Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Posts

OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#1

OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Dan Mitchell

>We live in the Seattle area on a lot with a lot of mature conifers. Unlike what I was used to in the mid-west, where I had a couple oaks & maples which would drop there leaves once a year, these things seem to be more like the arboreal equivalent of cats, shedding constantly. Consequently, the gutters are perpetually loaded with needles. I've seen a wide variety of "gutter guards" over the years, from fine screens to the type that overlap all but the last 1/2" or so of the gutter, it has always seemed to me they'd either plug quickly, or overflow easily in a heavy rain. Living in an area know for its rainfall, this is even more of a concern. Has anyone had any personal experiences with these systems, especially the "do it yourself" variety, and especially with conifers?

TIA

Dan

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I've had a product called "Gutter Loov" on my house and shop for several years. It works very well on oak and maple droppings - including the little 'helicopter' seeds from the maples. It installs under the first course of shingles, and attaches to the outer edge of the gutter. Louvres on the front catch the water, and everything else washes/blows off. I haven't had to clean gutters since I got the Gutter Loov. Cost me $7.50 per foot, installed, about three years ago.

Jim D.

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#3

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Dan arrowsmith

>I put leaf guard on a couple of years ago as the gutters were too high to clean. So far worked fine,and we have whirly's galore. added advantage downspouts are bigger than the normal ones and handle downpours better.

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#4

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Pete LaBelle

>Had an authentic Gutter Guard salesman come to the house one day just for kicks. Showed their product and showed a video of old people falling off ladders as they cleaned their old gutters. For my early 70's vintage ranch style house, with a straight run across the back side, and a diversion around a porch on the front, he quoted me $4600 for the project ! Neighbor with similar house had regular gutters installed for about $600 from a local contractor. Obviously, I didn't buy his product. I have seen a similar product in the big-box stores, but still haven't persued any gutters, for that matter.

I get a charge out of these gutter salesmen. "Oh....we use one piece gutters so there are no joints to leak". Idiot. Explain to me why a drip proof gutter makes sense on the ground, when 1" away, it's raining ? ?

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#5

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

John K Jordan

>At my last house I had the type that was a curved mesh, clipped onto the the gutter with little hinge clips. I had this only on the "high" side of the house. I had to clean the non-guarded gutters at least twice a year. I cleaned the others once in 25 years.

JKJ

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#6

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. Yeah I recall the maple whirlygigs from when I lived in Columbus. Loved palying with them when I was a kid, as a gutter-cleaning adult, not so much. Still I have to think in terms of gutter-screen clogging potential, pine needles may be worse. Plus there appears to be no "season".

I'm not sure the linear footage of gutters on this house, but it's pretty extensive, on multiple levels etc.

Dan

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#7

Bart Goldberg

Funny story!

Bart Goldberg

>

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#8

Touchy subject

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I bought a few lengths of this white plastic perforated gutter guard stuff at HD a couple of years ago and installed it on one section of gutter to see how well it worked.

I had to lift up the edge of shingles to get it under them. It was easy to install, and it actually worked quite well. It stopped the leaves from getting in, and most of the pne needles, but it let in alot of the buds and other smaller stuff that the trees drop.

I put it on section that was easy to reach so I could see how effective it was. I have some gutters that I can reach from a 2' ladder, other getters that I need to climb an 8' ladder to reach and then a few others that are REALLy hard to reach, even with a 30' ladder. So you can image that some of the gutters get cleaned out every 3-4 months, other sections get cleaned once or twice a year, and some other sections get clenaed... well, maybe once every other year ;)

Well..... we have these "people" that drive around the neighborhood and the "wife" part of the team comes knocking at our door every few months.... and with their toothless grin say: "my husband and I just cleaned your neighbor's gutters and since we're here we thought you might like us to clean yours".

I always say "no thanks" and clean them myself and spend the $50 taking the familiy out to eat at a erstaurent or some other treat. But one day last winter, shortly after my wife's brother fell off a ladder and spent 12 months in hospital, my wife decided to give me a break and pay them to do it. I think she paid them $100. I wasn't pleased. So what did they do?

The removed the plastic gutter guards and left them on the ground.

They cleaned out the lowest gutters.

THey cleaned out most of the middle gutters.

And then I foud out later they didn't even clean out the highest gutters.

I hate people like that.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#9

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Justin Szeliga

>If you go to a roofing supply house you can get a pretty good product that'll install fairly easily under the first course. I installed it on a clients place & it seems to be doing pretty well even in a heavily wooded lot that rains leaves, needles & debris all year round.

Peace

Justn

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#10

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Dan Mitchell

>Justin - Thanks for the tip. Do you happen to recall exactly what you bought, brand name, trade name, etc?

Dan

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#11

Re: Touchy subject

Dan Mitchell

>Mark - Your situation sounds very much like mine, in terms of gutter placement. I know what you mean about "hating people like that". I may just be very unlucky, but in my personal experience, virtually everyone I've paid for a service has been a "person like that" to one degree or another, including 3 gutter people at my last location. Which is why even for jobs I hate to do (like cleaning gutters) I find I'm very reluctant to pay someone & end up doing it myself.

One exception to the "people like that" generality was a handyman who I hired to do a lot of varied work on my last house, before selling it. Unfortunately, he would absolutely refuse to do anything on a ladder, beyond that needed for inside painting on this house w/8' ceilings. His father had fallen off an 8' ladder working on his own house, and actually died as a result. Makes scaling that 30' monster even more daunting...

Dan

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#12

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Barry Irby

>Dan,

I have used a product called "GuttaGard" for years. Works well, but I no longer have pines. Its a strip of solid metal shaped with a rolled edge. The flat edge tucks under the shingles and the round edge sits just above the front of the gutter in some clips they provide. Looks like a roof over the gutters. The trash rolls off the edge, but the water curls around into the gutter. It was less than a buck a foot.

Also, there are Englert Gutters that work on the same principle, but cost several times what regular gutters cost, but are guaranteed not to clog. Really nice setup, Google them.

And then there is Flip Clean. Ordinary looking gutters that sit in hinges. you turn them over occasionally with a stick they provide to dump them. Very satisfying to actually see they are empty.

Somebody is making a very coarse foam insert that fills the gutter. Water runs under it but the trash washes off. Not convinced on that one. Looks like a seed germinating factory to me.

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

#13

Re: OT: recommendations for "Gutter Guard"

Charley

>I have a white PVC gutter cover that I bought from Lowes for about $2/ft almost 5 years ago. It fits under the bottom row of shingles and extends out to cover the whole gutter and snaps over the front edge. There is a curved slot in it for the water to drop into the gutter but the leaves, pine needles and significantly large tree debris slide across it and onto the ground. I used to have to clean my gutters 3 or 4 times a year and haven't had to clean them at all since buying these. Sorry, but I don't have a brand name, but I do know that Lowes still carries them as I bought a replacement piece this spring (a wind casualty). The trees in my yard are mixed pine and hardwoods.