Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Is this correct?

Posts

Is this correct?

#1

Is this correct?

North of the Border

>In its July issue, Wood magazine listed bandsaw as much more damaging to our ears than a cabinet table saw. Is that correct? My Delta 10" bench top type table saw makes noise like an airplane flying to me. Wood says a circular saw is close to be as bad as a chainsaw, which I think is right. But I thought a bandsaw is not that bad ....

Re: Is this correct?

#2

Re: Is this correct?

Dan MItchell

>Cabinet saws are probably quieter than the bench-top variety. I don't have a band saw, but I find my cabinet saw is fairly quiet. That is, unless the blade is up pretty high, and then it's the shrieking of the phenolic zero clearance insert that makes most of the noise. I don't generally wear hearing protection when cutting most materials, though I probably should.

In my shop, the bleeding-ear-drum award goes to the planer, with the router a close second, followed by the circular saw & sable saw. I always wear protection with those. The main culprit is the universal motors in such tools.

Dan

Re: Is this correct?

#3

Re: Is this correct?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>It depends on what you are cutting, but the sound measurements if done correctly would be taken where the operators ears would be. In the case of a bandsaw, your ears are generally closer to the action than with a table saw.

I wear ear muffs when running the planer, routers or do resaw operations on the bandsaw. On the jointer and TS I generally don't run them very long and don't wear muffs.

Lee

Re: Is this correct?

#4

Re: Is this correct?

North of the Border

>In my shop, my tablesaw / circular saw and router make the loudest noise. I'm getting a thickness planer and that probably will top others. (My shopvac is enclosed.) I probably have heard too many horror stories (or preaches) about hearing loss / protection that I wear my ear muffs most of the time when I'm in the shop even when I only work with the drill press, lathe, or stationery sander. With my ear muffs, respirator and hat (to keep dust from my head) on, I probably look like an alien repairing his space ship to my neighbors!

Re: Is this correct?

#5

Re: Is this correct?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I have some hearing losses so I have to wear protection. But what I know is that it's not all about the decibels but also the pitch of the noise. Sometimes bandsaws blades can really squeal when scrolling etc.

Tom

Re: Is this correct?

#6

Re: Is this correct?

john lucas

>I have a powermatic contractors saw, a Dewalt miter saw and a Delta 14" bandsaw. The bandsaw is definitely the quitest but still requires ear protection on some cuts. The planer and jointer are the loudest probably followed by a handheld router. My chainsaw is actually one of my quieter tools, probably because it's used outside and the sound dissipates.

Re: Is this correct?

#7

Re: Is this correct?

NickB in Eastern Mass.

>Yeah, I think it is the high-pitched squeal that a bandsaw can produce.

The 12" lunchbox planer wins the noise award in my shop, but I have to say that I don't turn on anything without ear protection (I used to make 'one quick cut' every once in a while without earplugs/muffs, but my last physical showed some high frequency hearing loss, so I put on something every time). I had some custom-molded ear plugs made about 6 yrs. ago (local hearing aid shop did them for $60 if I recall). They are so comfortable I can wear them hours at a time, and they don't interfere with safety glasses.

Nick

Re: Is this correct?

#8

Ditto . . .

steve mackay

>I've also taken to hearing protection the last couple years ( Eye protection too [ tap-tap ]. Got tiered of digging stuff out of them ). I think, with the bandsaw, its the pitch of the noise. That little skinny blade whizzing around and vibrating against the wood.

Re: Is this correct?

#9

Re: Is this correct?

Chuck Jurvelin

>To all of you out there- wear your hearing and eye protection whenever you are in the shop running machinery. If you buy good equipment, it's comfortable and does the job. I din't always heed this advice, and I am going to be fitted with a hearing aid next week. I don't think it will be as easy to get used to as my earmuffs!

Re: Is this correct?

