Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

What's the best way to produce this table top edge

Posts

What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#1

What's the best way to produce this table top edge

Dan Mitchell

>On a small table top, maybe the TS with the blade tilted, on a larger one, a router, router table? Say you're doing a table ~ 24 x 48. A router table would handle the long edge of the top, but what about the end grain portion? What bit would be best? Raised panel?


img

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#2

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

North of the Border

>I'd probably use a straight edge and a router because neither my tablesaw nor router table is a big one for the job. It's also easy for me to control the cutting (routing) than working with a large (and heavy?) piece of stock As for the end grain, I can do a climb cut to reduce tear cut. If I had a big tablesaw, I might use a tablesaw though.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#3

Hand plane

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#4

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I've done a similar profile using a tablesaw, router table, and handplanes. I rounded over the top edge more than your picture shows, but the lower bevelled edge was similar.

1) the straight bevelled edges were done on the tablesaw with a tilted blade. The tabletop was fed through on edge. It has to be done carefully (don't let the board tip away from the fence) but it wasn't too scary.

2) the bevelled edges were cleaned up with a sharp handplane.

3) the rounded portion was done with a router or router table.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#5

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

Brian Gray in Sandusky, OH

>A shaper wasn't mentioned yet. A shaper with a powerfeed would be the fastest and probably safest way.

But if you don't own one, they are pricey, and the cutters are also pricey.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#6

JL

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

JL

>I've made a jig that fits over my fence (the LOML has the camera and she's far away). Basically I've got a "U" shaped channel that fits over the fence. I've glued and screwed (above maximum blade height) a tall backing board. I've got a couple of large holes drilled in a number of places in the backing board.

I clamp the table top to the jig and saw away. I refine the sawn edge with a hand plane.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#7

excellent idea

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>That angle is less than 45 so it is going to have to be done with top on edge. The problem is the table wiggling while cutting. I have captured a board on edge between two fences to lessen wiggling propensity but Your arrangement is the best I have seen.

I don't see how this cut could be made with a router.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#8

Re: Bosch Colt with a tilt base...

Denny

>Bill,

I've used the Colt with a tilt base (about $30) and a long straight bit to do something like this. It takes a minimal amount of jigging to keep things under control.

Denny

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#9

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

North of the Border

>Forgot to say I'd use multiple passes and also my method might not get that kind of sharp angle. A raised panel bit should only be used with a router table.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#10

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. I've seen shop made jigs like the one JL mentions, trouble again is the end grain, if the table is long, depending I guess on how high your ceilings are ;-)

Still don't see why you couldn't use a 25 degree raised panel bit either hand held (for the end grain on a long table) or entirely on the router table if the top is not too long. You could then easily saw off the tongue portion on the TS, or finish/round it as you wished.

Dan

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#11

BTW measured the pic, it's ~25 degrees

Dan Mitchell

>Which seems to further support the raised panel bit theory.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#12

Agree

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#13

JL

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

JL

>My cabinet saw table is ~34" to the top. I've got a bit over 8' to my ceiling. That gives me a 5' table. I've cut 48" tables before.

My personal problem with a panel raising bit is the mass of the bit. That's a lot of angular momentum to control at 12,000 rpm. I'd only want to do it with the bit in a router table. If you are using a vertical bit, you have the same problem. If you are using a horizontal bit, you'd better have a 3 1/4 hp router in the table as it is a bit much for a 2 1/4 hp (pun sort of intended :)) router.

If you do want to try it with a hand held router, have the table top securely mounted on the bench with a scrap piece either mounted on the base or beside the table top. This is to keep the router from tilting. I'd also have a good edge guide so you won't cut into your top (even with a bearing on the bit).

My $0.02.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#14

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

Barry Irby

>I did three of them. One was aobut 20 X 52" and the others were about 20 X 20 and 14 x 22.

I screwed a piece of plywood to my saw fence about 16" tall and 60" long, making a very tall fence. Tilted the blade to the desired angle and sawed it. Use a Forrest WW11 blade and cleaned it up with a ROS. I have a Contactors TS with a ten inch blade. Piece of cake. It was easier to do than to explain.

I also like the siding fence or jig mentioned above. Might do that next tiem, but it was so easy, I may not. Come to think of it, for the big one I think I clamped a brace to the fence and table to keep it stiff and vertical. I had to saw it onthe "back" side of the fence because that's the way the blade tilts.

