Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Fine points of lacquer repair

Posts

Fine points of lacquer repair

#1

Ellis Walentine

Fine points of lacquer repair

Ellis Walentine

>I have a curious finishing problem. My late mother-in-law left behind a rather valuable old Steinway baby grand with a veneered mahogany case. It was refinished quite nicely about twenty years ago, but since then the light coming in through an adjacent north window has bleached out the wood on that side of the case and has also prompted the lacquer to be a little rough to the touch. We want to sell the piano and need to address this finish problem short of a total refinishing job.

My instinct is to first kiss off the roughness with some very fine lubricated paper, probably 320 or 400 grit, and then mix a little dye stain into some padding lacquer -- essentially making my own toner -- and gradually match the color while building the finish by padding. I don't want to strip anything or do any amount of sanding to try to get back to bare wood, because I don't want to risk sanding through the veneer.

Does this sound like a reasonable approach, or would you suggest another method?

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#2

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

David Yoho

>Ellis, I'm betting you posted this to engage folks in a discussion. I also bet you know you could get an absolute answer from either Michael Dresdner or Kevin Hancock as to how to proceed.

Your initial plan of attack sound right to me but I don't begin to know enough about lacquer and the pitfalls that could occur and this is not a piece I'd want to experiment on. I'll be watching this to see what folks have to say.

David

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#3

Re: 1 Vote

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Against the pad.

Leveling the existing film is, I think, a must else you'll have internal visual anomalies in the lacquer that will pitch the color off in spots.

However, I would vote to go to either a good mini-gun or an air brush to apply your tone. Unless you're better at padding than anyone I've ever even heard of, it will be neigh-on impossible to feather out the added color at the edges of the sun-bleached area, whereas with spray application it will be rather easy. Then, once you have the color matched, you can over-coat with clear and rub the whole job out to a sheen that matches the existing.

This, of course, is one of the beauties of a true lacquer finish.

mm

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#4

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

Fred Davis

>Well Kevin Hancock would certainly be the guy to ask.

There's the reamalgamation process, but it probably wouldn't care care of the loss of color.

FredD

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#5

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

les winter

>Hi Ellis.

I took a quick cruise over to steinway.com to see what they say about refinishing. Although there is some small amount of information on the website, a call to the factory might not be such a bad thing.

I don't know much about the finish on your piano, but they do, even though it was worked on previously.

By the way, you may be able to check to see if the piano was registered when orginally sold and get a little history about it.

best of luck

les

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#6

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Les

Ellis Walentine

>Yes, we've got some historical info (made in 1907, restored in the early '80s), but since it was refinished once by a local firm, I don't know that Steinway would be much help with finishing advice at this point.

Spraying isn't particularly an option, as the piano is in a living room and will have to remain there, at least for the time being. I suppose I could rig up a fan and try to blow the fumes out the window, and use drop cloths and temporary plastic tenting. If padding is going to be that difficult, spraying might be worth it at any cost.

I have not spoken to Kevin yet, but he's definitely on my list.

Thanks, everyone for the advice.

Ellis

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#7

Re: Fumes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Think you're going to be venting regardless of method. The rest is a matter of masking and drop cloths. A couple of 20" box fans will do nicely as the vapor concentration will be pretty thin. I actually did a similar deal with shellac on a friend's mahogany game table [was too big and too much hassle to disassemble/move outside] using a top-cup mini HVLP (Sato gun) at about 12psi and light on the material. There was very little overspray to worry about, but I did have to retard the shellac to get it to flow out and level. Don't know the size of your damaged area, but the one I did was about 44" round. Fans handled the alcohol just fine on a summer day.

mm

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#8

retarding shellac

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>What do you retard shellac with for spraying?

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#9

Ellis Walentine

Hmm

Ellis Walentine

>I'd be spraying the whole straight side of the case, maybe 5 ft. long and 16" high, and yes I did figure on venting in any event. Now, if I can find my spray gun. Last I saw it, my son was shooting ceramic glaze with it. I might have to get a new gun for the piano job.

Ellis

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#10

Re: retarding shellac

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Drop or two of pure gum turpentine does the trick.

mm

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#11

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>There are other retarders, SolarLux comes to mind, but I don't know their formulations so I shy away from anything that might give me hassles with a waterborne top coat. The turps has always done well for me, and I've not had any issues with top coats. I use shellac as both a sealer/binder and a toning medium with Transtint dyes.

mm

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#12

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

Kevin Hancock

>Those vintage Steinway grands were very pretty pianos. The mahogany cuts were outstanding.

Repair to sunlight damage is a little daunting, but improvements are very possible. Un-doing the damage without refinishing is pretty impossible, as much of the damage in the color of the piano is actually in the finish and is seen as a yellow semi-opaque faded and cracked coating. Results of this repair process will vary depending on the level of damage.

