Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

TS Blade Problem?

Posts

TS Blade Problem?

#1

TS Blade Problem?

Tony - Memphis

>Ok, I decided it was time to take the WWII off and send it in for sharpening. I wasn't getting any bad cuts, just thought it was time. I had tuned up the saw recently and added a link belt, cleaned, waxed, etc. I was getting good cuts with no issues. Well, I got the blade back yesterday and was anxious to see results and boy was I surprised...it cuts worse now than it did before I sent it in! I haven't changed anything on the saw (Delta contractor's saw 34-444) since I removed the blade last week. I haven't even used it. I tried measuring everything I could think of. I didn't find anything really obvious.

I noticed the issue when I was crosscutting - that was the first cut I made. The overall quality of the cut is kind of rough, and you can see where a tooth/teeth started to cut on the backside of the blade before I pulled it back. So, I tried ripping and the cut was pretty rough there too. Anybody else had any similar experience? I tried an old Sears blade, but it cuts so bad, it was hard to tell what it was doing. I may stop at a borg today and get another blade to try.

Meanwhile, I sent Forrest an email and am waiting on their reply. I made some sample pieces that I was thinking about sending back with the blade. Here is a picture...

I checked the blade square to the table, checked the slot to the blade, etc. Nothing was out more than a few thou.

One thing I noticed when crosscutting was that I could hear and see the teeth cutting/hitting the wood as it passed the backside of the blade. I thought maybe the alignment was off, but I checked that and it is off a couple of thou, but in the opposite direction, so I don't think that was it.

Anyway, this is frustrating. You buy good stuff, send it back to them 'cause their the best, etc. and you get bad results. I've been considering buying a new saw, but I hate to spend that much money and it not be right.

Tony


img

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#2

Unbalanced I'd guess....

John in New Mexico

>I've seen blades do that, they kinda vibrate every so often making the kerf just a hair wider for that moment. I'm surprised a newly re-sharpened Forest would do that though. Must have a new guy doing the sharpening!

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#3

Check th emounting

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I'd check the flange on the arbor and make sure it is clean. A small amount of debris stuck to the face of the flange will cause the blade to wobble.

Lee

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#4

Re: TS Blade Problem?

David Yoho

>Tony, the last time I sent one back (earlier this year), it came back cutting superior cuts. If all is right on your end, I'd see what Forrest has to say. I'd have to think they'll make it right. Certainly not time to buy a new saw yet.

Is your blade a thin kerf? Mine is not but I still use a Forrest stabilizer with it. However, if your blade was not having this issue before, it shouldn't now. See what they have to say.

David

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#5

Ellis Walentine

That'd be my guess

Ellis Walentine

>Like you, I'd feel pretty confident of Forrest's quality control. Sharpening nowadays is almost totally automated, and IINM the blades are checked for plate flatness and rogue teeth by very sensitive laser indicators. Odds are the trouble is at your end. Lee's suggestion seems the most plausible to me.

Sometime you might want to get rid of those seemingly insignificant "few thousandths" of discrepancy between blade and table, too. The relief angle tolerances on that blade are extremely small and those couple thou' could make a difference in the quality of your cuts.

Ellis

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#6

Re: TS Blade Problem?

Chuck in ND

>I think makeing sure the arbor flange is clean is a good idea also, but I got to say, why do some people insist on cross cuting small width boards on a tablesaw ? It's 2008, there are electric compound mitersaws that do a better job in my opinion, plus you have better control of the board.

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#7

Thanks all

Tony - Memphis

>I got in touch with Forrest and they said send it back. I did check the mounting. That was one of the first things I checked. It is a thin kerf blade and I use a stabilizer, so I always make sure it is clean (lots of surface area for "crap" to get stuck to). I took it off and remounted twice to be sure. The thing I keep going back to is that all was well before I removed it. I've been getting great results with this blade and saw for ten years. I sent them samples with the blade, so maybe they can figure out what is going on. I'm not convinced either way. I also wonder if something happened in transit?

