Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Veneer Question

Posts

Veneer Question

#1

Veneer Question

lee beeden

>I have a passion to build Lonnie Birds 18th century secretary; it was in fine woodworking a few years back. A piece like that deserves to be built out of some very special wood indeed. My idea is to use as much Birch( i have lots} as I possibly can for all the secondary wood, budget is a little tight.

What do you think about veneering the lower and upper cabinet sides? I thought perhaps 1/4" curly maple onto birch.

Also the drawer fronts have a 3/8" rabbit around the outside which makes the overlay a little more subtle; i was thinking about a 3/8" veneer here.

I'm not sure about the panels in the Tombstone doors though?

I do not own a vacuum press; is it possible to get good results with lots of clamps and some kink of a flat board to hold the veneer down?

Any comments much appreciated.

Lee

Re: Veneer Question

#2

Re: Veneer Question

paul in AZ

>First a couple questions:

Birch -is that lumber or Baltic ply as your core wood?

Maple -do you mean veneer slices 1/4" and 3/8" thick? If so these are considerably thicker than what is usually used as veneer. Are you resawing your own veneers?

Nothing whatsoever wrong with veneering a piece. the old timers did that all the time.

I'd be inclined to use baltic birch ply as my base rather than lumber. compared with the labor involved a few extra bucks for better materials is small potatoes.

There will be considerations of climate's effect on expansion/contraction of dissimilar woods and grain orientation if you use lumber. Both with some implications as far as risk of subsequent splitting.

That said, glueing these up should be no more complex than glueing two boards together to make a thicker board. No big deal.

Re: Veneer Question

#3

Re: Veneer Question

lee beeden

>i was thinking of using birch lumber under the veneers. As far as the thickness of the veneer, i was planning on re sawing with the band saw, and buying as little wood as possible.

The thickness would depend on where i used it, as i said it would have to be 3/8"on the front of the drawers so that it was not visible when the drawers are closed.

I know this is labor intensive, but time is something i have and not cash

Lee

Re: Veneer Question

#4

Re: Veneer Question

paul in AZ

>Cracking and splitting will be the major risks of veneer over solid. You might get away with it or may not.

Laying the veneer's grain at right angles to the core's will help that a lot but that is often hard to do when building a larger piece.

An even better route will be to cross band an intermediate layer of [your birch?] veneer with all grains at 90 degrees to each other. This essentially is home made 3 layer plywood and should be very stable. Doing this will get more mileage out of your fancy surface wood because the top layer can be thinner.

Re: Veneer Question

#5

flawed economics and a comment on the wood

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If I had lots of birch, and wanted to build a curly maple desk as you described, I would sell some birch and buy the lumber needed. That desk sells for $15,000, to beyond $25,000, depending on the name of the builder. The route you are contemplating is not going to save but a few hundred dollars, at most. Save the passion to veneer something for the door panels, or something else that make more sense. Considering that it will likely take you a year to build it, saving $2 a day on other expenses will buy the lumber.

That said.....I have seen the original and many like it. In fact a friend is building it and nearly complete. (He has been building period pieces for 30 years and this one for 1 year and considered this piece a challenge, especially the gallery.) Curly maple is not the wood for such a formal piece. It needs to be walnut or mahogany. At the risk of being sexist, too much makup on a pretty woman doesn't enhance the attraction. The elegance of the piece is not in some fancy wood, but in its lines and shapes. Plain walnut or mahogany for all but the door panels.

Re: Veneer Question

#6

Re: flawed economics and a comment on the wood

lee beeden

>All things considered I think I'll find the extra money to buy the lumber. Thanks for all your comments.

Lee

Re: Veneer Question

#7

best of luck on it. its a fine piece

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you get stuck a friend has detailed prints for it. The gallery is difficult,