Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT - SUV and gas consumption

Posts

OT - SUV and gas consumption

#1

OT - SUV and gas consumption

Howard In Toronto

>Hi all -

Zooming around on the net made me think -

What are YOUR thoughts/opinions on fuel consumption and (per-gallon) pricing and your big vehicle - SUV and pickup.

Do you intend to change out your thirstier vehicle for something more frugal?

Drive less?

Not let foreign governments tell us how to live our lives and just doing what we've been doing?

Do you get heat from strangers about your choice of vehicles?

Not trying to start anything heated.

But I AM interested in starting a debate,

And I am curious about how we as REGULAR people feel.

Not the sensationalist garbage in the newspapers.

Are we where we are where were in the mid-70's?

Thank you - I look forward to hearing back.

Howard (who defintely doesn't think 1.37$C a litre makes ANY sense)

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#2

Better mpg

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>While the price of gas isn't crippling for my family, it is having its impact on fun money. Our FOrd Explorer was getting long in the tooth and was a concern at 15-16 mpg. We also wanted to keep our boat so the new vehicle had to pull the boat. We purchased a new used Mazda Tribute with a V-6. It pulls the boat just fine and gets 24-25 mpg on trils and 23-24 around town. It rides as good or better than the Explorer and LOML likes to drive it. It was a conscious part of our buying decision to consider the mpg rating.

I have altered my driving habits to drive at or just below the speed limit, anticipate stops and slower accelerations and have seen my gas dollars go farther as a result.

I hate the fact that the oil providing nations can control our destiny and at the same time finance terrorists and decry our principles and way of life as inferior to theirs while raking in our cash. I also decided to change jobs a year ago and one of the deciding factors was to loosen the foreign grip on our wallets. I now work for a company that just finished building a 45 Milion gallon per year Bio Diesel plant.

Lee

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#3

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I get 17 city and 22 highway on my 2000 Silverado 4.8 liter V-8. I can get 25 mpg if I hold it to 60 on the highway. I'm not planning to do anything differently other than slowing down when it's not going to create problems. Luckily, I'm retired and I don't have to drive to work or I'd be feeling the pain a lot more.

My favorite sight over the 4th of July was a full-size yellow Hummer, sporting 2 huge fender-mounted US flags, doing 80 and heading towards Detroit. I guess all the flags means he's a patriot, but he sure was using up a lot of gas and that's directly hurting his countrymen.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#4

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay Area

>I normally stay out of these discussions, and probably ought to here, as well.

My 1999 GMC Sierra has 177k miles on it, and is running well. There's no need to replace it, because it gets so few miles put on it every month.

When I start racking up the 3000 mile months again, soon, I'll look at something smaller, and more fuel efficient. But I'll keep the truck, because 1) I'll still need one and 2) the resale price will have dropped to the point that selling it makes little financial sense.

Certain things are sunk costs, and have to be treated that way, regardless of what the folks say that try to calculate things down to a $/mile rate. The first mile is tens of thousands of dollars. The next miles, not so much.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#5

16 and 20

Dustmaker Mike

>16 back and forth to work and 20 on the highway. 04 F150 with a 5.4 liter in it. It tachs 2000 at 70MPH. I travel 35 miles one way to work and do not plan on buying anything smaller to drive. If I could find a car just as safe and easy to see out of as well as at least triple the MPG I may look at it. Until then I will stay with my truck and be happy. The LOML drives an Explorer it is an 07 with to little miles on it to say yet what it gets in the way of MPG's I did look at smaller SUVs for her and she did not like the smaller feeling she had in them so we stayed with the Explorer.

As for depending on other countries for oil if we don't go after it now it will be worse in the future. We are our own worse enemy when it comes to thinking ahead, we are stuck on stupid if we think windmills and hydrogen fuel cells will be out any faster then 10 years where normal folks can afford them. If we use the hydrogen fuel cells and it emits water as a by product then will it cause more clouds and rain? We need to really test these concepts before we just toss them out there. Look at the compact florescent lights they have mercury in them, they save energy, but there is heavy metal in them so when they break you can not just toss them away. Okie Dokie I am done

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#6

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

Nat Robison

>When I was in high school in the mid-late '80's, my dad had a couple of full-size pickups. Both had vinyl bench seats, steel dashboards, and vinyl floors. Unfortunately, when the manufacturers decided to make trucks more car-like on in the interior, lots more people started driving them daily that probably didn't need to.

I have no problem with people driving full-size trucks and SUVs if they truly utilize them. But here in the Detroit area, many drive trucks that never haul or tow anything. In other parts of the country, they only people driving trucks are tradesmen. Lots of people have boats and trailers here in Michigan, but they don't tow daily although they own a truck or SUV capable of doing so. They'd probably find they could make do with less vehicle for the 10% of the time they're towing something.

