>Are there any masons or folks who've laid their own brick walks? I live in Wisconsin (not notorious for its gentle winters). My wife and I have decided to replace our deteriorating walk with brick. I've Googled a bunch of "How to" sites and don't seem to find an answer to that old question "Mortar or sand bedding". Some prefer concrete and others sand. I'm worried about frost heaving with just sand and not too clear on how thick a concrete bed should be. Any recommendations on books to defog this dilemma would be appreciated TIA
>We laid our front walk in brick on a two inch bed of sand and the stone and brick outfit sold us some plastic edgeing that locks the outside row of bricks in place so none migrate outward.
Still looks good after ten years tho it has sagged a bit in places.
>Mine's been in for about 12 years. Brick on a sand bed about 4" thick. It does heave during the winter, but not much. All settles back in the spring.
Michigan winters are a bit colder than here in Jersey. I would expect a little heaving with any method. Sand will settle back nicely, but I'm afraid what a concrete slab would do. I know that the original cement sidewalk cracked and heaved terribly. Only way that I know to stop any heaving would be to dig below the frost line. That would make for a deep concrete pour. :) I would go with a 4 to 6" sand base.
>I agree with those above. My climate in VA is much milder than yours, but I have done about a dozen walks and patios with brick on sand. They do shift a bit over the years and occasionally a root will find its way underneath and heave a few bricks. The good news is that the repair takes about ten minutes and usually costs nothing. Just lift out the bricks, set them aside keeping them oreinted exactly as they came out, Cut the offending root with a sharp spade, repack the sand and put the bricks back. If a spot settles a bit, lift it out, sift in a little sand and put it back.
Repairs on walks set on concrete are MUCH harder.
I would suggest you dig down about ten inches, lay four inches of gravel, put a layer of filter fabric or land scape fabric on top of it, add four inches of sand, compact it and shape it with a crown, top it with the brick. The binders at the edges are really good and worth it, but not essential. You can install a binder course of bricks standing on their ends, but that is much more difficult than the binder strips.
Put the soil from the excavation into the low places areound your foundation. As a Home Inspector, I can see them from here.
The fabric keeps the sand from sifting into the gravel. The gravel under it gives a place for the water to sit and soak away. If there is little or no water in the gravel, no heaving. The technique has been usued for centuries in Scandinavian countries. Know as a dry stone foundation. My house is built on one.
>Your weather can't be a lot worse than ours. What I've found is that the key to getting concrete walls or walks to not heave is proper drainage. IF you get the water from snow and rain drained away, the chances of heave are greatly reduced. I can guarantee that bricks setting in water will heave no matter what sort of base you put under them.
>FWIW, here's the method that we use for setting bricks in sand. Excavate deep enough to allow 4-6" of base + 1" of sand + the brick thickness. We lay a geotech fabric (not weed filter fabric) down on the clean dirt, lay down 4-6" of crusher run (aka hardpack- max 3/4" plus all the fines), compact it. Then lay a 1" level layer of coarse sand on top. Install the edging on one side, lay pavers, other edging, a layer of sand then compact it. If you're using real brick be sure to use a good layer of sand on top of the brick before compacting to protect it. We've also laid down plywood to help spread the compaction force to keep from breaking soft brick pavers.
>I've done some, but I'm in California, so my experience probably doesn't translate.
But the folks on Hometime do those regularly. They have websites and videos and the like, showing how they do them in the Minnesota region. Wisconsin can't be too much worse. ;-)
You can get brick, but make sure that it's the type for using in a path, and not the type that goes in walls, or you'll have water absorption and spalling problems. I've used concrete block in my more recent projects, and it looks pretty good. The work, though, is hard on the back and knees, at my pace, at least.
>When my folks built their last house in northeast Iowa, I was snot nose civil engineer fresh out of college and my dad had a whole lot of honest-to-goodness street paver bricks from when they replaced streets in my hometown. He wanted a sidewalk. I'd put in sand bed patios with them before but the weeds and heave were always a problem. Dad wanted me to do a curved walk in a mortar bed. It still looks good to this day, although they no longer live there.
We put down a 2" thick concrete base for the whole walk. In my business, we call that a work mat. Once that cured for a couple days, we set the brick in 1" mortar mix and once set, we squeeged mortar between the bricks to lock things up. He had me acid wash the whole thing several times because of the calcium "haze" that was still on the surface. It never really got it clean. Little did we know that just going through one winter eliminated all the calcium haze from the surface. Worked for me.