Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT: Wal Mart exit searches

Posts

OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#1

William Falberg

OT: Wal Mart exit searches

William Falberg

>On this 26th day of July, 2008; the first day of the rest of my life; I vow to never again give up my Fourth Amendment rights at the exit doors of a Wal Mart store.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#2

The Fourth Amendment

Chuck W

>The Fourth Amendment guards against unreasonable searches and seizures, and was designed as a response to the controversial writs of assistance (a type of general search warrant), which were a significant factor behind the American Revolution. Toward that end, the amendment specifies that judicially sanctioned search and arrest warrants must be supported by probable cause and be limited in scope according to specific information supplied by a person (usually a peace officer) who has sworn by it and is therefore accountable to the issuing court.

I think Walmart like to push the envelope sometimes. But that said where do the rights of the store to conduct business as they see fit begin and where do the rights of the individual begin?

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#3

William Falberg

Re: The Fourth Amendment

William Falberg

>At the cash register.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#4

Re: The Fourth Amendment

Charlie Self

>In the near past, I've gotten a strong impression that the store's rights end once money changes hands. At that point, it's up to them to detain you and call the cops if they believe you've swiped something.

Given the number of light-fingered citizens we have in the U.S., I can't really blame any store for being suspicious, but at the same time, I think (and I ain't no lawyer) they're laying themselves open to a lawsuit if they do detain you and search your goods without permission.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#5

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

Howard Norman

>I take it that you don't shop at Costco. Costco has always had a search at the exits. At WalMart it varies by individual store. Stores here in Prescott, AZ have none while some of the stores in the Phoenix area do have searches depending on the neighborhood where they are located. As I recall KMart stores have searches. I haven't been in a KMart, and never was a heavy KMart shopper, so I can't be sure that that.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#6

William Falberg

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

William Falberg

>I never was a big customer of the borgs, but now I'm a total non-customer. It won't affect them at all but makes me feel better that I'm doing my small part to resist the erosion of our individual dignity. As we progress toward globalization I suspect we'll see more of these assaults on the consumers' rights. I haven't been violated by an American business - yet. So I'll shop Main Street henceforth. It feels better.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#7

Steven Antonucci

I've never been searched?

steve antonucci

>I must be doing something right...

Steve

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#8

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

allen heath

>I never allow myself to be searched, as i believe it is a violation of my constitutional rights (and it is). the only time a retail store may search or dtain you is if they have witnessed you do something that warrants it ( conceal an item on your person, etc.) if they ask you to be searched and you decline there is nothing they can do escept call the police. If you are a law abiding citizen (and im sure that you are, then then is no worry. when they attempt to stop me, even if their exit alarm sounds, i just keep going. I was in law enforcement for many years, and know my rights, and yours too. just because you are in a bad neighborhood does not diminish the constitution.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#9

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

steve mackay

>Doesn't the fourth apply to government agencies ? If it were posted on private property isn't a search legal much the same as "right to refuse service" ? Right to search is posted on millitary instalations and once I'm informed its all on me. I'm, REALLY, not trying to to stir the pot, really, just wondering. If they searched me it'd be the last time I darkened their doorway !

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#10

William Falberg

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

William Falberg

>I don't really care if they're "legal" or not. I just won't darken their doorway again with my random shadow. That's wihin MY rights.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#11

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

Ralph Turney

>I feel I've walked into the middle of a conversation...what happened to start this thread??? I've never been searched leaving any store and wonder to what extent this search was conducted?

Always vote with your dollars!

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#12

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

Howard Norman

>Normally it is a "search" of the bags or your basket as you leave the store. Anything else would require a probable cause that you were shop lifting. As I said earlier Costco has done this of everyone as long as I have known of Costco and it has occurred in every Costco store that I have been in. My experience with WalMart is that it occurs in certain neighborhoods, probable where shop lifting has been prevalent.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#13

William Falberg

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

William Falberg

>There are lots of other stores in Grand Junction. Wal Mart is the only one that stops you on the way out to go through the same bag they just packed themselves 20 feet away and demand to see the receipt they just gave you two minutes ago. It's happened three times now and I'm tired of it. I'm sixty seven years old, have a high forehead, gray hair, and two distinct eyebrows. I don't wear a backpack and I shave most days. I wear clean Levis and a T-shirt that fits-with no man-bags or fanny packs to arouse suspicion. I have a concealed carry permit which I seldom exercise and a good reputation for not shoplifting. They have absolutely NO reason to suspect me of anything. If Grand Junction is a "bad neighborhood", the whole country's in trouble and stopping me won't help it. That's just me on a rant. I won't fly either; for the same reason. My sons are programmed to accept this kind of personal invasion but I'm just old-fashioned enough to resent it.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#14

You guys must sure be a suspicious looking bunch!

John in NM

>I've never had any trouble, but I don't go to Walmart much. I believe Costco is checking that their checker hasn't made mistakes. Goes back to the days when it was Price Club and they did all the ringing up by numbers rather than barcode. IIRC, they had one guy reading off about an 8 digit stock number and another entering it in the register. Made my head swim, they were so fast and furious with the digits.

So how do we feel about the automated security devices? Aren't they just the same thing? You know, those things that set off alarms and lights and embarrass the heck out of you when the checker forgets to de-activate the little security strip in the packaging.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#15

Re: You guys must sure be a suspicious looking bun

Howard Norman

>>I believe Costco is checking that their checker hasn't made mistakes.<

At Costco it goes both ways I believe. That you haven't put something in the basket after checking out at the register and that the checker hasn't missed something or double charged you. In most cases I notice that they just count the number of items in the bastket at Costco. Yes, the stores in Phoenix were Price Club before Costco bought it out but I have heard that Costco was doing it at their stores before that.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#16

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

Fred Davis

>whoops , flying, now there is a sore spot for me and my wife.

