Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT Laptop processor question

Posts

OT Laptop processor question

#1

OT Laptop processor question

Jim in VA

>I want to get a laptop but am pretty confused by the different processors available. Although I was an early adopter of PCs back in the 80s (anyone else remember Kaypro computers and single-sided floppy discs?), I stopped understanding chip improvements after the introduction of the 80386. I plan to use the laptop to organize my photos (mostly of furniture built by me and others) and music, maintain my website, surf the web, send email, write letters, etc. Overall, nothing too heavy duty.

So, do I stick with Intel and get something like Core 2 Duo Processor or save a few bucks and get an AMD processor? (Comes in flavors such as the Athlon 64 X2 or Turion X2, etc.) Does it matter?

All I know is that I figure I'll get something with 3 GB of memory and 200 GB hard disc, since memory and storage are always handy.

Any suggestions? I'm completely ignorant when it comes to these matters.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#2

Re: OT Laptop processor question

North of the Border

>All latest models of laptops regardless of brands should have the dual processor feature. I have owned or used laptops (Dell, Toshiba, and ) but don't see any difference despite the chips are different (Intel, AMD). If your intention is to use the laptop for normal use / internet, etc., I doubt there'll be big difference. A word of suggestion: don't go for the top-end model because the prices of computers come down so quickly and before you know it, your top-end model could lose its value in half or more .... in no time. My daughter bought a Dell and in less than 5 months, an improved model of hers came out and cost almost 30% less!

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#3

Re: OT Laptop processor question

Howard Norman

>I haven't purchased a laptop in three years so am certainly behind on current technology. However, I did build a new desktop less than a year ago. I have 2 gigs in this desktop and so far am happy with that. Another gig might be useful, I just don't know. I certainly would stay away from the very top of the currant processors but I would try to stay in the top half of what ever is available now. For what you want to do I doubt if you would see any real difference in performance between AMD and Intel chips at the same speeds. I have been a fan of Thinkpads for the last ten years. Even though IBM has sold the business to the Chinese I still think that Thinkpads are very solid performers.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#4

Re: OT Laptop processor question

Tom

>Any modern processor should do what you mentioned, even the lowly celeron. The C2D is the creme of the crop, in laptops, though. It would provide the best performance and, most likely, best battery life too. It all depends on your budget. The AMD x2 is a good cpu, as is the Intel dual-core, it's just the the C2D is a bit better.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#5

RAM needed for Vista?

Jim in VA

>Hi Howard,

Thanks for your advice. The reason I was leaning towards gettting more RAM is that I've heard that Vista is a memory hog. So, I was planning on avoiding the cheapest laptops on sale right now and spending a bit more $ to get at least 3 GB or RAM. Do you think that's overkill?

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#6

Re: RAM needed for Vista?

Bill Howatt

>My understanding is that 1GB will run typical apps with Vista just fine but 2GB is a better way to go to cover all bases and RAM is quite cheap right now. 3GB is the maximum a 32-bit processor can address so anything more is wasted unless you go 64 bits and IMO it isn't worth it right now.

Bill

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#7

Re: RAM needed for Vista?

Howard Norman

>No, I don't think that 3 gigs is overkill for Vista. I forgot to mention that I did not install Vista but XP Pro instead. I still don't regret that decision but if I was to do it today I would seriously look at Vista again. I think that you are wise in not considering the bottom of the laptops. I would also strongly suggest a three year warranty on any laptop. Laptop repairs are very expensive.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#8

Three suggestions…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>The subject of OS has come up. If you order one within the next few weeks (can't remember the deadline), you can still upgrade it to XP (at least through Dell). After that, m$ says no more XP installations.

Or, you could get one with some flavor of Linux installed, instead (Ubuntu is a very popular version right now), and avoid being told by some corporate monopoly what you can or cannot elect to put on your machine.

Or, for the trifecta, set up a dual boot XP/Linux machine.

