Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Very basic electrical question

Posts

Very basic electrical question

#1

Very basic electrical question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Why are electrical hookups that are typically measured with a voltmeter at 240 and 120 usually referred to as 220 and 110. Inquiring minds want to know.

Clint

Re: Very basic electrical question

#2

Re: Very basic electrical question

Barry Irby

>Clint, I am 59 and as my kids say, Back in the day, they actually were 110/220. Somewhere in the way back when the power companies changed them to 120/240, maybe 40 or 50 years ago. I don't know why, maybe for uniformity or to bump up the transmission rates a little. They often vary a little. It's common to measure 237 and 117. sometimes they are a little high also and I think they have an allowable tolerance or variance. Might be 5%. So, 110/220 just persists as part of the lingo.

There is another way to tap the generators and the power comes off as 110/208. Not used locally, but it may be in use somewhere in the country. You see it on the rating plates of motors and it may be enough of a variation to actually affect the output of the motors slightly.

Re: Very basic electrical question

#3

Re: Very basic electrical question

Dan Donaldson

>The 208 is usually 3 phase. They also tap a 3 phase system to get 277 which is used in a lot of commercial applications for the lighting.

Re: Very basic electrical question

#4

Re: Very basic electrical question

steve mackay

>Good one ! I don't understand electricity and don't pretend to. When I'm baffled ( often ) I call the brother-in-law. He works for the 'Lectric company building substations. His easy answer ( for the ignorant layman . . . ME ! ) is that the numbers are "optimum" when it comes out of the transormer on the pole. Then by the time it goes down both legs, into and out of your fuse box, through the house and all the different connections and outlets, AND the other houses that your transformer services, the value at any one outlet in YOUR house can vary +/- 10. Thats their "target". He says this is an over-simplified explanation but gives you the general idea.( At this point I nod my head and say " Yes Gerry, I understand. Now help me fix it." )

Re: Very basic electrical question

#5

Re: Very basic electrical question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I am skeptical of that answer, so everyone with a voltmeter take a reading and report back if it's closer to 110 than 120. Mine always read 120 and 240, except when they read zero when we take a power hit.

Clint

Re: Very basic electrical question

#6

JL

Re: Very basic electrical question

JL

>I was involved in moving my old company's laboratory into a converted factory facility. The building was ~1/4 mechanical shop ~1/4 laboratory and offices and ~1/2 warehouse. We had many electrical panels - even after the electricians worked on them (or should I say especially?).

Anyway to cut to the chase. A number of the instruments weren't working correctly (a SEM, a GC/MS, etc.) The voltage on some of the circuits was 105 +/- 5 volts - and it varied over time. The voltage on some of the other circuits was 115 +/- 5 volts. Some of the circuits were 120 volts. This was all in the same building. The instruments that weren't working correctly required at least 115 volts.

Re: Very basic electrical question

#7

Historical changes

Bill Howatt

>If you look at the power labels on old electrical devices you will see the input voltage specified as 110V, later on 115V and even 117V then it goes to 120V. The corresponding line-to-line voltages are double each value.

This implies a slow change in the devices corresponding to an increase in the line voltage by the utilities.

Voltages can vary during the day because of changes in loading on your local circuit and the voltage on the portion of the grid supplying your circuit. I believe the goal is to try and keep it within +/- 5% (10% overall) of the nominal 120V but wider excursions are not forbidden within reason. Tight control is maintained on the 60Hz frequency but not the voltage.

Bill

Re: Very basic electrical question

#8

For the same reason that

Henry Higginbotham

>. . . people insist on pronouncing height as if it were spelled heigth, the same reason they use nonexistent words like "alot," and the same reason so few people get its/it's correct. They don't know, don't care, and can't take 30 seconds to learn.

Whatever the reason, I vote that it's way past time to put 110/220 to rest, unless you're talking about some place that actually, and intentionally, uses those voltages.

And to answer your other question, my nearest receptacle measured 120.8 volts a few minutes ago. I can't remember ever measuring it at less than 120. Everybody's air conditioning is on tonight.

You can also sometimes get unexpected readings if the transformers are getting long in the tooth. My shop has open-delta three phase, and when it was initially wired maybe five years ago, the high leg measured around 230 volts to ground (it should have been 208, I think--or is it 214?). A couple of nominal 240 volt circuits that used that leg measured 263-266 volts. Recently, Alabama Power had to replace the ancient pole in the alley, and they put a new transformer in, as well. Now everything is back to around 240-242 volts.

Re: Very basic electrical question

#9

Simple economics / marketing

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>As the increase rates they know that we would get upset if we didn't think we were getting more for our money. So they increased the voltage just slightly so that we think we're getting a little more for the money.

No, not really, but then again ..... ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Very basic electrical question

#10

Re: Very basic electrical question

John Ballance

>Good question, but the answer is a little complicated.

The voltage levels delivered to consumers are set by ANSI standard C84.1, which specifies the maximum and minimum voltages at the "service" connection (basically at the meter), and at the "utilization" point (the motor in your shop). (Service voltages may also be specified by your state public utilities commission, but they will typically be within the ANSI C84.1 range.) Because there will be voltage drop between the utility transformer and the end-use device, the "service" voltage minimum is higher than the "utilization" voltage minimum. So the utility must deliver 120 volts at your meter to ensure that you have 115 volts (approximately) at your table saw motor (or other end use device). (If I recall correctly, the standard allows for about 4% voltage drop internal to the house.)

Next, end use consumer devices are designed to meet standards (such as ANSI C84.1 and NEMA MGI) that say that devices are designed for a specific "nominal" voltage level, and should operate normally when the voltage is 10% below nominal. This enables the manufacturers to design standard components and expect them to operate normally anywhere in the country - regardless of whether your house is right next to the substation, or at the end of the distribution line. My notes show that the NEMA standards were changed in about 1965 to match ANSI C84.1.

The last part is that utilities install equipment on their distribution systems to control the voltages delivered to their customers to fall within specified ranges, so all the "standard" equipment will work properly. Of course, nothing is perfect, so on a very heavy load day (like the hottest day of summer), you might find your house voltage falling below the intended minimum. But it won't be because your utility didn't try to keep the voltage within range.

I hope this helps.

John - former electric utility engineering manager