Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

So, how much should I charge him?

Posts

So, how much should I charge him?

#1

JL

So, how much should I charge him?

JL

>Jeff wanted me to build him a shaving mule. He is a friend who doesn't really have any shop equipment to speak of.

I've got to drive it down the mountain to get it to the transportation to his place. I've got about $30 in materials and about 10-15 hours in it.

Thoughts? I was thinking ~$200. TIA.


img

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#2

Whatever the original agreement was

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#4

Bart Goldberg

For friends - no more than material cost

Bart Goldberg

>

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#5

Lee Grindinger

How about a trade?

Lee Grindinger

>A mule has few uses other than in the making of chairs and such. Surely you could use another chair.

Lee

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#6

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

John McGaw

>Always a difficult question, especially with a friend. But let's see: $200 - $30 for materials divided by 10 hours gives us $17.00 per hour for labor. Of course this does not include the expense of transportation of materials and of the final product. If you actually spent 15 hours on the project you are talking $11.33 per hour. What do you think your skills and time are worth on an hourly basis?

As a reminder, the US minimum wage was just increased to $6.55 and some states and cities already have minimums that far exceed that. I would think that a project involving real craftsmanship and talent would demand something _far_ beyond that minimal level even for a friend. The other alternative, and the one I sometimes fall back on, is to simply make gifts of items I create but on those occasions this would never be something that I was actually asked to build -- a gift is always something that is _my_ idea.

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#7

Re: the gift idea is the one

North of the Border

>that I'd vote in support of - unless this friend of yours is a fair-weather one. Just sign and date the piece and hand it to your friend as a gift and it'll sure make his day.

If there isn't any prior agreement about the charge for the job, to be fair (no pun intended) to your friend, you should talk to him first before you put a price tag on it. (To avoid any misunderstanding, if I intend to charge someone for something I'll do him whether to cover my raw materials and / or labor, I'll raise the subject of charge well before I begin my work.)

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#8

Re:Rich guy poor guy?

North of the Border

>"Jeff wanted me to build him a shaving mule. He is a friend who doesn't really have any shop equipment to speak of."

Why doesn't he have any shop equipment? Just starting out? Can't afford it?

If either of the two is the reason (and he isn't a fair weather friend and there's no prior agreement and talk about charges for your job), give it to him as a gift. he'll remember your good deed as a friend.

On the other hand, if financially you really need to recover your costs / labor (or if you think he can more than afford to pay you), ask first what your intention was when you took up the job - did you intend to offer your friend help with your skills or make some extra income on the side? Your intention will affect how much you're to charge.

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#9

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

Howard Norman

>Unless he offered to pay you the "going rate" before hand just sign the piece and give it to him. It is too easy to lose a friendship over a misunderstanding about something like this.

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#10

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Send it on it's way and wish him a Merry Christmas.

Pretty simple question..

Rob

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#11

Steven Antonucci

Favor for a friend or commissioned work?

steve antonucci

>I make tools for friends and just give them away. If it cost you $15 for parts, I'm sure Jeff can find some way to "pay it back" in the future. The cost of the materials is negligible compared to the value of a friend.

In short, I work at $0/hr for my friends...

Steve

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#12

Re: Unless you are WW for the money

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I wouldn't charge anything. That is unless you and your friend had an agreement before you started. I personally will not charge one red cent for any of my work. I built my shop and bought all my equipment with one thing in mind, that is to have a hobby I enjoy. I build what I want to build, when I want to build. IMHO, if I started taking money for my hobby, it would no longer be my "hobby". It would then become a profession. I would feel obligated to build items I really didn't want to build and work to some schedule. As I have spent a great deal (to me at least) of money and time to acquire my shop and equipment, I really don't want it to become something I feel is a "job". The only exception to my "rule" is that I will allow someone to purchase/replace material used on their "project". Often that is only done after they insist.

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#13

If hes a good freind . . .

steve mackay

>and $30.00 of materials I think he got a free favor with best wishes.

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#14

JL

Re: I make my own chairs.

JL

>So a trade of that sort would be coals to Newcastle :).

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#15

JL

Re:Rich guy poor guy?

JL

>I don't know why he doesn't have shop equipment. He's been coming up to the Folk School for a couple of years now. I've gathered that space is somewhat of an issue.

As far as being rich? Heck, he's employed - I'm retired. Financially, I do need to recover my costs - gas is getting cheaper.

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#16

JL

Re: Thanks for your responses...

JL

>I got a check in the mail today w/o even asking for it. Now I have to deliver it.

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#17

Re: Thanks for your responses...So?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>JL,

Since the beginning of this was how much to charge.......

Care to share the amount?????

Bob (in_NJ)

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#18

Re: Think he is reading WC?

Earl

>

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#19

JL

Re: Thanks for your responses...So?

JL

>He sent me a check for $175. We hadn't really discussed price. He just said he wanted one and would give me a check. Well - it showed up, so I'm happy :). Now I can afford the gas to go down the mountain and even have enough to do some shopping :).

Let's see, what do I need...

Re: So, how much should I charge him?

#21

Funny....

Tony - Memphis

>I seem to always get requests from friends, aquaintances, and co-workers for some odd thing they need to fit a specific space or somehting they found at the store and it was way overpriced (in their opinion - afterall Norm could buidl this in a 1/2 hour). But its always follwed with..."Oh, I'll pay you for it!" I don't work for money. Its a hobby and a passion that I don't want to cloud by involving money and requirements and expectations. I love makin gthings for folks. Especially things they will use. Come to think of it, in the 14 years I've been at it, I've never accepted any money. My wife, on the other hand, is an artist and she gets a kick out of selling her art. She paints for fun, but has sold a few paitings. I think it validates her work to her. I don't need that I guess. Interesting how its all different for everybody. Its funny, I really try and challenge myself with each project and my last project was an 18th century lowboy with carving and turning and lots of hand work. Quite a challenge for me. But, I get quite a thrill building a bird feeder that I get to watch in action from my shop window. Then another when my sister-in-law requests a meal worm feeder like that one I built for myself(that is really a piece of junk I threw together just to see if the bluebirds would eat from it - they didn't much, but my carolina wrens just love it). Reward comes in different forms.

In regards to the original question, it ain't none of my business! But, if it was me, I'd ask for him to return something that he makes using it, or I would ask that he pass the favor when there is something he can do for someone else and ask them to do the same. Getting the money back for materials and gas would be good.

Tony