data gets added to the registry. A significant part of that data might even be useless data. Suppose you install a program on your computer, and then decide you want to get rid of it. In OS X, that program keeps its own data in its own file. When you get rid of the program, you may get rid of that file, or you may not, if the program wasn't written well. It may waste a little bit of hard drive space, but otherwise won't harm anything.

In Windows, if the uninstall process doesn't clear its data, it's still in the registry, which means that it will eat up your RAM. As the registry grows, it uses up more memory, leaving less for programs to run, which will make your computer run slower.

Furthermore, if something happens to the registry, your whole computer may get affected, since the registry touches on everything the computer does. In OS X, if you lose one of those data files, you lose your presets for that program, but it doesn't affect anything else, and your other programs will still run.

Our desktop computer at home is a G4 iMac that we bought in 2002. It still runs OS X 10.4 (the last version) just as quickly as the day we installed it. I'm having the same experience with my MacBook Pro, which is 18 months old now. Every Windows computer I have ever used bogged down over time.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#17

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>I Did it!

Bought an IMac for Dana too...

Photobucket

Suddenly things seem so much more clear....LOL..

Thanks for all your advice and comments, a new day ahead...

Take care,

Jim

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#18

Thanks Joe

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>I did all of that, including the three year plan...Thank You!

take care,

Jim

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#19

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

paul in AZ

>Great. You won't regret it.

BUT... you left something out.

You didn't include enough of that coffee table in the photo.

That looks fascinating.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#20

Thanks Paul!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Oh That old thing...LOL...

Take care,

Jim

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#21

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Frank Orfanello

>Jim,

i've been using a MBP with the Intel proccesor for 3 years now and would encourage you to get one. As everyone else has said they just run and run. Get as much memory as you can afford, but this is true whether you are using Mac, Windows or linux.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#22

Whoa! Way to go, dude!

Joanne in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>You couldn't stand it, eh? Saw those little suitcase handles and figured that meant you just had to bring them home with you? Good for you! As we discussed this morning, you'll be safer from viruses and spyware, and these will be great for video stuff. Glad you did the 3 yr. warranty--especially on the laptop. Someone else mentioned "BootCamp" (I couldn't think of the name this morning)--which will allow you to run XP and pc programs on part of the hard drive, so you don't have to start out buying all new software. If your printer(s) is/are usb, they will probably work with these just fine. Or did you come home with a new printer, too? I hope they threw that in. Or did they throw in the G&G coffee table? ;-)

Have fun setting them up. If you get stuck, the folks in the Apple stores are usually great about helping answer questions over the phone. And you have the other 24x7 Lifeline numbers if you need them.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#23

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

Jerry Samsen

>As one who converted to Mac two years ago -- go for it.

You have the best of both worlds with a Mac. Keep in mind that you can run WindowsXP / Vista on the Mac anyway, either through Apple provided "bootcamp" feature that allows you to boot your Mac up a as a Windows machine or using a 3rd party application that allows you to run WindowsXP/Vista concurrently. There is even an open source free utility that does this. I do that as I still use Quicken for Windows but use the OSX side for all other applications. the app I use is called Parallels Desktop.

If you go that route, you will have to purchase a licensed copy of Windows for about $140 to run on the mac.

Re: Ot-Considering a MACBook Pro

#24

Re: Whoa! Way to go, dude!

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Thanks Joanne,

I always appreciate the support,

Take care,

Jim