Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

dust collection

Posts

dust collection

#1

dust collection

barry nelson

>I am having trouble with dust collection on a delta jointer.Are there any suggestions on how to solve this problem?

Re: dust collection

#2

Re: dust collection

Ralph Turney

>Maybe if you describe the problem I'm sure someone here could help you.

Re: dust collection

#3

JL

Which jointer, which DC?

JL

>Not enough data.

Re: dust collection

#4

Re: dust collection *LINK*

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>The dust chutes on some jointers have open tops that need to be closed. See the thread below for a description of the problem and my fix later in the thread.


img

Fixing Jointer Dust Collection

Re: dust collection

#5

Re: dust collection

Fred Davis

>That didn't sound right, never saw a dust chute with a cover in any jointer I have used or owned, so..... I spent thirty minutes today going though the hoops at Deltas customer service in Pittsburgh and finally got connected to a Mechanical engineer there.

This is what he said approximately, though the design group at Delta that produced the DJ20 no longer exists as a group he said , the chute is open on top to draw fresh air though the pressed vents on each side of the cabinet to keep the heat down and the dust out of the inside of the cabinet.

So having one of those jointers for eight years , I took the side panel off and sure enough , it was clean inside.

Having never had a problem with the DC picking up the chips ( it is connected to a 5 inch spiral duct stepped down from a 8 inch trunk)

he thought that the posters DC could be the problem rather then the open dust chute.

So long story short , owners of this model or similar ones might want to rethink closing off the air supply to the cabinet and maybe look at upgrading the DC. Could save you a fire in the shop.

FredD

Re: dust collection

#6

Re: dust collection

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>That Delta rep is full of it.

The cabinet on the DJ-20 has a totally open bottom- which will provide plenty of fresh air to cool the motor which can exit the louvered vents in the doors or through gaps around the upper belt guard. It is not different than the enclosed base bandsaw- open bottom, no DC connection there. All I can say is that without the top on the chute, though most chips would be picked up by my DC, I would still get some chips bouncing out of the open top chute and off the sides of the cutter. With my chute top I now get almost no stray chips.

As old as the DJ-20 design is, I am certain it had a chip chute designed for snow shovel dust collection, NOT a modern dust collector. If they did design it for a DC, the open-toped chute was probably to keep dust out of the motor- since Delta put a cheaper ODP motor in the DJ-20 instead of a TEFC motor.

Re: dust collection

#7

Re: dust collection

Fred Davis

>well, actually the Mechanical Engineer at Delta sounded spot on, on your DC efficiency or lack of, by your totaly enclosing the dust chute , you increased your D.C.'s vacuum , so now it gets most of the chips, but not all.

The open bottom of the jointer cabinet in my shop and I suspect any modern building designed for that purpose fits rather closely to the floor , so I doubt any air flow could be accurately described as more then negligible.

The DJ 20 came on the market in 1996. bought mine in 2000 and I think that qualifies it as new as opposed to old design.

My Delta 14 inch bandsaw is about thirty years old and has a 5 inch dust port right in the middle of the bottom door, no dust at all.

It didn't come that way , but when the Oneida DC system was installed , I had a buddy cut the hole and we riveted a 5 inch flanged port onto the door. Works great and I didn't feel a urge to bad mouth Delta for not thinking of it.

Be glad to send you a pic, if you wish.

FredD

Re: dust collection

#8

Re: dust collection

Fred Davis

>one last comment on the DJ20 Jointer, the motor in mine is a TEFC 1 1/2 HP SP 220 V.

I suppose it's possible a previous owner replaced the motor in yours, but mind and every one I have seen advertised has the totally enclosed fan motor.

In the instruction manual that came with it I noticed a caveat I disagree with.

It says "Delta reccommends 14 gauge wire with a 20 amp time lag breaker or fuse and also says they recommend that same procedure on all machines .

I HAVE NEVER RUN LESS THEN 12 awg. TO ANY MACHINE REGARDLESS of voltage and in the case of the PM TS I had to use a 25 amp breaker (no time lag breaker available) to avoid occasional breaker kickoff on start up.

FredD

Re: dust collection

#9

Re: dust collection

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>I am not talking about an "old design" as to when it was actually designed/patented, I am talking elements of the design, specifically the cabinet and dust chute that were not as current as they should have been.

Since the chute is open at the top and rectangular, it is old technology. Why have a rectangular opening if it is designed for dust collection (which it was not). 99+% of dust connection hoses and ducting are round. A round port, not an after-thought plastic add-on, should have been part of the basic design. It may have been a manufacturing cost-based decision not to do it that way.

As far as keeping dust away from the motor. The DJ-20 casting and base are two separate units. The only way dust can get into the cabinet and the motor is if it escapes from the open-topped chute or enters the belt passage. The best place to get the dust is at the source- on a jointer that is at the cutter head, and an enclosed chute improves the chances of that happening, especially with a smaller DC. My big DC didn't get all the chips and dust, because the take-up air was being sucked in from the open-topped chute and not from around the cutter head! A number of WWers have reported this same issue.

As far as cooling the motor, as I said, few of the other Delta machines with closed cabinets (HD shaper, bandsaw, planer, etc.), require or could even use dust control air flow for motor cooling. If they did, it would likely say so in the manual.

Beyond the louvered cabinet sides, an additional source of cooling air (which it doesn't need) in my DJ-20, comes from under the cabinet since my DJ-20 sits on a mobile base. That provides about a 1/2" opening around the entire base and allows plenty of cooling air into the cabinet.

I am not bad mouthing Delta (I have a DJ-20 and most of my machines are gray), but their designs are not perfect. From an engineering standpoint (yes, I am one) a closed chute is better. I have also received reports from owners of other brands who say their chutes are enclosed.