Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

The Little Cedar Chest That Could

Posts

The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#1

The Little Cedar Chest That Could

David Yoho

>I thought I'd post some shots from a recent restoration job. Although I have many photos documenting my work on this project, to keep this short I'll show some of the before and after. A customer brought me a Lane cedar chest that belonged to her late mother and asked if I could do anything with it. After looking at the chest, my first reaction was one of horror! I've never seen anything with quite the damage this had. However, because of the sentimental value and the fact that it was built by Lane in Altavista, VA in 1936, I decided to take it on.

There were numerous problems with this old solid cedar chest. The front left foot was missing a piece in front but fortunately the mother had saved the piece and the customer found it while going through her things. The finish was totally hosed and there were many dings and scratches in the wood. Beyond these, there were some major and obvious problems I had to deal with.



The first major repair was going to be the two front corners of the lid, which for whatever reason seem to have been chopped off. Second, the molding that was attached below the lid on the front and ends was a mess too and would need to be replaced. Third, there was a big gouge in the roundover profile just next to the left missing corner.



I don't know how many restoration/refinishing jobs I've done where someone tried to make repairs. These are seldom done correctly and often times make things worse! The photo shows where someone repaired the loose hinge screws in the lid by using larger and longer screws. Then they took something and ground off the protruding ends.

To fix this, I made 1/4-inch plugs from cedar and inset them to cover the holes on the top surface. I glued in pieces of dowel from the under side to help hold new screws of the correct size. The hinges were really rough looking so I sanded them to bare metal on the show surfaces and gave them several coats of spray paint.



Reproducing the molding was one of the things that presented a challenge. Luckily, I found one of my architectural molding bits would work by using a segment of the whole profile. I actually think the new molding turned out very close to the old.



Repairing the corners of the lid required adding some new wood. To repair the gouged area on the left side I planed the spot down to a flat and glued on a piece of cedar. After working it down close to the level of the top with a plane, I cut fresh square miters on the front corners, and attached new triangular pieces of cedar. Because there was so little wood to work with, I decided on using a biscuit on each corner joint to add a little strength. Also, because this was basically and end grain to end grain connection, I used one other trick to try and strengthen the joint. I applied a thin coat of glue on each surface, let it almost dry, applied a fresh coat, and clamped the joint. The first coat of glue "sizes" or fills the pores of the end grain and allow the second layer of glue to bond better.

Here is a frontal shot of the completed cedar chest. I stripped the old finish, sanded, filled places too deep to sand out, dyed it with a color that equalized the extreme color difference of the white and red of the cedar, stained it to a walnut color, and finished with eight wiped coats of Waterlox.



Even though the corner repairs are visible, it's only due to the joint lines. The wood and finish used made things blend together so well that the joint lines are the only telltale sign something was done.

I used a combination of planes, rasps, and some sanding to shape the new cedar corner pieces and match the existing profile. Add massaging the old cedar exterior a little, cleaning up the old hardware, and a new finish, and this little chest looks almost new. I included full-sized photos of the before shots along with the history of the Lane Company that started in Altavista inside the chest. I will deliver this to my customer this week and I think she'll be amazed. At least I hope so!!

David



Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#2

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

Chuck in ND

>Nice job David, I've restored quite a few pieces in my time and it's allways a joy to see them come back to life and possibly last another 100 years. Ofcourse the hardcore antique people would say you just devalued the piece, I say the heck with them, in my opinion you saved it.

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#3

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>From trash to treasure; very nice job.

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#4

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello David,

You performed a masterful restoration. I really liked doing cedar chests. They are always multi-generational and sre always treasures. I especially like the corner treatment.

George

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#5

Ellis Walentine

Very nice, David

Ellis Walentine

>Did you sand the inside to rejuvenate the cedar smell?

Ellis

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#6

Re: Very nice, David

David Yoho

>Yes, I hand sanded the inside mainly for that reason. However, after checking it over time, I ended up having to help it a little with the addition of some Cedar Oil.

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#7

Cedar oil

Ellils Walentine

>I tried a bottle of cedar oil once and didn't know which species of cedar it came from. Does yours smell like a cedar chest?

Ellis

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#8

a successful silk purse from a sow's ear!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>as we say on the farm. That was an impressive repair. I have my mothers, circa 1940, and it needs new lacquer but no significant wood damage.

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#9

JL

Re: Nice "Save"..

JL

>Were the feet damaged? I wasn't sure.

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#10

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

Fred Davis

>It's jobs like that, that separate assemblers from craftsmen .

Very unusual right end , looks like two book matched boards with a diagonal 1 by 3

You made a friend for life out of your client,

FredD

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#11

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

Michael Bush

>I just wrote you an email, David, then came here to see what was up, and here is this promising thread!

This is very nice. How did you find working with the cedar? It is so unstable. I have a wardrobe that my grandfather had built from cedar trees on his farm. I took it apart while I could still control the disintegration, and marked every board and half-board (where they split) so I could put it all back together. Now, fifteen or twenty years later, the whole business is in J's father's barn, waiting for me to come get it and put it all back together. I've left it alone all this time because I don't have much confidence in cedar as a furniture wood and don't want to waste my time.

So have you figured out a way to keep cedar in one piece?

MDB

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#12

Re: Cedar oil

David Yoho

>To me it smells like the aromatic cedar I used.

David

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#13

Re: Nice "Save"..

David Yoho

>Only damage to the feet was the one on the front I mentioned. Luckily, I had the piece that came off and was able to glue it back. Also that foot was missing one of two screws that held it on. I replaced it and all is well.

David

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#14

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

David Yoho

>Michael, you're right. When I went to purchase a little piece of aromatic cedar for the repairs, I had to look through a pile before finding a piece that was straight and clear enough for my purposes.

So have you figured out a way to keep cedar in one piece?

Yes, assemble it quickly! I'm not feeling too positive about what you'll find whenever you go back to the farm for those pieces that have been unassembled. I wish you luck.

David

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#15

Wow! Nice work!

Tony - Memphis

>

Re: The Little Cedar Chest That Could

#16

Thanks All

David Yoho

>Thanks for the comments everyone posted or sent via email. This was a challenging project but one that I had fun doing. For me, this one was special for several reasons. First, because of the sentimental value for the customer and second, because it provided a chance to bring back a piece of furniture that was built here in Virginia back in 1936.

Thanks again,

David