Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Boards for raised beds?

Posts

Boards for raised beds?

#1

JL

Boards for raised beds?

JL

>The LOML wants me to put in a set of raised beds this fall - I get a feeling that there will be several.

I wouldn't have wanted to use the old style pressure treated wood with CCA (copper chromium arsenate) - I don't know about the new style with ACQ (Alkaline Copper Quaternary salts). I have seen some studies that say ACQ treated wood should work just fine. What have ya'll used?

Yes, I've seen the Lee Valley set up that uses patio blocks - that is under consideration. I'm looking to put up maybe 4 raised beds, at least 3' x 8', but I could be talked into longer and wider. I have contemplated putting in a plastic (or old tire) liner.

TIA.

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#2

Re: Boards for raised beds?

Thomas S Stockton

>I personally wouldn't use any type of treated wood in a raised bed that had food in it. Just don't want to risk having that stuff in my food. We use old 2" fir and rebuild the beds every so often.

Tom

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#3

I used cinder blocks. *LINK*

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca,

>I'm in the process of making some raised flower beds and decided to use those gray cinder blocks instead of redwood. I couldn't see spending for con-heart redwood to stick on the ground and I know I won't be in any better physical condition when they rot in a few years. So far I have made one of the cinder block beds and I purchased a can of Behr concrete stain to tone done that industrial cinder block look. I haven't applied the stain yet as I have just finished one bed. Heh, I hope I chose a wife pleasing color. I didn't use any mortar or glue to bond the blocks together and only a very shallow trench was dug to aid in leveling and placing the blocks. I filled the two large holes in the blocks with dirt, wet it, compacted it down, then refill and re wet the areas. I plan on using a few metal rebar stakes to secure the corner blocks. Each block weighs 26 lbs. or so and they seem fairly secure. I only did a single block height raised bed. Here's a link to one of the many sites I found for "cinder block raised flower beds"


Cinder block flower beds

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#4

Re: Boards for raised beds?

John McGaw

>I would not hesitate to use treated lumber for vegetable garden raised beds. If you worry about some sort of contamination then install inexpensive PVC pond liner inside so that the soil doesn't come into contact with the wood. Of course you will need to provide drainage through the pond liner so that it doesn't truly wind up a pond but if you buy the cheaper sort it shouldn't be overly painful.

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#5

JL

Re: OK - Thanks.

JL

>I've got some thick rolls of plastic leftover from my former job - probably would be the perfect liner. I can even do a "cap" to hold the plastic to the sides.

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#6

Re: Boards for raised beds?

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>I used cinder blocks for vegetable garden raised beds. They work, but...eventually the holes fill with soil and grow weeds, which can be hard to pull; when the ground under them shifts a bit, individual blocks also shift. If you need to step or lean on them (you know, while you are weeding or planting) they're not terribly stable. And, yes, they're not too attractive, although that doesn't matter for my use.

I had figured that when I next put in more raised beds, I would either use regular lumber and figure on replacing by and by, or use one of the Trex-type products. I hadn't looked, but surely one of those manufacturers makes a large size for this sort of use? Seems like a good market...

Ken

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#7

Re: Boards for raised beds?

John K Jordan

>JL,

I add a few each year. I have been building them out of railroad ties since that makes a nice wide place to sit. Since my garden site is on a mild slope, I fill in under the front tie as needed and on the ends with black locust or e.r.cedar boards cut on my sawmill. I drive black locust stakes into the ground on the inside and hold everything together with screws (8" timberlock landscaping screws for the end boards).

JKJ

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#8

JL

Re: I aim to grow vegetables, not..

JL

>flowers :). I don't really plan on sitting much while I'm out there. My main objection to heavy stuff like cinderblock or railroad ties is that I have to manhandle it. I'd rather not risk my rotator cuff if I don't need to. It'll be a while before I get a lawn tractor (or riding lawnmower) or something with which I could move something heavy.

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#9

Do you have children?

