Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Cutting board question

Posts

Cutting board question

#1

Cutting board question

jeff

>Hi all

I'm having a dis-agreement with my brother.

I read somewhere that a wood cutting board is better then plastic.

My brother says no way, that the plastic is better for cleanliness.

Who's right?

Also, anyone know where to find any articles or proof?

I might add, I make my own cutting boards.

But, no money is riding on this, just my pride.

Jeff

Re: Cutting board question

#2

JL

Re: The USDA says... *LINK*

JL

>Well - read it yourself :).


Food Safety

Re: Cutting board question

#3

Ellis Walentine

Here's another study...  *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>


UC Davis Food Safety Laboratory Study

Re: Cutting board question

#4

My Google Search.....

jeff

>Turned up a bunch of studies and advice.

But nothing definative and alot of contradictions.

I suppose my brother and I will call it a draw.

Jeff

Re: Cutting board question

#5

Does Not seem to be a Draw......

Barry Irby

>The results of the tests I read were counter-intuitive. It seems obvious that a plastic cutting board would be naturally cleaner and easy to clean and disinfect as a wooded one. So I think we approach this from the stand point that plastic is the winner and wood has to prove it is even close to as good.

The last paragraph of Ellis' Link said you were twice as likely to get salmonella from a plastic cutting board. The articles indicate that wooden boards tend to self disinfect over a couple of hours or a relatively short period of time.

What I see is that wooden boards are not at a disadvantage to plastic at all. I think in the home application they are superior.

Re: Cutting board question

#6

Re: Does Not seem to be a Draw......

Howard Acheson

>>> The last paragraph of Ellis' Link said you were twice as likely to get salmonella from a plastic cutting board. The articles indicate that wooden boards tend to self disinfect over a couple of hours or a relatively short period of time.

As far as I know, that conclusion in the UC-Davis study has never been supported by any other study or by the FDA.

The answer is to keep any board clean and disinfected. In general, because a plastic board can be put into a dishwasher, it is easier to clean. However good cleaning with a soapy rag followed by disinfecting with a bleach solution will get a wooden board clean also.

Re: Cutting board question

#7

Re: Does Not seem to be a Draw......

Howard Norman

>Just because the results from UC Davis have not been reported in another study doesn't make the UC Davis study incorrect.

What I have done for many years is to use a plastic cutting board for cutting up raw meat and a wood board for cooked meat, fruit and vegetables. I hate to use the plastic board at all because it will definitely due a knife faster than using a wood board. But it is easy to toss a plastic board into the dish washer.

Re: Cutting board question

#8

Re: Does Not seem to be a Draw......

Ryan Stagg - Cincinnati

>That's what I was going to comment about - I have a plastic cutting board for trimming lots/big pieces of raw meat, and it wears my knives much faster if I'm slicing on it as opposed to my maple butcher block. I think that's a solid 'check' in the wood block column.

Generally, I have the flexible plastic sheets that I cover my maple block with when I'm putting meat on it. You still have the softer maple backing, and the sheet takes up next to no room in the dishwasher when you're done.

Re: Cutting board question

#9

Re: Does Not seem to be a Draw......

Howard Acheson

>>> Just because the results from UC Davis have not been reported in another study doesn't make the UC Davis study incorrect.

Nor does it make it correct. UC-Davis study was singularly attributed to one individual and claimed that wood was actually a better cutting board than plastic. Supposedly wood (not sure what wood or if they claim ALL woods)has some power to actually kill germs and bacteria even if not cleaned. The FDA doesn't buy it nor do most local health codes used to evaluate public food establishments.

Nor does it appear that you fully buy it if you use a plastic board for meat products.

Re: Cutting board question

#10

Re: Does Not seem to be a Draw......

Howard Norman

>>The FDA doesn't buy it nor do most local health codes used to evaluate public food establishments.<

I have never seen any statement that the FDA doesn't buy the opinion. Can you cite a reference. I don't think that one exists. As far as why I use a plastic board for cutting up raw meat I think that I stated why I do that, the plastic board can be put in the dishwasher. That makes it a lot easier to clean up than having to scrub down a wooden board. I have never sterilized any wooden board that I have used and never felt the need for sterilization of one.

As far as local health boards are concerned. Most of them are not made up of the sharpest knives in the drawer.

Re: Cutting board question

#11

Re: Does Not seem to be a Draw......

Fred Davis

>Having installed Maple counter tops in the State of California for well over thirty years, I can say, it is a well known fact among CA contractors that the State Health dept. , approves Maple counter tops made by John Boos and co., in Effingham Ill., for commercial food preparation and serving and to my knowledge, that is the only manufacturer of Maple counter tops with that distinction.

J.E. Higgins Hardwood Lumber In Ca and Nevada stocks that brand for that purpose.

FredD

Re: Cutting board question

#12

Re: What about butchers?

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>Do they still use maple cutting blocks?

Re: Cutting board question

#13

Re: What about butchers?

Howard Norman

>>Do they still use maple cutting blocks? <

Yes