Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

Posts

Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

#1

Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

RobRing

>Has anybody evaluated the performance difference between the Byrd Shelix jointer cutterheads vs. the Grizzly spiral cutters? The main difference seems to be the orientation of the cutter inserts - on the Byrd they are skewed at an angle for a true shearing cut while the Grizzly inserts are at 90-degrees to the jointer bed. Intuitively I'd expect the Byrd to leave a smoother surface on heavily figured wood, but I'm not sure that is the case. I'm considering either buying the Grizz 8" jointer with their spiral cutter or buying it with straight knives and upgrading to the Byrd if the performance difference substantiates it.

I appreciate any insight anyone can provide.

Thanks.

Rob

Re: Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

#2

Re: Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters *LINK*

David Yoho

>Rob, I just now installed a Shelix on my jointer. The cuts are fantastic! I can't speak to which is best with no experience on the spiral head. However, see if the link below for the Byrd varieties from Sunhill give you any help deciding.

David


Shelix and Spiral cutterheads from Byrd

Re: Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

#3

Re: Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Rob, I have the 8" Grizzly joiner with their spiral cutter head. I also have a 20" Yorkcraft (Wilke Machinery brand - seems the same as Grizzly, Jet, Powermatic etc. with different paint). I honestly can't see much, if any difference in performance. I have used both on the same gnarly wood with equally excellent results. One wood that was very tough to join or plane with my previous straight cutters - joiner (6" Grizzly) and Dewalt 733 lunchbox planer was Honey Locust. At least on the batch of lumber I obtained I had pretty bad tearout with both machines - edge and face. With my present equipment, I have seen absolutely no tearout. My normal method is to face plane one surface until it is flat enough to register against the fence then edge plane at 90 deg. Then I move to the planer and do the opposite face - then redo the first (joined) face. Last I saw the second edge parallel to the first on my Unisaw. (I use a WW2 and rarely go back to the joiner). I have even ran a completed frame and panel (rails were cross grain) thorough my planer with darn nice results. Although the Byrd head is excellent, I doubt the money difference between it and the Grizzly is actually worth the performance difference (if any). The replacement cutters are also somewhat cheaper for the Grizzly, although I can't see that being a big deal as I expect at least 8 to 10 years out of a set. If I had to buy today I probably would go Grizzly. I've had the joiner for about 3 years, My son purchased the Planer as a retirement gift for me about 2 1/2 years ago. I haven't had to rotate or change any cutters yet, but did notice I have some very light lines on boards ran through the planer. So far they sand out completely with one pass of my ROS w/150 paper. - I normally use 150 ~ then 180 or 220 grit, so I am not in a hurry to rotate them yet. I have ran 4 to 5 hundred BF of white oak and a few hundred bf of misc. (Locust, cherry, walnut, poplar, maple etc.) through the joiner and planer so far.

Re: Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

#4

Re: Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>The Byrd definitely seems slicker, and I have one. But, a former co-worker had a generic one and real world experience shows me that there really isn't any performance difference between the two.

Jay

Re: Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

#5

Re: Byrd Shelix vs. Grizzly Spiral cutters

RobRing

>Thanks for the responses - I pulled the trigger and ordered the 490X - the Grizzly 8" jointer with spiral cutterhead.

Rob