Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Table Saw Purchase

Posts

Table Saw Purchase

#1

Table Saw Purchase

Dwain

>I'm about to purchasse a table saw and for me there are two contenders the Powermatic PM2000 and the Delta 230V SP left tilt 5HP with a Beisemeyer fence and the extension table, and due to the fact that I don't use it as a means of income meanig it's not my job I opted for the Delta based on price, and I figure if I so desire to upgrade in the future I'll just sell the Delta and get what I want.

What I'd like is feedback from you guys as to the Delta VS. The powermatic based on my needs and over all quality. I know from research that the Powermatic is a notch above the Delta due to mechanics but overall from the knowledge I have I think both machines will still deliver good to excellent results, and meet furniture quality standards.

I appreciate any feedback you can give.

Thank you,

Dwain

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#2

Re: Table Saw Purchase

Chuck in ND

>Sounds like overkill to me, but what do I know ?

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#3

Re: Table Saw Purchase

Dan MItchell

>I had a US made Unisaw a few years back, which I sold when I moved, and a PM2000 now. I'd say the PM is more refined than the Unisaw was.

Don't know if you really need 5 horses.

Whatever saw you get, expect to spend an afternoon (or more) tweaking/tuning to get to get decent results.

Dan

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#4

Re: Table Saw Purchase

Jim Dillon

>Dwain,

There was a thread in the past regarding 3 HP vs 5 HP TSs and IIRC, the consensus seemed to be that 5 HP is overkill unless one is in a production workshop cutting big thick stuff all day long. Rest assured, the 3 HP saws can produce "quality furniture" - at least in hands other than my own 8-). I can't speak to either of the saws you are looking at, but one WoodCentral poster had to put a lot of work into getting his new PM running right. Given PM's reputation, I would like to think this was an anomaly. Good luck.

Jim

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#5

Re: Table Saw Purchase

Ralph Turney

>Some thoughts.

Get the saw that gets your blood pumping, the one you day dream about and you WILL be happy with it.

I used a standard Unisaw as a cabinet maker for a couple of years and had, and still have, a PM66 with a 5hp Baldor at home. Even though I liked my PM better and felt great pride of ownership, I had to admit to myself that in reality there was no difference in the actual use of either saw.

With a 3hp saw, if you need to, you can still jam the wood into the blade to stop the saw if things go sideways with a cut...I don't think that's possible with my PM66 and that worries me a little. 5 real horse power is a LOT OF POWER and even though I live by, more is better, it might not be the case in situation.

At this level of table saws, why in the world would you sell it and upgrade...to what, unless you mean to buy a European saw.

My 66 was made in the USA, I'm not sure where any of the saws are made today, but that might be a factor in your decision also.

Let us know what you finally do.

Ralph

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#6

Delta

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have seen a lot more Delta Unisaws (whatever number that is) in cabinet shops in my area than Powermatic in spite of the fact Powermatic used to be made just down the road, so to speak. You will never put significant wear on either machine in a home shop. My Delta is 30+ years old with a 1.5HP motor and I have never seen a need for anything more, nore does it have detectable wear. Over the years I have worked something like 300 bd ft of lumber per year on it. I am presuming the saw you speak of is the modern equivalent to the traditional Unisaw.

Why ever do you need a 5 HP motor? My 1.5 HP rips 8/4 oak just fine. If I was ripping hundreds of feet of 8/4 hardwood I would want more motor than 1.5, but 5 seems extreme.

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#7

Re: Delta - Agreed

North of the Border

>In this " More is better and bigger is better" world (bit not for cars at this point of time), bigger machines are a selling point to some people. But I believe with proper feeding, and if necessary through multiple passes, a 1.5 HP tablesaw can do anything ripping or cross cutting of boards we normally come across. Hardly could I think of a home shop situation where a 5HP machine is needed.

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#8

Mother in a Hummer

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I saw a 95 lb mother with her 4 year old daughter get out of her Hummer H1 in the parking lot this week. This is in a city where most people try to use the golfcart for errands around town.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#9

JL

Re: Table Saw Purchase

JL

>Buy the saw that you will be happiest with for the long term. Don't count on resale value or being able to resell it in a timely fashion. Why waste time with a saw that you don't really want?

A large extension table and fence are really nice. I've got a 50" fence and a large table and I'm very happy with them. Do you need 5 hp - no. As others have said, you can cut a lot of material with a sharp blade and less hp.

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#10

Re: Table Saw Purchase

Bob Burnet (NW Florida)

>Get what you want. Don't worry about the small difference in cost. A couple hundred dollars over a lifetime = a few dollars a year. Agree with others that 5 HP is probably overkill for a 10" cabinet saw unless you are cutting beams or something similar. A proud PM66 owner who likes left tilt Unisaws just as much.

Bob

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#11

Bet they were backing out of a "Compact" space...

Dan MItchell

>

Re: Table Saw Purchase

#12

Ya... 3 compact spaces at once

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>