Rod

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#9

Re: Three suggestions�

Dan Donaldson

>I have a desktop, but it is set up for dual boot. Linux and Linux ;-) Two different flavors, one of which is about to be reinstalled with a later version.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#10

corporate monopoly

Jerry Nicholson

>of course with Linux most of your support is likely to come from a bunch of wild eyed zealous wacko supergeeks (much like Bill Gates and Steve Jobs 30 years ago)who believe any Linux application is orders of magnitude better than any Windows application no matter how bad it is. I currently prefer Linux Mint 5 over the latest version of Ubuntu but there isn't much difference. (I have tinkered with a couple dozen Linux distributions) There is certainly a lot more activity on the Ubuntu forums but some of the people on the forums seem to go out of their way to snow and/or belittle the Linux beginners. Totally unlike our woodworking forums!!!!!!!

Jerry

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#11

XP or Vista

North of the Border

>Before you decide to go for the older version (XP) instead of the default Vista (as some people did in the past year or so), please note that Windows has announced it'll cease from delivering any XP after [sometime] (forgot the exact time), except for the cheaper models designated for some poor countries. This means the support for XP (updates / upgrades) will one day stop as well.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#12

;-)

Dan Donaldson

>I like linux because I subscribe to the school "if it ain't broke, tweak it until it is". I like to play with stuff and I can dig in deeper in Linux than Windows, plus, it is relatively painless to do a complete reinstall when I hose something beyond my ability to repair it. (/home is on a separate partition)I have only been playing with Linux for about a year and a half now, still a ways to go up the curve. I went cold Turkey and did not set up a dual boot with Windows. Right now, I have a Gutsy install and a Hardy that is my main OS. I will be replacing the Gutsy with Intrepid at either the last alpha or first beta release.

Windows is fine, but linux is more fun if you have a high pain threshold ;-)

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#13

Re: XP or Vista

Dan Donaldson

>The fact that support for XP will be going away, probably much faster than 98 did, is what caused me to first investigate linux as an alternative. A this point, I will probably never go back. I am not a gamer (Windows is still mostly the only game in town for that {pun intended, George ;-)}), and the savings in software costs (I always try to be totally legal on the software I run) will buy me a new computer every 2 or 3 years. Probably still not for the faint of heart, though.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#14

Re: XP or Vista

Ralph Turney

>I just bought a workstation from Dell and it came with both Vista and XP installed...not sure how that works, but it boots in XP, so I'm happy.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#15

Re: XP or Vista

Jim in VA

>Count me among the faint of heart. Even though I regularly think evil thoughts about Bill Gates and his Empire, I doubt I have the time or capacity to leave MS.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#16

Re: XP or Vista

David Yoho

>Just as some don't want anything to do with MS, I am that way about Intel. Call it rooting for the little guy or whatever, but I've been using AMD chips for a long time. If they made a little sticker to go on the outside of the computer case that said "No Intel Inside", I'd proudly stick them on mine!

That said, any of the new processor chips out there now will do a nice job for you. When it comes to memory, you're right, Vista is a hog. Early on it was determined that XP's sweet spot for RAM was 1GB. If your computer could take it, the 32 bit versions of XP could handle up to 3GB and the 64 bit version, 4GB. It's been determined that Vista's sweet spot is 2BG but can handle more RAM than XP does. So, I think you definitely want one with 3GB.

Also, something else to look at is check out the various manufacturers business models. I have three HP business model computers here and they all are nicer than the standard grade offerings. They all came with 3 year warranties. Personally, I like HP but Dell and some others offer business models too.

David

David

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#17

Ellis Walentine

What is it with geeks?

Ellis Walentine

>Can't live with 'em, can't live without 'em. Every time I check into a computer/applications/programming forum, it seems that social graces are optional at best, and mostly absent. It makes me appreciate our woodworking visitors even more.

Ellis

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#18

Re: XP or Vista

Dan Donaldson

>Nothing wrong with that. I have a few issues with Windows, but won't bash them. Windows works, and for many, that is enough.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#19

Re: What is it with geeks?

Jerry Nicholson

>After many hours on various Linux forums, it appears to me that the average emotional and social maturity of the "gurus" is 13. I remember my own arrogance and self importance at 13 (There are a lot of other things I would rather remember, however) and no amount of money would make me want to relive it. Woodworkers are a far more mature bunch, no matter what their age!

