Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

Posts

Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#1

Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

Dean Lapinel

>1500 sf red oak with previous 15 y.o Street shoe finish (water poly).

Using U-sand (4X 6" discs.

Finish is 98% off now but odd things happening.

kingspor discs

Norton discs

Both do the same;

At 36 grit they skip and really don't remove anything and don't wear down (machine is 150 pounds).

60 grit removes wood for about 15 minutes.

I need to sand down into those little shallow grain lines that can't be more than a mm or two deep. The old finish remains in these areas. It would take too many passes with 60 to get the whole area done....SO SLOW!

Any ideas about why the more aggressive grits aren't "catching"?

Wet the floor first?

drum sander is out of the question due to board layout and space.

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#2

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

Chuck in ND

>The last thing you want to do is wet the floor. You just need to have a little patience, it is what it is and in order to do a good job these things take time. If you try to rush the job, you will regret it everytime you look at it after it's done.

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#3

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

Barry Irby

>I am interested in this. I posted on this about two weeks ago. You might try searching under my name back two weeks or a month. I have not rented the machine yet, but plan to in the not distant future. Hope you work this out and let us know.

Somewhere in my reading about the machine I got the impression the disk life was about fifteen minutes. Also, that you need the disks made for the machine that have exceptionally heavy backing paper. That might be your problem if the other brands don't have heavy backing. Are the disks wrinkling?

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#4

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

Dean Lapinel

>The Kingspor are made for U-sand and they have slightly thinner backing than the Norton. None wrinkle.

15 min is about right.

Sadly, my Rigid ROS that is also 6" does a better job and each single disk lasts longer. If I were younger I would just use that hand tool and probably a stanley 12 scaper. :)

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#5

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>FWIW, I had a smilar experience with a different brand of what is essentially a ROS floor device; mine was one of the large rectangular ones. It was just very, very slow to take off the old finish, even with the rougher grits. I tried to put more weight over it by kind of sitting on it. That helped some. I think the problem is that sure, you are only trying to go down a millimeter, but the sander is trying to remove (in my case) over a square foot of 1 mm depth, and that's a bit of work. Couple that with a nonaggressive design, and you have a recipe for serious boredom while you wait for the thing to sand off the smallest ding.

I went back to using one of the little (smaller diameter) drum sanders after that experience. Tricker to control but I couldn't stand the slowness of the other type of sander.

Sorry I could't offer any actual help. I decided it was just the nature of the beast.

Ken

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#6

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

Andy Halterman: I like cooler weather

>Now you know why us pro guys use big belt machines.

Usand means you spend lots of time. Great machine for certain things but it lacks the stones to really get the job done.

Did you try contacting a local guy and maybe working a deal where he sands to a certain point and you take it from there? I've done that for people before.

Anyway, I hope it all works out for you.

Andy Halterman

Wake up, work, sleep, repeat in Henersonville, NC�

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#7

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

Barry Irby

>Andy, are you a pro floor sander/finisher?

I don't know my NC geography. How far are you form the Cary/Apex area?

I am working on house there for my cousin and it will have some major patches in the red oak flooring. I take it from your post that the USand would not be the right tool for leveling the patches from removing walls and rearranging the rooms.

Any chance you would interested in the work? Otherwise, can you recommend somebody local?

I don't think I'm up to having my butt dragged all over the house by a drum sander.

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#8

Re: Floor Sanding Arrgh!!!!

S. Traum

>Andy is right on target with a drum sander. If you want to waste a lot of time and money buying those U-Sand discs and still not have a professional looking job, keep doing what you are doing. I installed oak hardwood floors in four rooms last year. After spending hours using a U-Sand sander and getting very little of the floor sanded smooth, I finally consulted a pro who directed me to a drum sander first, and a large square-pad sander for finishing next. The results were fantastic.

I didn't have scratch marks and the floor finished out just like a mirror.

The trouble with using 36 grit sand paper on the U-Sand is that your will have a very hard time getting those scratches out even if you use finer grits of U-Sand sandpaper later. If you want good results and are not comfortable with a drum sander, my suggestion would be to hire a pro to sand and do the finishing yourself.

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#9

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

Andy Halterman: I like cooler weather

>I'm on the left side of the state just south of Asheville. The Containment Area for Relocated Yankees (Cary) is about 4.5 hrs away. I'd contact one of the flooring distributors in the area and see what they say. NWFA (Nat. Wood Flooring Assoc.) should have a list on their website somewhere. It's a bit too much of a drive for me but thanks for the offer.

Let me know if you have trouble finding a source and I can see what I can do from my end.

Good luck.

Andy Halterman

42 miles of pedaling pavement on a cool morning in Hendersonville, NC�

Re: Floor Sanding- ARGGH!

#10

Re: Floor Sanding Arrgh!!!!

Dean Lapinel

>I took your advice and rented a drum sander.

I wish I had gone with my intuition and skipped the U-sand and the vibratory sander I swapped it for. The drum sander was incredible!!

I think the issue with the drum sander is not that it's difficult, more that it requires concentration and awareness of potential trouble.The sander I rented was a 40 year old drum. It was problem free and took off as much wood as I wanted but was also capable of finer (100 grit) runs. Feather starts were enjoyable.