Ellis, I've tried to get rid of all those thousandths here and there, but I can't. This is a contractor's saw and things even go out a little when you drop the motor. The largest number I saw on anything was around 5 thou. Heck, the grind marks in the saw blade are a few deep! I have a TS Aligner Jr set (nice tool) and I was thinking about getting one of those plates (Master Plate or something) thinking that would give me more area to measure against. Even my Beis fence is not flat but within a few thou, so its hard to get rid of them all. But, proof is in the cut and I was getting really good cuts. I just finished a frame for a painting (wifey's 50th birthday present) and had tweaked everything to help my miters (got em close, but still finished them on the Lion like trimmer).

Anyway, thanks for the imput. If they find its me, then I'll need all that to figure out what's going on. My old Sears blade is so bad, I can't get a decent enough cut from it to see anything. I may stop at the Borg on the way home and pick up a backup blade and see what I get from that.

I wasn't thinking about the new saw in repsonse to this, I've been thinking about it for a while. I was just trying to make a point that its frustrating that it seems to be hard to get anything that works as advertised these days. Very few things I have purchased or services I have received have been "just fine." At least most of the woodworking businesses seem to really support their products and their customers.

Tony

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#8

Huh?

David Yoho

>Except for rough crosscuts, which I do on my RAS, all crosscuts are done on my tablesaw. I have two (right and left cutting) Dubby sleds that give me absolute control of cut and extremely accurate results.

I also have one of the older Delta compound miter saws but it sees limited duty in my shop. Why would I crosscut on anything else when my tablesaw does the job so much better?

David

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#9

Re: Huh?

Fred Davis

>yep

FredD

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#10

Re: Huh?

Chuck in ND

>David, comeon now, how many finish carpenters in new home construction do you know that cut most of their miters on a tablesaw ? To each his own, but it makes no sense to me to use a tablesaw for that task unless the board is so wide it can't be cut in a single cut on a miter saw. If your current miter saw is that bad, you may want to look at a better blade and or a better saw, there are some nice saws out there that can save you time with professional results.

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#11

answer

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>multitasking machines(table saw) are advantageous.....too numerous to enumerate and obvious to all. If the work load in a shop justifies an already set up cut-off operation that is a different story.

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#12

Re: Unbelieveable

Chuck in ND

>Why do I bother ?

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#13

Finish Carpenters

David Yoho

>A miter saw is great for trim work and I use mine when framing/carpentry is involved. However, I thought we were talking about crosscutting in the shop where cabinetry and furniture making is involved. That's not to say any of the current crop of miter saws today can't do as nice a job crosscutting but I don't own a newer saw, don't leave mine set up, and already have a solution that works better for me.

Just as I've seen you protest about spending money on expensive machinery that's not necessary, why should I purchase anything else when my tablesaw is the perfect solution. Wide cuts or narrow, mine does them all and does them extremely well.

So, if I'm working with two-by material, the miter saw works great and is portable. If I'm working on something that needs to be much more precise, the tablesaw is my go-to machine.

David

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#14

Re: Unbelieveable

Fred Davis

>I have over the years made a lot of Wainscot and the step moulding that surrounds the recessed panels in the Wainscot.

In a typical upscale home in say BlackHawk in Danville, Ca., the job would run into the hundreds of feet of Wainscot and multiples of that in mitre joints for the panel moulding.

No compound mitre saw could come close to the speed and accuracy of repeat cuts of the same lenght with a shop built mitre jig sliding in both mitre slots in the Table saw top.

FredD

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#15

an idea

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If I am reading the picture correctly that sawing defect looks to me like a blade vibration/flutter (instability) that occurred part way through the cut and then went away. I have seen this pattern many times when crowding a rip cut but not so likely on a cross cut. If the blade has not left yet try a cut that loads the blade very little, like just shave part of a blade width off some ends grain. Alternatively load the blade heavily with a rip in 8/4 and see if it gets real bad. Could be arbor bearings or for some reason the tension in the saw blade has changed for some unknown reason.

