Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Posts

SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#1

Ellis Walentine

SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Ellis Walentine

>Hi folks,

It's time yet again to take your pulse on a compelling woodworking issue. This time around, it's about the nature of craftsmanship and our preference for the wood medium.

I assume that everyone who comes here is doing it because they are interested in wood craftsmanship. But, I'd like to know if you also enjoy working in other media besides wood? If not, why is wood the only medium that interests you? Is it because of the specific skills and tools and knowledge you need to work it? Is it because of the abundance of the materials? Or is the usefulness and purpose of the finished product your objective? What is it about wood?

As usual, we'll edit your replies and send them off to Woodworker West magazine for inclusion in their September/October issue. Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#2

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>It's time yet again to take your pulse on a compelling woodworking issue. This time around, it's about the nature of craftsmanship and our preference for the wood medium.

I assume that everyone who comes here is doing it because they are interested in wood craftsmanship. But, I'd like to know if you also enjoy working in other media besides wood?

At this point in my life, wood is the only medium I care to exploit. I have thought of doing some polishing and cutting of some common gemstones but haven't yet invested in the equipment or training.

If not, why is wood the only medium that interests you? Is it because of the specific skills and tools and knowledge you need to work it? Is it because of the abundance of the materials? Or is the usefulness and purpose of the finished product your objective? What is it about wood?

I worked with metals and plastics much of my life as a manufacturing engineer. None of the equipment or items I spent time on will have any value in very few years. Wood has a beauty, both visual and tactile, that IMHO cannot be duplicated by synthetic materials. It is my hope that some of the furniture I design and build will remain in, and be enjoyed by my family members and decedents for at least a few years. I don't believe any other medium other than Art or Jewelery will produce items that are held in esteem for more than one generation. I have worked with wood for over 50 years, and really want to pass on some objects that will remind future generations of me. No other medium has the challenge of designing something of both beauty and utility, that others may enjoy in viewing, touching and using.

I always try to use the finest woods for my projects after the thought provoking message answered by Ellis. He answered a query requesting recommendations for cheaper substitute wood for a furniture project. Ellis answered, as I remember, stating that the material cost - compared to the time and other costs spent on the project - was in most cases a small portion. When the project was complete the material would certainly be a major factor in the perceived value of the piece, and recommended using the best material for the item.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#3

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>I enjoy working with wood,plastics, clay, and a little bit of metal. But my feelings about wood are pretty much summed up by a line from Joyce Kilmers poem, "Trees"- " I think I shall never see a poem as lovely as a tree"- Man has yet to create a material as beautiful as wood.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#4

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

>Over the years I have dabbled in metal fretwork for gates, fences, and other things that needed welding. When my grandkids were young I made a clay wheel for clay working. It was made from swamp-cooler parts, about the size of a small suitcase, and a turning wheel for working the clay on. Still have it and some clay, and after getting my shop back into working order I will probably make some coffee cups, flower vases, etc. Clay working is also so soothing...just like woodworking, and some good products arise from my hobbies....making Xmas presents for family and friends too.

One Xmas I made 19 electronic chime clocks...3 months work...and gave them to friends and family. Still have the one I gave my Mom when she passed away 4 yrs ago.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#5

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There is a fraction of woodworkers that are artists working in wood. No me, I have no artistic talent. I work wood to make stuff I need, from sheep pens to attempts at fine furniture. If I had more need for it I would learn to weld.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#6

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

David Barnett - SW Florida

>"But, I'd like to know if you also enjoy working in other media besides wood?"

I find wood alone to be somewhat boring, both visually and in the crafting. Metals, cast glass, stone are three things that I prefer in the mix. Secondary are other once-living materials; hide, bone, ivory, horn, and so on. Also, I care little about primitive or period reproduction, eschewing mouldings and representational carving (acanthus leaves, shells, whatever) but do enjoy shaped and sculpted forms. I now prefer plainer, quieter woods than when I started, emphasizing color and matte finishes (on all materials). Pear is a current favorite and if I want a bit of figure, a narrow straight stripe is enough (qtr-sawn Braz. RW, for examptle). Perhaps an extreme of this is my recent fondness for stacked plywood showing only the edge laminations.

I often find it stimulating to employ wood as a 'cold' element in my work, with metals and glass coming off warmer due to form and finish. Just a phase I'm going through.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#7

JL

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

JL

>"I assume that everyone who comes here is doing it because they are interested in wood craftsmanship. But, I'd like to know if you also enjoy working in other media besides wood?"

I have dabbled in blacksmithing and jewelry making - but it is dabbling. I don't choose to afford the expense (and dirt) of a blacksmithing operation.

"If not, why is wood the only medium that interests you? Is it because of the specific skills and tools and knowledge you need to work it? Is it because of the abundance of the materials? Or is the usefulness and purpose of the finished product your objective? What is it about wood?"

I work in wood because I like making things, preferably useful things.

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: SURVEY: THE IDES OF JULY

Moses Yoder

>My woodworking has led to some metal working as well, such as making plane irons, but I do not spend much time dabbling with anything other than wood.

Things I like about wood as a media;

1) It used to be a tree, and perhaps still is.

2) Every board is unique, so it is never boring (this becomes more evident when working with hand tools)

3) Due to it's insulating properties it feels warm to the touch

4) A lot has been written about it, so it is easy to learn more about it

5) It has a good strength to weight ratio

6) Most people enjoy objects built of wood