Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Which wood to use

Posts

Which wood to use

#1

Which wood to use

Moataz Warshanna

>I am doing a project that is made from walnut. However, this is my first project so I wanted to start with a wood that inexpensive; but have the same strength and would use the same technique.

If I stain it to look like walnut what would be the best stain to use.

Thank you for your reply.

Moataz

Re: Which wood to use

#2

Re: Which wood to use

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>I'd use poplar and off-the-shelf walnut stains to experiment for the look you want.

Re: Which wood to use

#3

Poplar

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I build my practice pieces from poplar. If they turn out well I paint them, or they could be stained.

Re: Which wood to use

#4

JL

Re: Which wood to use

JL

>I would also say poplar. It is relatively inexpensive.

The drawback with poplar is that it is a relatively soft wood - and it often doesn't play well with some stains. If you end up staining it, I've had better luck with reasonably quality gel stains as opposed to the typical solvent suspension stains.

Re: Which wood to use

#5

Re: Which wood to use

Neal in San Jose

>I'll throw another suggestion out there: Alder. I haven't made anything from it in several years, so I'm not current on costs, but when I have used it, it was about the same as poplar. It handles easily and takes stains and all clear finishes I've tried very well. Two advantages over poplar is that it is much more consistent in color and it is somewhat harder so will take joinery/carving/sanding better. The grain is pretty similar to cherry and I've fooled a couple of pretty accomplished woodworkers with a cherry stained alder stereo cabinet. I haven't tried a dark stain like walnut, but my guess is that it would look super. My main complaint with poplar is the green color much of it has, which leads to some "interesting" stain sessions.

Re: Which wood to use

#6

Re: Which wood to use

Fred Davis

>Neal has it right , Alder is commonly referred to as "poor mans Walnut"

FredD

Re: Which wood to use

#7

Re: Holly/willow

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>The most similar, commonly available hardwood to walnut on my list of mechanical properties is holly (Ilex spp.)

Mechanical properties of (black) walnut (Juglans nigra):

Hardness: 1010 lbf

Specific gravity (moisture content): 0.55 (12%)

Weight: 38 lbs/cu. ft.

Mechanical properties of holly (Ilex spp.)

Hardness: 1020 lbf

Specific gravity (moisture content): 0.57 (12%)

Weight: 40 lbs/cu. ft.

Regarding the look of the wood, willow is used to mimic walnut.

I'll leave the staining question to others.

Al