Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Handplane Refurb Question

Posts

Handplane Refurb Question

#1

Handplane Refurb Question

Jerry Samsen

>I'm new to handplanes but have owned a small block plane for some time and found it very handy. I wanted to try other planes but investing in an expensive Lie-Nielsen or equivalent was too much and buying an el cheapo may be a mistake. So I bought a Stanley No5 Jack plan on eBay ($30) to referb and tune.

I noticed in my new, used plane that there was a small area on the base where the cast iron looked unusual almost like it had significant corrosion and someone tried to grind it off.

First step was lapping so I started lapping using some paraffin oil and Veritas lapping grit (started with lowest grit - 90) on a 1/4" plate glass. After grinding for considerable time I noticed that the suspect area was not touched by the grinding. I cleaned and placed a straight edge along the base and noticed that there was a gap in that area. I can't say how much (0.01"?) but seemed like enough that hand lapping would not work.

This area is about 2/3 of the way from the mouth to the back of the plane and offset to one side of the base in a area about the size of a nickle.

Would this small imperfection in the base cause problems? If so, I'll dump this one and look for another. I'm sure with the right tools this could be reground flat but the investment may not make sense. I don't have any tools (like a edge sander) to do aggressive power grinding / sanding.

Thanks.

Re: Handplane Refurb Question

#2

Re: Handplane Refurb Question

Dan Donaldson

>You will probably get more input on the hand tool board, but from what you describe, it should not be a problem. The most important area is right in front of and around the mouth of the plane. A small imperfection behind the mouth (as long as it isn't directly at the mouth) should not cause any problems. Take a look at the articles, there are a couple of articles about flattening and tuning hand planes. Look in the hand tool section.

Re: Handplane Refurb Question

#3

Re: Handplane Refurb Question

Jerry Samsen

>Thanks for the advice. I'll repost on the handtool board.

Re: Handplane Refurb Question

#4

Re: Handplane Refurb Question

john lucas

>I don't believe it will be a problem either. Some people have actually relieved this area to reduce the friction. As Dan said the toe, the heel and right around the blade are the important areas.

I have a lot of older planes because the good ones are simply too pricey. I've gotten good service from them even though I'm sure they don't cut as well as a new Lee-Nielson.

Re: Handplane Refurb Question

#5

Re: Handplane Refurb Question

Steve Schoene

>Don't be so sure about weaker performance of older planes. Sure on some very difficult woods, figured and exotics, the Lie-Nielsen and such will out perform. But that's only a small percent of the time for most of us. And, upgrading to blade to the newer thicker ones will close the performance gap significantly.