Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Anyone see a problem with this construction?

Posts

Anyone see a problem with this construction?

#1

Anyone see a problem with this construction?

Henry Higginbotham

>I'm sketching out plans for a pair of subwoofer cabinets. These are for music, not home theatre, so I want solid bass with pitch definition, not loud, boomy exploding cars, buildings, and bad guys.

I briefly thought about laminating solid, glued-up panels of white oak (since I've got a pile of it) to MDF, but quickly realized that it would either split or buck off the MDF pretty quickly.

Now my plan is to laminate 18mm MDF to 12mm Russian birch plywood, and then laminate the plywood with some nice looking 1/4" cherry or maple veneer plywood for a pretty face.

Or am I just asking for trouble again, somewhere?

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

#2

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

Scott in Montana

>Hello Henry,

A good part of our business is designing and building speaker cabinets for very custom installation. There are dozens of variables to consider. Might I first suggest that if you don't have it already, you buy RadioShack�s book on speaker building (if it's still available)or one of the other resource books that are out there. On outward appearance it looks a little dated, but as long as the laws of physics are intact, the information is good. This little $5 book along with a calculator that has a square root function and you'll be set to start. In regards to your multilayer cabinet construction; in theory it's good but in real life you may face delamination resulting in rattles. If weight isn't a consideration you might consider 1 1/8" MDF flooring material with a thin laminate on the outside and MDF cross-bracing on the inside.

If you�re building for music application you'll want to make it a sealed box if room allows. That little RadioShack book will show you the plusses and minuses of all the porting configurations.

If you have other questions, please feel free to e-mail me direct.

Good luck,

Scott

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

#3

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

Henry Higginbotham

>Thanks, Scott. I do have the RadioShack book, along with the Loudspeaker Design Cookbook and links to lots of seemingly good stuff on the Web. But for these, I was sort of planning on buying Madisound's MAD1259 sub kits and building 3.5 cubic foot sealed cabinets as they recommend. Those are pretty big cabinets that I don't really have the room for, but ya gotta do what ya gotta do.

I appreciate your comments, though, and may indeed send along a couple of other questions.

-Henry

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

#4

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

Scott in Montana

>Henry,

Doesn't that use a Foster Driver? If it's the one I'm thinking about, it's a solid design. I've heard nothing but good responses on the forums. Are you planning on building a pair of them and running them stereo? By building a sealed cabinet your impedence swing will be friendly making it easier to match amplification to.

Feel free to e-mail me anytime.

Scott

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

#5

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

Howard Acheson

>>> Now my plan is to laminate 18mm MDF to 12mm Russian birch plywood,

I would be careful about that. While both MDF and multiply plywood are considered to be stable, they do have slight changes in dimensions with changes in relative humidity. Each one will have a slightly different rate of change. Therefore, you will be very likely to have unequal stress between the two and the panels may be subject to warping.

I would either used thicker MDF or double up on the thinner MDF. I don't see any advantage to the Baltic birch. You can then laminate your 1/4" plywood to both sides. You want to keep a balanced build up of your panels. In other words, have the same structure on both sides of your MDF substrate.

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

#6

Re: Anyone see a problem with this construction?

Henry Higginbotham

>Thanks, Howard. The advantage to the 12mm Russian birch was, mainly, that I've got some. But you're at the heart of my question regarding the expansion of the dissimilar panels. I suppose I could also use veneered MDF, but the choices there are not very good. An A4 or B4 1/4" plywood panel seems to be available in much nicer veneers.

I was hoping someone had tried something similar, or knew of tables detailing the dimensional stability of each product. The largest panels will be around 17" x 32", or maybe a bit smaller.