Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

Posts

Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

#1

Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

North of the Border

>thickness planing? I'm looking to buy a 12.5" planer (with stand) priced at $220 Cdn (plus tax and plus $25 more for a dust hood). Its spec. is given in the link.

Any Canucks out there who have had experience with King Canada products? It's headquartered in Montreal but I believe it's only an importer (and chances are this planer is from Taiwan or China) - company profile http://tinyurl.com/5bgg9h.

The Dewalt ones are out of my current budget for a planer as I don't do planing a lot close to $500). My Delta table saw (10") is made in Taiwan and I wonder if its planers are also imported. If they're, I'll save $100 or more by going for King Canada. (Side question: are there still woodworking power machines made in the U.S. or Canada any more??? I mean at prices that hobbyist woodworkers can afford. I don't blame the NFTA for the loss of jobs in the US. Our inability to compete against cheap labor in Asia is the main culprit that we rely on imported machines as much as we on oil from Middle East.)


King Canada 12.5" Planer Spec.

Re: Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

#2

Re:Correction - planer doesn't come with stand

North of the Border

>but I don;t it anyway as I'll put the planer on my workstation.

Re: Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

#3

Re: Is this a resonable machine to do light duty

Barry Irby

>I know nothing about King Canada or this planer. It mentions four machined posts (?) but says nothing aobut a cutter head lock. If the head does not lock, this might lead to more snipe. Don't know, just speculating.

If you buy it, you want to buy several spare sets of knives. Just in case they discontinue it.

Re: Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

#4

Re: Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

Dan Mitchell

>I think I might be a bit leery of a 2-knife planer, though there are a lot of them out there.

In a 2007 FWW article on benchtop planers, they give the Ryobi AP1301 a "Best Value". Wood magazine says "Our Top Value choices were a bit easier. The Ridgid TP1300LS and Ryobi AP1301 left surfaces as smooth as the Delta 22-580. Ridgid does it for $40 less than the 22-580, and the TP1300LS also comes with extra knives, a leg stand, and dust hood. The bottom-dollar Ryobi planer costs $150 less than either of those models, but plan to cut off the sniped ends or build your own infeed and outfeed tables."

The Ryobi is $199 at HD (link below), including dust hood.

I have a PDF of the FWW article I can email you, if you'd like.

Dan


http://www.homedepot.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet

Re: Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

#5

Re: Yes - with thanks. Please

north of the border

>email me a copy of the FWW article. Just now, after receiving your tip, I got an exceptional good service from Home Depot on the phone. The CSR - Bruce - found me the info. on the AP1301, including checking for me which stores have them in stock. The price here is $279, though (despite the fact that the loonie has almost gone on par with the US dollar). Compared to the King Canada's planer ($245), the AP1301 is only $34 more, before tax. I think I'll most likely go for the Ryobi planer, given the assessments it received from FWW & WOOD. Thanks Dan for your timely advice. (I was planning to pick up the King Canada Planer tomorrow on my way to or after work!).

Re: Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

#6

And after the pruchase of the Ryobi planer, I'll

north of the border

>have to stop spending any more $ on woodworking related items in the near term ...!

as within two weeks, I had or will have spent on these:

Bought a 1 HP dust collector, etc. for $200

Got some cut-offs - $45

Picked up a second hand Detailer woodburner (new was $139) and a Skil plunge router all for $65

Going to buy some 30 board feet of white oak (about $150 ($5 per bft) - from the same place where I bought the cut-offs)

(In June, I got a spindle drum sander and Leigh Superjig and the truth of the matter is I'll have no more space in my garage for any more tools after July. I've thrown away things to make room for the new toys! - while bearing in mind I have to park my cars (2) in the garage every night.)

Re: Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

#7

Re: And after the pruchase of the Ryobi planer, I'

Barry Irby

>Go with the Rigid. No doubt in my mind. Name brand for HD rather than brand X from?. It's a no brainer.

Owning a planer made a huge change in my shop. It was a tool that allowed me to "do Stuff" rather than do work aroudns or go borrow the use of one from and friend. You will like it.

Think of your tools as investments rather than toys. Some of my toys are over thrity years old and going strong.

Re: Is this a resonable machine to do light duty *LINK*

#8

Re: And after the pruchase of the Ryobi planer, I'

del schisler

>i have the ridgid 13" planer and the ridgid 6" joiner and both are very good Right out of the box I use mine every day for about a yr. now and still going strong my 2cents del