You can also tilt the blade into the fence and saw it that way, but the piece trapped between the blad and the fence becomes an arrow. On those occasions, I started with a small cut and basically did it over and over, turnign the waste into dust. The advatage to that is you can not screw up. Once you reach the possision for the last cut, you can run the piece over and over to clean it up.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#15

Re: Recommend extreme caution

North of the Border

>if you decide to use a panel bit not on a table. I read somewhere on a forum a guy reporting kick back from the action and his arm was actually hurt from the sudden and unexpected twist motion. His arm wasn't cut but he said he lost control of the router. The size (and the mass) of the bit is intimidating even used on a router table and I have never attempted using it freehand.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#16

2 Jigs

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Friend made that cut when he went to a Shaker furniture "school". They used a tall wall (24") clamped to the table fence for the long side rip cuts. They used to a sliding jig for the end (cross) cuts that moved in the miter shots (like a cut-off sled) and held the table from both sides in a vertical clamp to keep it plumb. The whole assembly slid to make the cut quick and simple.

He said they did the cross cuts first.

Cleaned up a belt sander in a special frame.

mm

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#17

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

Fred Davis

>Looking at the shallow angle Dan, I wouldn't have any trouble running that over a jointer with the bottom side resting against a clamped to the table angled 3 by 3 and the fence of the jointer set to keep the leading edge in the same place with every pass.

FredD

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#18

time to take notice

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When confronted with what seems to be a difficult operation and someone says, I've done that, and here is how" it is time to perk up and take notice. Theory doesn't trump "been there and done that.....successfully". There is little question how I would now tackle this job if I needed to.

An interesting question is how did the Shakers do it?

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#19

Yep!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#20

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top *LINK*

Sgian Dubh

>There's far too much contributor overthinking and attempted application of unnecessarily complicated machine technology for this most simple of tasks.

Unless you're doing scores of panels with such a profile that makes it worthwhile either jigging up machines or setting up special tooling and cutters it's my experience that the simplest approach is best.

Here's the simple method. Hold a pencil between finger and thumb and mark the limit of the bevel on the bottom face of the panel using a spare finger as a fence to guide the pencil lead. Using the same sophisticated marking tool (sic) mark the limit of the bevel on the edge and/or end of the panel.

Dig out a hand held electric plane, switch it on and tear off the wood until you've got close to your two pencil marks. Finish the job off with a hand plane. Round off the upper edge of the profile with a bit of abrasive paper held in your hand.

I've done these sorts of profiles so many times I've forgotten how many I've done-- see link and browse around a bit to see several examples of similar profiles on my work. It usually takes me no more than 30- 55 minutes to do all four edges of an average table top from initial marking to final sanding using the method I've just described.

Before I had a hand held electric plane I had to do it with a non-electric hand plane. It never took more than an hour even using these tools-- just make sure you use a really coarsely set and aggresive cutting jack plane or something similar for the initial bevelling work. Slainte.


http://www.richardjonesfurniture.com/halltable4-large.html

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#21

A dare!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I dare you to post this elegant(in its simplicity) solution on the hand tool Forum! Some would have a stroke.

I borrowed a power hand plane once and when I returned it I told its owner that if I was ever hired to "make a mess" this would be the tool for the job. (but it worked as intended)

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#22

Re: A dare!

wilbur

>Prediction:

If you post this over on the Hand Tools forum, you'd quickly get an answer about using a hand saw to play the role of the power planer by cutting off the corner close to your lines. Then finish with a hand plane

At least that's what I do, except that I have to admit that I've not done as many of these as Richard.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#23

Re: A dare!

Sgian Dubh

>What could they possibly object to Bill?

Before I used a hand held electric plane I used hand planes, which I described, so that fits the hand tool only ethos.

Do you mean they'd object to me using a coarsely set and aggresive cutting jack plane?

In truth I only said use a jack plane in this thread because I reckoned most visitors here would have one like it. I actually use an old wooden try plane I've got for this kind of work. It's a brutally efficient extremely coarse cutting monster if I set it up just right for such tasks. It's more like a field plough than an effeminate 'wood-lovingly-crafted' type plane. Hell, I've even used a drawknife to rip most of the wood off before a bit of fiddling and pussyfooting around with a couple of nicely set up smoothing planes. Slainte.

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#24

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top

Marc

>Funny, I just did something like this last weekend, but on a curved bubinga edge. I did it with a router and 1/2" cutter and a jig. The jig ran along my curved reference edge (fence) and was angled at the angle of the taper I wanted. Then multiple passes with the router being slid down the jig and multiple passes to get to the depth I wanted.

Finished with a handplane for smoothing. This all worked fine on endgrain.

Hopefully when I get my camera back I'll be able to post some pics, as this is a piece I am finally very proud of :)

Marc

Re: What's the best way to produce this table top edge

#25

I'd like to see the pics!

Dan Mitchell

>