Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

House addition question, Carrying beam

Posts

House addition question, Carrying beam

#1

House addition question, Carrying beam

jeff

>Hi all

I've been asked to help a friend with an addition/modification to his house.

Basically, it's a 2 story, frame construction.

He want's to open up a room, by adding a 6ft foundation and taking out an outside support wall and enlarging the room.

I told him, that he would need a carrying beam to replace the wall as it supports the second floor and roof.

If he were just putting a door or slider in there a header would work, but this is 20 ft of wall.

I told hime he needs 3 2x12"s nailed together into a beam to support the load properly, and placed under the floor joists.

He wants to know if they could be attached to the end of the joists and not under them, so he doesn't have a beam showing in the room.

I'm at a loss if this could work or not.

Maybe attaching cats onto the joists and extending them would be better in my mind.

Can anyone give me some advice here, before he makes a big mistake.

Jeff

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

#2

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

Bob Wilkerson - Richmond, VA

>This is the time to call in an engineer.... That's a large span and I'd doubt that even 3 lvl's would be enough. Probably going to require some steel - ie: flitch plates or a steel beam. In the house I have under construction we needed a 16" tall x 8" wide beam to support two floors for a 25' span not including a roof load. Weight capacity will be one part of the equation - you'll also need to calc the deflection to make sure that the floor/roof doesn't sag. Check with a local lumber yard that sells engineered lumber to get them to do a first run calc with LVL's as most will do it at no charge. If their materials fail to meet the loads the engineer is your next stop.

Bob

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

#3

I had my suspicians

jeff

>

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

#4

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

Steve Schoene

>There aren't many parts of the country left where this project doesn't require a building permit. I wouldn't want to be involved, if required permit hadn't been obtained, at least not in a situation like this where the potential for a serious structural problem might be an issue. And, joists running perpendicular to the wall is a red flag that there is some serious structure involved.

Without seeing the situation I wouldn't want to specify the nature of what beam might be needed. Definately use an engineer.

But, if, and only if, you adequately support the joists during the process, you should be able to use properly specified joists hangers to support the joist ends onto the sides of the carrying beam. Again this isn't stuff to be guessed at.

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

#5

I'm not an engineer

jeff

>And don't pretend to be.

I did a project like this 2 years ago, but the opening was only for a sliding door.

When I opened the wall, I found the roof and upper floor poorly supported and did a full rebuild and support. If I hadn't, the roof and wall might have collapsed. I wish I could have shoot the original builder.

Mt friend asked for help and I think I'll be smart and suggest he hire an engineer as it is out of my comfort zone.

I bet the cost factor will end this project quickly.

Jeff

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

#6

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>When I replaced the load bearing beam in my shop with LVL's the supplier did all the calculations for me. I ended up with two LVL's bolted together and the support was perfect. I spanned 16' with two 1-1/2 X 11-1/4 LVL's I get no measurable sag in that span. There is an attic storage space above the rafters and LVL.

Lee

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

#7

Re: I'm not an engineer

Barry Irby

>Jeff, I am not an Engineer either, but I have a degree in Building Construction and was builder for years and am now a Home Inspector. All these guys have given you good advice. From experience, 3 2X12's will not carry this load. Get the building permit. Check with the people that sell LVL's. I doubt they can proveide beams for this application, but maybe they can. They can spec hangers for you if they can provide the beams. The beams if availabe will be deeper than the joists. Might be posible to let them into the upper wall. Get this Engineered. No guessing. The size of the beam goes up with the load, but it goes up dramatically with the span.

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

#8

I agree

jeff

>I did some fast math and the job is do-able.

But, since my friend wants to do this himself and he wanted my advice, I'm gonna tell him no.

I think he'll use short-cuts and wouldn't like a full beam, so I don't think I'd touch this with a ten foot pole.

I don't want to end up getting blamed for a sagging roof.

Jeff

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

#9

Re: I agree

Fred Davis

>Jeff,

since you say the guy is your friend, do him a favor like a friend would do and point out the reality of his project.

1. needs to have a remodeling permit.

2. The building dept. will require specs from a structural engineer or a paper from the engineered joist builder stating how the Header will pass load requirements, attached to the departments record of inspections for that building.

3 If he avoids the engineered permitting process and does a Mickey Mouse job on his own, he can rest assure it will come back to haunt him ,if it fails structurally , or if he tries to sell it down the line and the new buyer demands to see if all improvements were done with a signed off building permit.

4. if and when it fails structurally and his home owners insurance agent sees what was done illegally, then that would be bad news from the insurance company.

5 Lastly avoid any connection to a failed remodel that could possibly point a finger at you as the cause.

FredD

Re: House addition question, Carrying beam

#10

Re: I'm not an engineer

George Koch

>Jeff, to echo Barry, I am not an Engineer either, but have a degree in Building Construction and was a builder for years and am now retired. All these guys have given you good advice, the most important is that this project has to be engineered and certified by a professional, That being said, there is another way of supporting the ends of the joists other than hangers onto a wood beam. They could be let into a steel beam and bear on its bottom flange. Again, only if design by a certifying engineer as to loads and spans. George