I once had a Sears blade that I was going to throw away, but for some reason sent it for resharpening. It came back a very fine blade. It was never sharp, or properly ground?, to begin with and sharpening make it useful.

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#16

Re: an idea

Tony - Memphis

>Thanks. Its already gone though. I may get the Sears blade sharpened so it will be a good backup. I bought it when I first bought the saw. It looks pretty rough. No telling what I put it through back then. Probably lots of 2x4 stuff. I had to really dig to find the thing! I'll post what Forrest tells me. Hopefully, they find something! If not, I've got some work to do.

Tony

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#17

Re: Thanks all

pecker

>I had a brand new Freud blade once that gave the exact same result you're getting. When I called their service guy, he said it may be one tooth out of alignment, and to send it back.

The replacement blade worked fine.

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#18

Thanks!

Tony - Memphis

>I hope that's all this is. Glad that somebody has at least seen this before. That gives me hope. Tony at Forrest said they would turn it around real fast, so hopefully, it will be back early next week.

Tony

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#19

Re: Finish Carpenters

Chuck in ND

>WOW ! I guess cabinet shops and trim carpenters don't use miter saws according to everyone in here. It's truely amazeing that anyone even makes a miter saw, let alone sells one, but then again there must be a few uneducated foolish people like me that like them. I guess I don't belong to the elite class in here, but thats ok.

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#21

Re: Finish Carpenters

Fred Davis

>I have a 14 inch Makita mitre or chop saw, I used to use in the field, now that I don't do field work , anymore ,the TableSaw is more comfortable to use , even though the chop saw still gets a workout.

FredD

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#22

Re: an idea

Fred Davis

>Bill just touched on a fact of life , many blade and bit products are not up to speed until they are resharpened by a good tool grinder.

I bought a Freud Dado set at a woodshow because the hype said splinter free crosscuts in plywood,well after Bay Area Carbide reground it , that is relatively so.

When I purchased a 14 " Makita mitre saw , I clearly stated I wanted a ATB grind on the blade, so naturally they furnished one that had chisel teeth designed for Particle Board cutting, it didn't do a bad job on hardwood cutting , but when I had Bay Area Carbide do it over , they reground it into a ATB configuration and the cut now is shiny smooth.

FredD

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#23

Re: Finish Carpenters

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Chuck,

All saws have purposes that they excel at.Some choose to cut miters and bevel cuts on a compound miter saw,others on a table saw.

For the last couple weeks I have been busy cutting miters,bevels and crosscuts in hardwood and man made sheet goods on a saw just like this one,and I am a union carpenter.It is a saw I haven't much experience with as of yet but we have been very pleased with the results.On the 22th of July we have a client review,if they are happy I'll get about 6 months worth of aquaintance with that saw.


Andy

Re: TS Blade Problem?

#24

Actually - They do

David Yoho

>Chuck, I know a professional furniture maker that uses his miter saw quite a bit. I'm pretty sure most cabinet shops use compound miter saws on a daily basis too, but that's not the point I was making.

When you replied - "how many finish carpenters in new home construction do you know that cut most of their miters on a tablesaw?" - that took the conversation in a new direction for me. New home construction and finish carpentry is obviously done on the job site - not in the shop, so the miter saw makes good sense in that application.

The other point that I found disjointed in your reply was - "If your current miter saw is that bad, you may want to look at a better blade and or a better saw>".

My older model Delta compound miter saw does a pretty good job with the blade I use on it for cutting trim and construction materials. So, it is not that bad. My point was - why should I consider purchasing a new miter saw or blade when (1) I don't have space in my shop to leave it set up full time, (2) mine doesn't give me as accurate a result as my tablesaw equipped with a crosscut sled, and (3) I can handle almost all my crosscutting and miter operations on a piece of equipment I already own and use regularly in the shop.

With a radial arm saw, two band saws, and a cabinet saw available, there is no need for me to use anything else for the kind of cuts we are talking about in my shop. If I had a more accurate miter saw and the room to leave it set up in a dedicated space, I'd probably use it. Since neither one of those holds true for my situation, I stand by what I said.

David