A guy in my neighborhood has a VW (probably from the early '80s) that was based on the Rabbit but with a pickup bed......probably doesn't have more than 100 horsepower. I've been wondering lately if there isn't a place in the market for these "mini-trucks" that would allow you to haul things occasionally and still get 30 mpg when empty. I'd probably be interested in one.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#7

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I won't be giving up a truck any time soon. Not only is it hard for me to fit in anything smaller, I need the size and power to haul all the wood I am burning to heat the house in the winter! Putting in that wood furnace three winters ago was a real plus for us.

I don't care about mileage, as I don't buy for mileage. I do plan my trips a little more right now, but for any other discussion than that, I will have to get political, and then Ellis will spank me. So if you want to hear the rest of the discussion, you'll have to come to Five Barns, where I am sure it will be a late night topic!

Bill

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#8

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Howard,

My wife drives a Honda Accord which we bought new a couple summers ago. I like something with utility, and we always had station wagons--at least since 1970 when I got rid of my beloved Mustang so I could accommodate kids. At one time we had 3 intermediate sized wagons for our family of 12. I headed up a car pool at work, and was the principal driver. My passengers paid for all my gas and most driving expences. When I retired, I bought a small Mazda B 2200 4 banger 5 speed stick shift pick up truck. It got 28.6 mpg on my last trip to Silver Sporing MD just three weeks ago. It is now 15 years old, and has 85,00 miles on it. Last year I drove it less than 2,000 miles. To me, it is a reasonable, inexpensive alternative to a small SUV or full size pick-up. I don't have any luxury, but enjoy all the utility it offers. I'd be a fool to drive anything else, and a poor fool at that.

George

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#9

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

John in Calgary

>I agree that $1.37/litre doesn't make any sense, but I've always selected my vehicles on the other side of the spectrum (I drive a turbocharged 4 cylinder VW Passat that gets 40+ MPG, the imperial kind, not the US kind, on the highway and 30 in the city, 35/25 for you US folks). It still hurts though when you have to spring $85 to fill the tank, its just not as often.

The better way to look at this debate is how much per year you are going to spend (or save) on gas. It costs me $2000 a year to fill up my car, but only because a tank of gas lasts three weeks commuting to work and back. Compare this to my boss's Humscalade that costs him $20000 a year in gas to commute to work because he lives further out from downtown Calgary and he drives a vehicle with poor gas mileage (even with half his miles on the highway). So, does it make sense for me to upgrade my vehicle to something more fuel efficient - no, not for my commute and not with my current vehicle. But, if I had my bosses commute, it might make more sense to trade in for that diesel TDI Jetta wagon that I have my eye on right now. Funny thing is we probably both spent the same amount of money on our houses (his is slightly bigger, overlooks the river from his back yard and has a bigger shop, uh, I mean, garage), yet I could probably pay for way more house just in gas savings alone.

John

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#10

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

Howard Norman

>I am retired and drive a 02 Jeep Grand Cherokee,17/19 mpg. I don't intend to get rid of it. I need the four wheel drive during the winter. I have cut my driving down considerable. I make less trips into town which in 20 miles round trip and don't drive to Phoenix very often anymore. The Phoenix trip, where my kids and grandkids live, is 225 miles round trip.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#11

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

Kevin Rabenaldt

>I have a 97 Suburan (185,000 miles and running great) and get 18 to 19 mpg highway. Also have 96 Dodge 1500 with 150,000 miles and get around 17 mpg highway. I do not plan to change anything. I drive my vehicles till the wheels fall off. I think that saves alot of energy in manufacturing. In general, I do not believe we take good enough care of our vehicles. Unless you buy a used car that gets good mileage, I do not think you are economically coming out ahead.

If you just drive alittle less (say 5 to 10 percent), I think we would be surprised how fast the price of oil would drop.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#12

JL

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

JL

>I have a 1988 Ford F-250. It has ~66,000 miles on it. I have rarely driven it. I drive even less now. The last trip to the lumber store, I drove my Subaru Forester and cut the boards at the store so they would fit inside the Forester or on top.

I don't even want to think about the next time I need plywood.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#13

Did the math.

Joe Pack

>My TrailBlazer gives me about 17mpg all-around. My Impala gives me 25mpg all-around. If I drive the TrailBlazer 10,000 miles @ $4.50/gallon, my cost would be $2647. Assuming I traded it for another Impala (too fat for anything smaller), my gas cost/year would be $1,800, or a savings of $847/year. I owe nothing on my TrailBlazer, but would only get about $9,000 for it on trade while the new Impala would run about $26,000. At today's gas prices, it would take over 9 years to save the $17,000 it would cost me to buy new. Plus, I would have nothing to tow my boat (not often or far, but I still use it) or my craft show trailer.