Without going into a long rant about treatment of us on

our very last flight, it is interesting to us to ponder the level crap must rise to before the American public decides to forego the madness surrounding commercial flying.

Which in many cases can get you from A to B only slightly faster then if you had driven in your private car sans waits , searches and fee nickel and dimeing, not to mention the pleasure of having your luggage get to your destination at the same time you do, in the shape it started out in.

FredD

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#17

My very odd Costco test

Michael Dresdner

>We always wondered what they were doing when they draw a line down your receipt leaving Costco. I figured it is so you can't reuse the receipt, but one day we decided to test it.

A friend came shopping with us. We bought stuff and so did he. We each paid separately and got two receipts. We put all the stuff in one basket. When we got to the door, we showed only one receipt, for about half the items in the basket. The person at the door marked a line on it, handed it back, and said "Have a nice day" as we walked out.

Sloppiness, or is the whole thing a psychological sham to encourage you to be honest?

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#18

Re: My very odd Costco test

Howard Norman

>Interesting! I would say a very careless Costco employee. On a few occasions at Costco I have seen the very opposite of your experience where every item in the cart was checked against the checkout printout.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#19

Even worse (or better)

Bill Howatt

>While talking to the "checker" at the Costco door about the weather, I handed him my receipt. He drew the line on it and handed it back with the usual, "Have a nice day." As we went through the door I realized that my last gasoline purchase pump receipt had a black line drawn on it!

Bill

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#20

"Call the Cops while I block this doorway & wait"

Art Silva

>

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#21

Lee Gordon

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

Lee Gordon

>I have solved this problem by never making use of the Wal-Mart entrance door.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#22

Violated?

wilbur

>"On this 26th day of July, 2008; the first day of the rest of my life; I vow to never again give up my Fourth Amendment rights at the exit doors of a Wal Mart store....

I never was a big customer of the borgs, but now I'm a total non-customer. It won't affect them at all but makes me feel better that I'm doing my small part to resist the erosion of our individual dignity. As we progress toward globalization I suspect we'll see more of these assaults on the consumers' rights. I haven't been violated by an American business - yet. So I'll shop Main Street henceforth. It feels better. "

Last time I checked, Wal-Mart is an American business. It might be too late for you.

In the current political climate, with an emphasis on the deregulation of business, the Bill of Rights is seen to be only applicable to what government agencies can and cannot do. It doesn't apply to the private sector at all.

Non-disclosure agreements could be seen as a violation of the right to free speech (First Amendment), yet they are commonplace. Companies routinely place limitations on what employees can and cannot say on public forums.

If you look at the license agreement for any piece of software you buy, it is clear that the software publisher can revoke your right to use that software for nearly any reason, in effect unilaterally deciding that you are in violation of that contract. Credit card companies reserve the right to change the terms of your contract at any time, for whatever reason they wish. Again, usually, they can deem you a worse credit risk if they are looking for an excuse. These could be seen as violations of due process (Fifth Amendment).

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#23

Re: Violated?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> In the current political climate, with an emphasis on the deregulation of business, the Bill of Rights is seen to be only applicable to what government agencies can and cannot do.

That's always been the case.

> It doesn't apply to the private sector at all.

Never has.

> Non-disclosure agreements could be seen as a violation of the right to free speech (First Amendment), yet they are commonplace. Companies routinely place limitations on what employees can and cannot say on public forums.

Agreements are just that. If a party agrees to non-disclosure, the government has little to say about it. The Constitution does not apply to private agreements.

> If you look at the license agreement for any piece of software you buy, it is clear that the software publisher can revoke your right to use that software for nearly any reason, in effect unilaterally deciding that you are in violation of that contract. Credit card companies reserve the right to change the terms of your contract at any time, for whatever reason they wish. Again, usually, they can deem you a worse credit risk if they are looking for an excuse. These could be seen as violations of due process (Fifth Amendment).

No, they couldn't, unless it was the government making those agreements. Private agreements aren't governed by the Constitution.

The foregoing are common misconception of freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution. All that document says is that the government won't abridge those freedoms. It says nothing at all about what a private person or even a business may do to abridge them, particularly when in accord with an agreement between those parties. Don't like the credit card's agreement to change your rates? You are free to shop elsewhere for credit.

To put it another way, your freedom extends only to the end of my nose or my front door. The Constitution does not guarantee your freedom of speech in my house, for example.

Rod

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#24

William Falberg

Re: Violated?

William Falberg

>" Private agreements aren't governed by the Constitution."

The consumer can, however, challenge the enforcibility of private contracts based on constitutional rights, IIRC. And many states have "consumers' rights" laws to protect consumers from unreasonable contracts.

The OP was not meant to start a revolution nor nor to influence Wal Mart's policies. I can't change that or any of the other consumer-abuse things you mentioned, which WERE right-on BTW. All I can do is stop shopping there. Ya'll are free to do as you please. I feel better knowing I'll nevr be insulted by THEM again. I'll look for someone else to insult me. My future is that little bit brighter for it.

Re: OT: Wal Mart exit searches

#25

Re: Violated?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> All I can do is stop shopping there.

I haven't been in a w-m for a long time and don't plan on changing that status. In addition to all the other ills that have been discussed, I don't like being part of the majority of the demographic who go there—at least around here. Let's just say, it always makes me think there's a carnival in town, or a trailer park nearby. Don't need to be lumped in with that group.

It's sort of like noticing that the majority of the ads in the TV show you're watching are ED or STD products. I don't need to be part of that target demographic, either.

Rod