Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Respirator opinion

Posts

Respirator opinion

#1

Respirator opinion

Guy

>After having been away from woodworking for a few years I'm starting back up and of course protecting my lungs is an issue. I have a good half-face respirator with new filters but am curious about the powered respirators. As far as actual protection, if fitted properly is there a difference? I would assume if they fit properly and have the same class of filter the protection would be the same but there would of course be the differences in comfort, convenience, etc. I used to use the Dustfoe (like miners wear) but now use a double cannister version from 3M. My wife ( a scroll saw nut )uses the Dust-be-gone and I am trying to convince her to use a respirator also. We are running a Jet air cleaner and a single stage dust collector but will be upgrading to a cyclone by the end of summer (that will be another thread) Any thoughts, opinions etc are very welcome. Thanks folks...

Re: Respirator opinion

#2

Re: a Jet air cleaner

North of the Border

>a Jet air cleaner - I suppose this is the air filtration system. You didn't mention about the size of your shop and its filtration capacity (in terms of cfm). Also for the dust collector, use 1 micro bags for protection. You also didn't say how much woodworking (saw dust generated) you do. I'm not expert in air quality but I can say you're far better equipped than many shop owners ....

Re: Respirator opinion

#3

JL

Re: Respirator opinion

JL

>A good half face respirator will provide as much protection as many of the common powered respirators at relatively less expense. The big difference is comfort and convenience. The powered ones that I have tried have been more comfortable and relatively easy to slip on/off.

A good half face (such) as 3M also offers you the ability to switch cartridge types - though you probably won't need to. An organic vapor cartridge usually suits - unless you are doing stripping and require a halogenated solvent cartridge.

Your described set-up is better than most by far.

Re: Respirator opinion

#4

Re: Respirator opinion

Jim Dillon

>Guy,

Can't give you any first-hand experience with the canister/powered types as I just use a simple 3M mask (with valve) for sanding. However, you might also post your question (if you haven't already) on the turning board/forum as it is my understanding that turners use the canister/powered types often. Just a thought.

Jim