If I HAD to buy a new vehicle, I might look for more fuel economy, but trading a larger vehicle for a smaller one does not necessarily save money in the end. It saves on fuel cost, but the fuel savings likely will not make up for the large extra cost of a new vehicle.

For folks who buy or lease a new car every year or two, downsizing might make sense. For those who drive them until the junk yard hauls them away, swapping cars only for the mileage difference is a false savings.

P.S. Sure wish I could get to 5 Barns this weekend. It would be worth the drive just to Bill G. fired up on politics! :-))

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#14

Re: Trailers...

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>replaced my pickup years ago. Our sedans get mid-20s mpg at highway speeds, a bit less around town. We just bought a Ford E150 conversion van someone traded in on a Kia so my wife could take it when she goes camping. She's tiring of the tent and cot and wanted the bed/seat of the van, as well as the hard walls around her. Must go with the gray in her hair, eh? She got 16 mpg on a trial 400-mile trip last weekend. I drive a VW diesel that gets nearly 40 mpg. If it's nasty, I take the Audi for the AWD. Both have trailer hitches, as does the van now. It replaces a 1979 Suburban that got 8 mpg with or without a trailer. I guess almost 30 years is long enough to keep a vehicle licensed.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#15

annoyed by SUV bashing

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1. what ever the cost of gas is it makes perfect sense. It is determined by a balance of supply and demand . There are only three ways to lower prices 1. increase supply. 2 lower demand 3. price controls which will mean rationing and gas lines like in the 70's. Notice this time around there are no gas lines because the government has not fixed prices. The price has been allowed to rise till demand lessened. I prefer this situation to rationing.

2. I own a Ford Explorer which I purposely special ordered with a 6 cyl engine and 4 speed manual transmission. I was told that only 2% of the Explorers sold were with manual transmissions. My point is that just because something is a SUV, it does not mean it gets 15 mpg (US gal). Mine averaged 25 mpg on a 2000 mile trip to WY and back. For short trips we drive a Merc. Tracer, 4 cyl manual and it gets near 40 mpg. We have been driving some less with gas at $4/US gallon. I used to drive a VW rabbit and it got 45 to 50+ MPG depending on how it was tuned and that is 1980's technology and no batteries (except to start it).

A 6L diesel duel wheel pick up was at the greenhouse recently to pick up a 6 pack of tomato plants. This person is not really concerned about fuel prices, or it has been made impractical for him to own something cheap to do these errands.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#16

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay Area

>I had a VW Rabbit from the early 80's that had a 53hp diesel engine in it, and regularly got close to 50mpg with it. Gave it to one of my sons, who later sold it to a friend of his at about 300k miles.

It was loud, and not fancy, but it could go from Salt Lake City, UT to Oakland, CA on one fillup in the middle, and do it in less than eleven hours...

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#17

Long...old....stiff....legs.....

Basil

>....sure get out of a pickup easier and with less pain than they do from a low slung car.

I'll list a few I had that I thought got good mileage.

'64 Plymouth 318 22 mpg

'68VW Bug----32 mpg

'78 Olds cutlass(diesel)----28 mpg

'82 Olds 98(diesel)-----32 mpg

'85 GMC 2500 4dr Dually (special blt. and diesel)---20mpg

'99 Dodge Intrepid----30 mpg

'05 Chevy 1500 LSE (5.3L) ----15 mpg for the wife (round town and to work) 22 mpg on the road for me.

In the summer of 1955, my mother and father loaded all us kids, luggage, food and stuff in a big, old '51 Cadillac tank of a car and went to Texas. Nothing but 2-lane highways for about 1200 miles one way. We averaged 22 mpg going out and coming back. ....and daddy drove fast back then.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#18

Bravo Joe

paul in AZ

>With everyone stampeding out to get something small to save $10 or $20/week on gas it is difficult to get them to realize that the new econocar will be rusty junk before they break even.

I don't drive a guzzler but have cut back by driving less... planning trips better than I used to.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#19

The solutions are up to us, all of us.

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>If only we could all think about the big picture....

Reading the posts here shows that most of us are only concerned about our own situation. Should we be thinking more in terms of what we all need to do to reduce our dependence on the Arabs and Muslums? Most of them hate us and would love to put an end to our way of enjoying our freedoms, what's left of them, that is. They aren't beating us with rockets and bombs but they sure are kicking our asses with their oil. Who's fault is it? Look in the mirror folks. Why weren't we concerned about this inevitable problem when we decided to buy those SUV,s and over sized pickups? People in this country only react, we don't seem to look beyond the year at hand. We have managed to vote a bunch of idiots into office that do nothing but blab and disagree. We the voters put them there. And it looks like we are heading down the same road with the two guys who one of them will be in the oval office soon. Is either of them smart enough to do anything about our gas prices? I don't think so.