Ed Snow

>My father seems to think I am exceptionally good at moving rail road ties and 8" landscaping timbers, so he continues to have me do so whenever I am around. With that logic noted any child ought to work.

It is not one of my favorite activities so expect some complaining.

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#10

Re: I aim to grow vegetables, not..

Jim Pugh, Elyria, OH

>I made my beds out of treated 4x6's with the 6 dimension being verticle. Used 8 footers and made the beds 4x8. Worked out well. After a couple of years I added a second layer to make the beds deeper. Just locked the corners together inside with plated angle brackets. Once filled with dirt they aren't going anywhere.

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Durable ansd more durable.......

Jesper, Denmark

>Wehave a fe raised flower beds in the patio area made from granite curbstones. Quite nice looking, but as they weigh 230 lbs each, they were a pain to manhandle in place.

Black locust boards would still last longer than PT lumber and weather to a nice grey and not need any treatment against rot.

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#12

Re: I aim to grow vegetables, not..

John K Jordan

>All of ours are for vegetables. I've become a believer in raised beds - it's easier to control moisture, no one steps on plants and roots, and it's far easier on the old back when thinning and weeding. And things grow like crazy. For example, nearly everyone around here tells me they've given up on carrots but we get the best carrot crops in the beds. (Dig deep) Things like lettuce, radishes and onions really take off. I'm getting ready to plant elephant garlic followed by some fall cool-weather crops soon. I fill the beds with a mixture of garden soil and composted horse/chicken/goat manure & hay.

I don't have any good pictures but this one shows the "shallow" end of one and the corner of another.

BTW, I also have rotator cuff problems but fortunately I have a tractor with a front-end loader. As for manual labor, I used to hire teens from the church for heavy work - you might ask your youth director.

JKJ


img

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#13

Raised beds? Why sure

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Our younger son's first raised beds were just that: old pickup beds filled with dirt. He even put an old open "box" spring at one end of one for the peas, thus making a raised bed in a raised bed.

Around where you live, I bet you could get dozens of rusted-out pickup beds for the asking.

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#14

JL

Re: Nah - they are still driving them.

JL

>

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#15

Re: Boards for raised beds?

Curly Smith

>I cut used 3'x14' sheets of steel roofing/siding into 1' widths, attached it to cedar stakes, and made a 20' x 30' raised bed garden. It was a lot less work, and used far less construction material, than a series of smaller beds.

Like Ken, I'm wondering about the plastic boards and the plastic trim boards in particular. It comes in decent widths and if you put in enough rot-resistant stakes (maybe every 18") then you could keep it straight. It would take longer to install than treated wood but you wouldn't need the liner and it should last a long time.

One other possibly bad thought... how about UV resistant fiberglass siding/roofing cut into strips like I did with my used siding? It's more than strong enough to hold the minimal load, it's cheap, it's light and it's corrugated for your protection.

Also, if you stick with smaller beds, you might consider a 2' x 8' instead of a 3' x 8' bed since each would only allow 1 crop (or a 4' x 8' and plant 2 rows 1' from each side).

Re: Boards for raised beds?

#16

Re: Boards for raised beds?

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I haven't read all of the other responses - each has their own ideas, I suppose.

I am a greenie at heart, when I grow my own veggies. I don't like additional toxicity added on my account. The price difference here between chemical laced 2x12 and con heart redwood isn't worth it.

We have 7 open bottomed, redwood sided 4'x8' grow boxes. The interesting part is that the growing medium now reaches down at least 32", the results of taking care of the soil over the last ten years. And water that leaks through, as it should, waters and nourishes the other plants that grow in our mediterranean climate.

Redwood is our local outdoor wood. There, it may be a cedar, or something else. Use what grows there. And dig deeply for your growing soil. Let someone else worry about replacing the walls of your garden in twenty or thirty years, but don't make them worry about the chemicals that you put into the soil.

OK. Preaching done. That wasn't really intended. Enjoy your garden.