What I've done in the past is to smooth the surface with 400-600 finishing paper. I like the 3M 216U gold paper and use it dry. If there is any wax on the surface, a wash with naphtha might be in order. With the surface clean, pad on a NGR dye mixed to desired color. I've used solorlux for the task, but Mohawk and others make similar products. You will have to apply in quick passes and get a feel for what it takes to amalgamate the surface without getting it too wet and gooey.. The colorant should bite into the fine cracks and crazes and mask much of the yellowing. Apply only what is needed to get the surface looking better without getting the surface softened too much. Sorry I can't describe in writing exactly how much that is, but I don't like to get the surface too soft as it will stink to high heaven and take a long time to dry. Give this step overnight to dry.

By the way, you will need good air movement in the room where you are working and use gloves for hand protection.

Once the color looks better, French polish the surface with shellac. I like the mix in Stars, LacFrench for this task, but again, you can choose a French polishing mix, based in shellac, that you might prefer. The first few passes will be the more challenging as the solvents will be pulling some of the colorant out of the finish. Don't worry that your pad is collection dye, but do try to avoid streaking the colorant and creating a muddy mess. Make a quick pass over the surface and let it dry for 15-20 minutes and make repeat passes as needed. I use straight long fast passes to apply the FP and gauge my pressure based o nthe wetness of the pad. As the finish builds, you can use less wetness on the pad and burnish the surface to get rid of the streaks in the surface.

I hope this is helpful. The combination of the dye and shellac will work nice to soften and re-melt the finish, but will only mask the sun damage.

Kevin Hancock

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#13

Ellis Walentine

Thinning NGR stain

Ellis Walentine

>I wish I could afford to have you refinish the whole piano for us, but this advice is just what I was looking for. I've used SolarLux and Mohawk NGR stains quite often in the past (I also used a lot of Constantine's NGR), but I'm afraid they will be too concentrated for this job so I'd like to be able to thin my mixture. I never figured out precisely the right thinner to use with any of them, but as I recall, they all had different thinners, i.e., I couldn't mix different brands to get the color I wanted. Any help on that? Or should I use it full strength?

Ellis

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#14

Re: Thinning NGR stain

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I would think that lacquer thinner would thin an NGR stain. The stain will have available a MSDS sheet and that will tell the solvent system. If it is not obvious from that list what to use send me the solvent list and I can suggest something. I will guarantee that either toluene or acetone will work, and probably either.

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#15

Ellis Walentine

Solvents

Ellis Walentine

>Yes, I recall trying all those, Bill, plus a few others, and yes they all have varying degrees of effectiveness with the different stain porducts, but the dyes themselves have different solvencies in different solvents. A water-based dye that is one color in water may be quite another in a different solvent, such as alcohol. I think the same is true with NGR dyes. Coming up with predictable color using different manufacturers' products is a lot like alchemy: Try it and see if it works.

I'll let you know what I find out.

Ellis

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#16

Explanation of dye color shift. Its irrelevant

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>All that is important is that the diluting solvent dissolve the dye. The final color the dye will impart to the wood, or finish, will not be affected by the solvent the dye was dissolved/diluted in.

Indeed, when a dye is dissolved the dye molecules interact with the molecules of solvent, which alters the electronic structure of the dye molecule, which in turn can change the dye hue(color) in the solution. There are some neat demonstrations where a certain dye in one solvent is red while in another it is blue, etc. In your case the extremes in color shift will be water or alcohol on one end and mineral spirits at the other extreme- with toluene and acetone in between.

However, these color shifts are not permanent. They will change as the solvent changes by dilution or evaporation. Once the diluting solvent has evaporated the dye hue will be only dependent on what it remains dissolved in, in your case lacquer or shellac.

Bottom line.... dilute the dye in whatever keeps it in solution and is miscible in the original dye solvent. You must spray it on the piece to know what the final color will be.

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#17

Re: Point of Confusion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Kevin,

I'm confused about your posted advice because Ellis stated the existing finish is lacquer, and you seem to be describing repairs using shellac and alcohol-based NGR to reamalgamate the existing coating, and then FP to final. I think I missed something here. Could you clear this up for me? I made my suggestions based upon Ellis using lacquer, toned and clear. Never occurred to me to use shellac to repair a lacquer finish.

Thanks

mm

Re: Fine points of lacquer repair

#18

Re: Thinning NGR stain

Fred Davis

>Ellis,

I remember when Kevin first started refinishing Pianos and how we used to kid him about finish techniques, but I can say without a doubt he told you exactly right about NGR's and Shellac.

Look on a can of Solarlux or Mohawk NGR stain and it will tell you the correct solvent , most often Alcohol.

The right shade is a matter of experimenting .

If you have Mac "Mohawks" address from the chat , he is another expert at it.

FredD