BTW, Linux is lots of fun to play with but I still do most of my serious computing with Windows XP.

Jerry

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#20

Re: OT And no one mentioned Mac

Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay Area

>One of my sons has an absolutely beautiful Mac laptop now, for a bout a year. It's his third Mac, the other two being the heavy duty desktop systems.

I've been doing this stuff for over 25 years, and this version of Macintosh has me seriously tempted, for 98% of what I do.

For what you mentioned, perhaps you should consider investigating it too.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#21

another minor point

Tom

>Most, if not all, laptops have only 2 memory slots. If you want 3gb, you'll need 2gb and 1gb sticks. In that case, you'll lose the performance tweak of dual-channel memory. It's not a big hit, but it is something to consider. If you're the type of person to turn off most memory hogging features of XP or Vista, 2gb might be enough, and you can retain the dual-channel feature.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#22

question

Dan Donaldson

>Just wondered what you consider serious computing. (not meaning that the way it might sound) ;-) There are a lot of professional programs that only have Windows or Mac variants and for these types of items, Windows (or Mac) is the only real alternative. Beyond those types of applications (and I do not need any of them, although many do), I have not found much of anything that I could do with Windows that I couldn't do with Linux. I was just curious. I get great performance and all of the functionality out of linux that I need, but have no problem with those that prefer Windows nor necessarily want to "convert" anyone. I just like to understand the reasons that they have for the preferences.

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#23

Re: question

Jerry Nicholson

>Serious computing? Actually what I meant by that was anything other than just playing and tinkering. Linux will do many (possibly most) of the things that I do in Windows but I haven't found that it will do them better or faster. I still prefer MS Office 97 to OpenOffice but I can run MS Office 97 in Linux under Crossover and it seems to perform slightly better than OpenOffice (no benchmarks, just perception). Several other Windows programs also work adequately under Crossover. I definitely prefer Photoshop CS2 to Gimp but I could probably learn to get along with Gimp. Firefox works just fine for me in both Windows and Linux and I think I could get along with Thunderbird for e-mail. Possibly I could replace DesignCad 2000 with QCAD but I already own and understand DesignCad. I prefer Nero to the CD/DVD writers available for Linux and purchased NeroLinux for just that purpose. I find no equivalent to Microsoft Streets and Trips in Linux. My printers, connected to a Windows XP computer on my network, work just fine from Linux but I have not tried my scanner in Linux. The Parallax Propeller software development environment does not work in Linux.

I will continue to evaluate Linux distributions looking toward the day that the path of least resistance (for me) will be convert to Linux rather than convert to Vista but I have learned enough so far to know that a lot of the hype promoted by the true Linux Zealots is just that - hype, and that Linux is not better or worse than Windows, just different. So far I am quite impressed with Linux Mint 5.

Jerry

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#24

Re: question (PS)

Jerry Nicholson

>I run both Windows and Linux with the fancy visual effects such as exploding windows and the Linux Compiz Fusion (Confused Fission?) turned off. Being a really old grouch, I find that kind of stuff annoying and don't see any sense in taking a performance hit for nothing but eye candy.

Jerry

Re: OT Laptop processor question

#25

Thanks

Dan Donaldson

>I was just curious. I still use Windows at work because I have to and have a version of XP installed in a virtual box that I run once in awhile for stuff that just won't run in anything but Windows. Interestingly, Windows seems to run better in the box than it does native. Weird. I also run MS office in crossover and for some applications, prefer it over openoffice. For general usage, I use whichever one is handiest at the time.

My other computer came with Vista and I ran it for awhile just to see what it was like. I didn't care for it, but in fairness, I didn't spend a lot of time tweaking it or anything. On that machine the perceived performance is better with linux, but that could be because I know how to make it run fairly well and don't know Vista's foibles. I still have the Vista hard drive in a drawer and probably should put it back in to at least get the updates.

I have never run Mint, but I believe that I have probably installed most of the stuff that makes it different.

Thanks for the response, I am just interested in what people think about various systems, especially those that have tried several different ones.