#10

SWMBO Tells Me

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Howdy Woodguy,

My wife tells me the loudest sound eminating from my shop happens when I make a mistake. All the neighbors have had their little kids ears fitted with muffs.

I can tollerate even the DW planer. What I can't stand is my DC being on, even though its in a different room. There is a characteristic to that sound which compels me to turn it off.

George

Re: Is this correct?

#11

Re: SWMBO Tells Me

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Good Afternoon Colonel,

We are all well aware of that. When that clock fell I heard you all the way here in Mount Level! ;-)

PS- I never knew you were a long shoreman. ;-)

Tom

Re: Is this correct?

#12

I always wear protection with my bandsaw

Bill Howatt

>

Re: Is this correct?

#13

Re: Is this correct?

r payne

>I've seen loudness (decibels) and pitch (frequency) discussed but didn't see where anyone mentioned length of time (duration). They all can factor in hearing damage. Loud sounds can be harmful in short bursts (I think proteciton is required for any exposure to 90 or 100 decibels) but quieter sounds can cause as much damage if exposed to it for a bit of time. OSHA has in its regulations criteria for protection based on time exposed for a decibel level. If memory serves 75 or 80 decibels has an exposure limit of about 10 minutes. Frequency exposure tends to damage hearing in a specific range. That is if you are exposed to high pitched sound you'll loose hearing in higher frequencies first and lower pitches damage the ability to hear lower frequencies more. And the ability to hear higher frequencies tends to be more suseptible to damage than lower frequencies.

So the band saw may be considered worse based on time the machine is on for typical use.

ron

Re: Is this correct?

#14

thank you all

North of Border

>for the explanations and comments. The factor of duration of exposure is covered in the Wood magazine. I had a hearing test done at my request as part of my annual medical, about a year ago and the result was good for my age, with no significant issues or concerns (I took up woodworking about 10 years ago and have used hearing and breathing protection at all times.). I plan to have another one done say in 5 years and hope little will have chnaged.

Re: Is this correct?

#15

William Falberg

Re: Is this correct?

william Falberg

>There's a huge difference between the noise level of a Universal motor and an Induction motor. Most stationary tools have Induction (like with the big capacitor sticking out on top) motors because they're quieter and designed to run for long periods; weight is not a factor and they last longer. Hand tools, like routers, need to be lighter so use the lighter but noisier universal (brushes) motors. You don't normally run hand-held tools for extended periods. Add a gear reducer to the high RPMs of a Universal motor and you've got one screamin' SOB. Some stationary tools use the cheaper Universals and they should either be replaced or destroyed in a humane, environmentally responsible way.

Re: Is this correct?

#16

A bunch of years ago

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>my dad had his hearing tested and found that he was completely deaf in a narrow range that corresponded to the pitch on his tablesaw.

I have that same tablesaw and have not failed to wear hearing protection.

Bruce

Re: Is this correct?

#17

Re: Ditto . . .

John in Calgary

>I agree with using both. Two reasons - when I started working fresh out of University 15 years ago, I had to get my hearing tested, shockingly, at the ripe age of 23 I already had a notch in my hearing.

As for eye protection, I make my living with my eyes, so why would I take chances with them. About 10 years ago I helped a buddy re-roof his house and decided to wear my safety glasses for the weekend of pounding (yes, we manually pounded every nail for every shingle on a 1450 ft^2 bungaolow) and was shocked at how many nails pinged off of my glasses as I worked.

Nuff said - everyone safety up before they work, that includes your hearing protection and your glasses (and never wear flip flops when you cut the grass, although in my case its so that I can give the reel a good kick with my boot when bark mulch gets caught between the blades and cutter bar of my push mower!).

John

Re: Is this correct?

#18

hours of exposure

McKay

>Because I teach woodshop, and then go home and spend another 6 hours in my own shop, I went to an audiologist and had a custom pair of plugs made. They are comfortable and because of that, I wear them 24/7. They do not cause my ears to sweat like the head phones. Well worth the money.