Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Question for Chair Makers

Posts

Question for Chair Makers

#1

Question for Chair Makers

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>I was just going through some of my lumber stacks looking for some cherry for a project that I have coming up. Most of the cherry that I have is not dry enough to use yet, although I have a good bit of 12/4 which I sawed in 04 from a fairly crooked tree. I was thinking I might use it for chairs where the back leg needs a good bend for the legs and back to tilt.

Do any of you look for wood which has grown in crook for this purpose? I would think this may be a little hard to find on the market, because it just doesn't make for a very pretty stack, and would probably get knocked down into the lowest grade.

Since I am only needing really small parts for this current project, I feel nuts for even thinking about cutting any of this up for tiny parts.

If any of you have used grown crooked wood for this kind of project, I would like to hear from you as to whether there have been issues with the parts changing shape more than normal straight grained wood.

Also, What about value? If you were going to make some chairs where you needed a good bit of sweep for the grain to follow the leg into the back. I know how much work is involved in steam bending, then waiting for it to dry, so do you pay more for wood like this, or just feel luck when it is sold in the cheap pile.

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#2

JL

Re: Question for Chair Makers - response - long

JL

>From personal experience only.

"Do any of you look for wood which has grown in crook for this purpose? I would think this may be a little hard to find on the market, because it just doesn't make for a very pretty stack, and would probably get knocked down into the lowest grade."

Do I look for it - upon occasion. If it has lots of knots or imperfections - it isn't worth the trouble. Many of the crooked pieces have the knots and imperfections. Does the grain sweep the way I want it to sweep - will it take the stress in a proper fashion? You have to consider how much force a person can exert while sitting down. It might surprise you to find out how much it actually is.

"If any of you have used grown crooked wood for this kind of project, I would like to hear from you as to whether there have been issues with the parts changing shape more than normal straight grained wood."

The big problem is carving or changing the shape to the intended shape. If I have a normal straight grained wood, I can carve or shave it into rough shape and then steam bend it. In this way I can get the pairs of legs to look alike. Ditto for everything else that I end up bending. I'm trying for a standard. You don't want a set of chairs with legs that don't match.

"Also, What about value? If you were going to make some chairs where you needed a good bit of sweep for the grain to follow the leg into the back. I know how much work is involved in steam bending, then waiting for it to dry, so do you pay more for wood like this, or just feel luck when it is sold in the cheap pile."

See above - it may not be more valuable. You want the curve to be "just so". It typically takes me a couple of days to carve and shave legs and other stuff before steam bending. It then takes me about 2 hours to bend everything. If I put the legs, hoops and slats in a hot box, they'll be dry in 2-3 days.

I have used cupped or curved wood in back splats, arms, crests and a few other pieces. I have felt lucky when I've found wood that I can use - but I'm not going to actively search for it. I would not want to use such wood in legs or leg/back combinations because they may not take the stress.

All that being said, there you can do some interesting "art" pieces out of wood that has shapes like you describe. They can look great. But if I usually do a chair, it is part of a set - and they have to look quite similar.

My $0.02.

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#3

JL, Thanks for the response------WebKitFormBoundar

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>I guess I didn't do a very good job of describing the wood. It is really quite nice and clear of knots. It was not just a limb, but was about 24" D at this point. And I have enough of it to make a set I believe. It has about 2" of bow in about 4 feet, which to my eye would be about right for a lot of chairs.

I might not have even bothered with sawing the tree if I could have seen it good enough. There were so many vines covering this second log up that I couldn't even see it until I had it down. Since it was just down the street, and I could just drive my tractor down and grab it with the bucket, it was too tempting not to give a try.

I have decided not to cut it into little pieces. I found some Pear up in the loft which was from a short log that is drier and really nice. It will be about what I need for this project.

However, what I was hoping to find out from some of you guys who do more chairs than I is. If you have cut any parts out of wood like this, then set them aside to acclimate or even to dry on down some more, have you noticed much change in the curve.

I have steam bent some thick parts before, that I measured the chord after it was steamed, and found that the chord was shorter after drying than when it was still up around 18� after steaming. I supposed that the across the grain shrinkage through the bend would cause the piece to bend more as it dried on down.

I guess what I will do is make a pattern, and cut out a couple of blanks, then put them up in the attic for the next month or two to take the MC on down, then put the pattern back on them to compare.

------WebKitFormBoundaryFchmMfG+LWz2jxst

Re: Question for Chair Makers

#4

JL

Re: JL, Thanks for the response------WebKitFormBou

JL

>OK - I think I have the picture.

By all means, try for it. I have dried wood into shape. I.E. put some wood that already had a reasonable bend on it onto a form and threw it in the hot box. It will usually hold the dried form quite nicely. But you probably want to construct a form to constrain the wood to make sure that it doesn't twist as it dries. That would NOT be a good thing :).

If you think you have enough for a set, or even a short set of two, it would be worth it. I usually use either exterior grade plywood or sealed MDF for my forms.