>Since several people brought up the subject of refinishing antique furniture, I thought I throw in my perspective on the whole subject. Lets see if I can explain it well enough for people to understand. As I mentioned in a earlier post, most hardcore antique people think it's a sin to refinish, well in some cases that maybe true, some people are horrible at it, but I think the real decideing factors are, is it extremely rare and belongs in a museum were it will only get looked at and never used ? Then by all means don't touch it. On the other hand is it something thats fairly generic that you plan to use but has very little finish left on it, or has been white washed and or is so rickety and beat up that your afraid it will fall apart ? This is where antique furniture lost it's luster and became thought of as junk by alot of people, probably one good reason there aren't many antique shops left in our city anymore. All the antique furniture I have repaired and refinished gets used. As far as it being an investment, well all I can say is, they don't buildem like that anymore, I doubt I'll be loseing money on them. One thing to remember if you refinish a piece is original hardware is allweays a plus.
>I agree completely. this is almost the same thing that I tell a customer when they want an antique refinished...do you want it done to use and keep using and pass down? or would you rather keep the value? I always tell someone that if an antique is refinished, the value is significantly less. most people who bring me antiwues to refinish though, want it done anyways, as the piece is in such bad shape and they want it too look good in thier house, as opposed to sitting in a museum.
>Antique furniture is all over the place around here. To me, the word "antique" simply means it's old enough to be called antique. I think from there you have the breakdown of importance and value. There are fine antiques that are valuable and then there are the run-of-the-mill antiques that don't have any special monetary value.
I'm not a professional appraiser but if someone ever brings me an antique I think has some value due to its maker, history, or rarity, I would advise them to consult a professional first.
All of the antiques I've restored have been daily user type stuff that was either purchased at an antique shop or owned by the family for years. Mostly it's mass-produced furniture of bygone eras that was sturdily built but either has fallen into disrepair or needs a major face lift to be used and enjoyed again by the owner.
When it comes to stripping, I don't advocate it if it's not needed. I've had several customers bring me old pieces and say to strip it that didn't need stripping. I explain the cost difference and advise when it's not necessary. I have a technique I learned years ago for cleaning and revitalizing an old but still intact finish that brings back the luster and shine without going through the whole stripping process.
Just because a piece of furniture is old enough to be considered an antique, doesn't always mean it's a fine antique of museum quality. I think it's wise to get as much information from the owner about the piece and then research it as much as possible from any labels that might still be visible. I always tell customers with strip jobs of the decrease in value and let them decide the final fate. Again, if I even suspect a piece has value, I advise them to seek a professional appraiser first. However, for daily user stuff, I'm always happy to bring the piece back to its former beauty and usefulness for a fee!!
>I don't think it's fair to say that in all cases it devalues the piece. There are alot of pieces out there that are in pretty tough shape, leaveing them in the condition they are in only invites more deterioration. I know, theres a fine line in all this.
>"is it extremely rare and belongs in a museum were it will only get looked at and never used ? Then by all means don't touch it."
Actually most museum pieces are cleaned up quite a bit as they mean to show them as they looked when made. It is the antiques auction market that seems to equate dirt with authenticity.
>Supporting David's comments about fixing without stripping: clients sometimes say "I think this needs stripping", to which I reply "let's try cleaning it first". This plus a little French polishing (maybe) and a coat of wax often does the trick. Also, Briwax gives a good result all by itself. I ask if they care about the value (don't touch) or would they like it to look like it did when Chippendale made it. With the non-stripping method which preserves the patina, it may look even better!
>As a former restorer I have always thought that if the craftsmen of yester year spent so much time picking and choosing woods and matching and joining, they hardly wanted their efforts clouded by oxidisation. It was at one point that there were traveling finishers who would arrive every so often and recoat the household's treasures. I once stripped and finished a customers cherry chest on chest. It was a dark muddy brown when I began. When it was done it was a stunning red-brown with great grain, etc. It was one of those pieces that I sat and had a Jim Beam and branch with after the day's work. Oh yeah, I polished the brass, too, what's the world coming too?
>It is true that these days the antique market frowns on refinishing, but it was not always that way. That is a twentieth and twenty first century attitude. Back in the eighteenth and nineteenth century, and even in the early part of the twentieth, it was considered perfectly acceptable to refinish antiques. The mania for "untouched since the cabinet maker made it" is a recent creation, probably spawned by some of the modern auction houses and furthered by television shows.
You might want to compare our current definition of antique (something 100 years old or older, and basically original) with the Japanese view. They have antiques that go back hundreds and even thousands of years, but have no problem with the concept of making appropriate replacements, even to replacing all the parts. They have a hard time understanding our definition of original. Their's is quite different. To them, the joke about the hammer makes no sense. ("This is an original hammer that has been in my family for 150 years. The handle has been replaced three times and the head twice.")
There have been court cases about the definition of antique on imported Japanese pieces over just this issue. Some temples, for example, get burned to the ground and exact replicas rebuilt every fifty or one hundred years or so, and they are considered original to whatever time the first one was built on that spot.
Thus, what you should or should not do to a piece is a function of both time period and geography.
>You are almost absolutely correct on dates. Refinishing antiques was still considered ok in the late 1930w, at least in Marblehead, Mass. Mrs. Jakes, a friend of my family and an antique dealer, always said that the new idea of keeping the original finish was silly. Arther Heinztelman, Curator of the BPL and a well known etcher (also a friend) stated much the same but said that it was museums that were driving the view. As a result I have always refinished our antiques, and we have more than afew, as they needed it. After all, unless the furniture is too fragile to be used, use it. If it is fragile, then put it away.