It's not all about supply and demand that gets the price per barrel of oil up or down. When you see the price jump up 9 dollars in one day, that is not a supply and demand thing. It is purely speculation. Fix the speculation problem and we'll see the price of a barrel of oil drop by at least 40%. Why do we have to wait until we are facing a crisis for those idiots in washington to take notice? You and I can't stop the speculation except by effecting the demand by using a lot less gas and other fuels. So it's all up to us folks.

The answer to our problems will not be solved by polititions. The problems will be solved by individuals like T. Boone Pickens who are willing to take the inititive and do it in spite of the people in washington who do nothing but put up road blocks.

The problems will be solved by you and me, that is if we can get to a point where we are concerned about the big picture and not only our own situation. Some of us are doing what we can, but I'm willing to bet, if we stopped and gave it a little more thought, we could do a lot more an do it now before it is too late when we will have no other choice.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#20

Re: The solutions are up to us, all of us.

randy

>Right on Marv. We (americans) are the most waistful slobs on the planet. Mommy running to the grocery store in her expedition just doesn't cut it.

I've been riding or walking or using public transportation to get to work for the last 15 years.

It's amazing that we couldn't see this coming.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#21

Re: The solutions are up to us, all of us.

Fred Davis

>I am paying a lot of attention to T. Boone Pickens who is one of those rare socially responsible oil billionaires , who is spending millions to educate the country , since the government won't step up to the plate.

He has determined that we currently sent overseas to foreign governments about 700 BILLION dollars a year for oil.

This according to him constitutes the biggest transfer of wealth in the history of civilization.

If we as a country continue to sit back and keep hoping things will be better next year, then we richly deserve the consequences which are only now starting to be noticed on a small scale.

He says the technology exists to convert to a abundant source of Natural Gas and Wind and Solar power to get energy independent and stop funding governments who can charge as much as they want while snickering behind out backs.

He sounds like the only intelligent ,qualified to say so person , I have heard on this subject since it startied to atract attention.

FredD

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#22

Jesper, Denmark

Re: The problem will solve itself.........

Jesper, Denmark

>It is not a sustainable situation that US/North Americans use twice as much energy per capita than other developed economies. Either the consumers will have to adjust to the higher prices or seek alternates that use less fuel.

I think someone once said something like " I have seen the problem, and we are it" Blaming foreign governments or other outside sources are just putting your head in the sand like the proverbial ostrich.

Fortunaately, there are alternates, which, even in America, will work and allow a reasonable standard of living. As an example, my Diesel Skoda (VW derivative) transports five people easily and gets better than 40 mpg. When used to haul wood, I pull a trailer that handles 1300 lbs on a 50 x 100 inch bed - more than most pick-ups.

Gasoline and Diesel prices are more than $8/gallon.

If you need/want/have a gas guzzler, you just have to analyze if that is the right thing for you and live with the consequences. It is going to get more expensive than it is now and no Arab bashing is going to change that.

BTW: This is not politics, but macroeconomics.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#23

Re: The problem will solve itself.........

Fred Davis

>Porgy said " I have seen the enemy and we are it"

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#24

Euro 95 US 87

Dustmaker Mike

>In Europe the octain rating for your low end gas is 95 over here it is 87 and in some places 85. For us to get 95 or better we have to go to the local airport and pay about 7 or 8 bucks per gallon. So we do pay less but we also receive less. I was just over in the Netherlands last month and discussed this with friends.

Re: OT - SUV and gas consumption

#25

Re: The solutions are up to us, all of us.

Tony - Memphis

>Yeah, I have to admit that as I was reading the responses here I was very disappointed that the main concern was immediate ROI. It ain't just about the money folks. And, its bigger than ME ME ME. And its ALL of our's problem. (forgive my good english!). My goal is to lessen my "imprint," not just save money. The parking lot where I work is filled with SUV's driven by one individual to and from work (probably 40 miles a day). I just don't see how anyone can justify that. Heck, I feel guilty driving my little truck. I tend to drive vehicles until they fall apart. I'm 42 and I've only owned three cars. Now, I'm not holier than though! I don't drive an SUV, but I drive a small truck with a much larger engine than it needs (and inefficent too!). To and from work, I only get 19mpg. My wife's car gets 23mpg. We use a lot of gas because we live far from work. Wish we had some mass transit here, but it ain't gonna happen. been looking at car pooling and such. We've been looking into solar power / hot water too. What's the return? I really don't care. The return is that it take smuch less resource to get power from the cells than it does the coal/oil that's burned at the plant (although a lot of our power is hydro -which is great). And we pay extra to TVA so they can support small "green" power concerns. I just relaized I am rambling off topic...sorry...I'll shut up now!

Tony