Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Torsion Box Construction Question

Posts

Torsion Box Construction Question

#1

Torsion Box Construction Question

Howard In Toronto

>Hi all -

I seem to remember reading somewhere that recommended using styrofoam insulation panels inside "skins" to form a lightweight torsion box.

Has anyone here done this?

If so, can you add any particulars about its construction and long term performance.

Thanks.

Howard

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

#2

Ellis Walentine

Insulated torsion boxes

Ellis Walentine

>Hi Howard,

Insulation will definitely add, well, insulation, to torsion boxes. I'm struggling to envision your particular scenario. Can you give us some more info?

Ellis

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

#3

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Sounds like the moral equivalent of a Structural Insulated Panel (SIP), which are ply or OSB panels with a foamed-in-place core in between. You could get the same general effect by gluing panels on either side of a styrofoam sheet. The variables determining strength and longevity are the type of panels, thickness and density of the foam, and how the panwels are adhered to the foam.

What is your intended use?

Clint

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

#4

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

Dan Donaldson

>The strength would depend a lot on the quality of the adhesion between the foam and the skins. The ones that I have built have used and "eggcrate" type of center. The foam might be a little lighter, but unless you need insulation I am not sure of any real advantage.

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

#5

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

Barry Irby

>Clint hit on my thoughts pretty much exactly. My understanding is that the SIPs have ribs in them such as wooden 2x4's. If you glued the skins directly to the blue board, the strength of the panels would depend primarily on the bond strength of the glue line between the plywood and the foam. My intuition on that is that they would be pretty fragile, but I am not sure. You might go to the This to That web site and see if they have a good wood to foam glue. In the SIP's the foam is foamed in place and glues itself to the plywood. If you can find a good glue they might work, but I am still thinking "fragile". Why not make them with wooden ribs? Those definitely work.

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

#6

Ellis - thank you

Howard In Toronto

>Hi Ellis -

Musta misunderstood the concept.

Don't need to do it this way for the insulation - just wanted fast & dirty.

Thank you.

Howard

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

#7

My house and shop are SIPS buildings

john b. southwest Chicago burbs

>There are no ribs "in" the panels only where the panels are connected to each other. The panels are very rigid and strong. In each panel the foam is one piece,not blown in, and OSB is glued on. These type of panels would make great torsion boxes.My roofing panels are 6'x20' and don't bounce when walked on. john b.

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

#8

My thought is that styrofoam is to fragile

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>There are foams of different densities, and I would go with something more dense if it were me.

I don't know how many you need to make, but I would be thinking of using a vacuum bag system to clamp it all together. I have built big one time use bags out of just heavy plastic film, using two sided carpet tape, and rope caulk to seal around wrinkles and hoses.

I can mix and spread a lot of thickened epoxy in the hour of open time before sealing the bag around a stack.

You could probably get better information if you would actually tell what you are wanting to do in more detail.

Re: Torsion Box Construction Question

#9

SIPS *LINK*

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>What you are talking about are structural insulated panels (SIPS). There are lots of resources, but the link below will get you to many of them. They are being used for walls, roofs and floors in houses.

Lee


SIPS