Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

fitting dovetails questions

Posts

fitting dovetails questions

#1

fitting dovetails questions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Yes, I know you are supposed to saw them perfect and fitting is unnecessary. At my skill level I can often do it if the situation is compressible poplar tails into rigid maple pins, for example, like on a typical drawer. But this trunk is oak into oak and this oak is not compressible. I might as well be trying to fit brass pins and tails. In fact, maybe I should be asking the infill plane makers!

Anyway, with great care, since they will be on a trunk corner for all to see, I have the pins and tails sawed and they are crisp........and in most cases a few thousandths of an inch from going together. In most cases I can just make out the remains of the scribe line on the pin top, so I am less than 0.010 from perfection.

Let me preface the questions by saying I have never had great success in diddling with pins and tails to make them fit. What once was nice crisp sawed pins and tails get rounded and out of shape as I attempt to remove material by various means.

Questions: 1.What is the best strategy for fitting- remove material from pins or tails? I think pins as they seem easier to get at with the wider spacing between them. 2. What is the best way to remove a few thousandths of an inch of material so the pieces will slip together. 3. In a row of 14 fairly closely spaced pins, what is the best way to locate some that are too big?

Re: fitting dovetails questions

#2

Re: fitting dovetails questions

Virgil Johnson, Versailles KY

>Odd as it may seem I use a smooth faced claw hammer to tell which pins are too tight. There is a distinct difference in the sound and feel of the hammer tap. When the pin is too tight the hammer sounds is crisp/high pitch and you feel the hammer "bounce back" ever so slightly. The looser tails have a dull thud and the hammer does not "bounce". Obviously I'm not talking about really whacking the board just a light tap. I use a sharp chisel to trim the tail. If the tail looks really good and I'm afraid of rounding it over I trim the pins. Generally the tails get trimmed.

Re: fitting dovetails questions

#3

Re: fitting dovetails questions

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Bill

First thing I do is check that the sawn tail surfaces are perpendicular to the board face. If not, remove wood but obviously don�t go past �the line�. Then, check that the sawn pin surfaces are perpendicular to the end of the board. If not, remove wood as above.

I remove wood cross-grain with a chisel with a very flat back. There will be no tear-out or splitting as might be the case if you go with the grain. Take tiny bites, and work from the show face so any blowout is hidden.

I saw pins, then mark tails with pencil and then saw. There�s pencil dust on the tails that carries onto the sawn surfaces when you trial fit the joint. It shows where the high spots are. Absent pencil dust, the high spots will show as shiny when you disassemble the joint and inspect the sawn surfaces.

I aim for a joint that can be assembled dry with moderate pounding with my fist.

Ed

Re: fitting dovetails questions

#4

Re: fitting dovetails questions

David Yoho

>Bill, I think others have or will answer your question as fas as trimming to fit. One thing I've found is I like my pins and tails a little on the snug side. That's because I use liquid hide glue and it allows the joint to go together with ease. This is not a substitute for a proper fitting joint. I'm just saying I don't worry about a real snug fit because I know the hide glue will make them slide together like they were greased.

David

Re: fitting dovetails questions

#5

CH Becksvoort Pencil Lead Trick

Martin from Granbury

>First, if you have not already done so, use a sharp chisel to cut a 45 degree chamfer along the bottom edges of your tails. If you dovetails are half-blind, you can take this chamfer all the way to the edge, as it will never show. With through dovetails, you should either not do the chamfer trick, or don't go all the way to the tip of the tail. This will keep the tops of your pins from getting chewed up during multiple test fits. Then, using a dull lead pencil, color the inside faces of each tail. Don't forget to color the "bottom" of the tail. Now, fit the joint together, I usually tap it gently until it stops, just prior(I hope) to splitting the board. Now separate the boards, and trim off the pencil lead that has been transferred to the pins board. Repeat as necessary.

This trick was documented by Chris Becksvoort in an article on dovetailing tips and tricks in FWW. If you have access to their site, I am sure a search will turn up the article.