Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

How to keep PT lumber from warping?

Posts

How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#1

How to keep PT lumber from warping?

John E in SC

>My last 2 outdoor projects using pressure-treated lumber have essentially been disasters because of EXTREME warping of the lumber after only a year or so. I built a deck around an above-ground pool about 3 years ago, and a picnic table only a year or 2 ago, and both of these have warped to the point that I'm embarrased to say I built them. The picnic table in particular is almost unusable. Lumber for the picnic table came from the "blue box", and all of it was as straight as I could find when the table was built. The deck lumber came from a very reputable building supply place (the one all the contractors use) here in town. Both areas get full daytime sun. I'll admit I haven't done anything to seal / paint / etc. - would that have helped, and if so how much? I've built other stuff in the past from PT lumber with no significant problems. Is this related to the "new" treatments they're using for PT lumber now? I have another project I'd like to do, but I'm scared to even attempt anything with PT lumber at this point. WOuld appreciate hearing others experiences / thoughts.

John

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#2

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

George Koch

>What type of fastners did you use in the construction of these projects? Screws, handnails, gun nails, etc?

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#3

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>The only recent PT items I've made were a picnic table and benches for my daughter and her family last year. It is a year old now and sits outside all summer. They store it in a shed in the winter. It also was treated with a water seal right after they got it home. I just ate at it about a month ago and it was still straight and flat, no wobble in table or benches. I think the lumber came from the Big Orange store. I also picked out straight pieces and used their "premium" grade to avoid most knots.

Lee


img

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#4

It would help if you could post photos.

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>The problems may be closely related to how the lumber was sawn, and how you use and chose your lumber for each part, and how you fastened them all together.

Learning to read potential problems in individual boards as you go through a stack is something that takes a lot of practice. If you can show these worse boards, I'll bet you will get some information that will help you avoid those mistakes in the future.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#5

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

Barry Irby

>My experience is that treated lumber warps. Let me put that another way, treated lumber warps.

All I have ever seen is Southern yellow pine. A wood that has a pore structure that makes it suitable for treating. They take kiln dried wood and suck the air out of it and then force chemicals into it under pressure and you buy it wetter than it was when it was in the tree. It drys while you watch. Yellow pine has a reputation for warping and treating it seems to put it on steroids.

Some things you can do. Buy lumber that was dried again after it was treated. ADAT (Air Dried After Treatment) or KDAT (Kiln Dried After Treatment). The blue and orange boxes are not going to have this. Shop around for a local yard that has it. I know of one company that carries it in the Richmond, VA area. Having been dried again, you get to pick boards that are straight and have more chance of staying that way. And they are lighter in weight.

You could dry your own, if you are willing to stack some and wait a year or two.

The other thing I try to do is buy pieces way bigger than I need and break them down to size. The theory is that they come from larger/better trees and have fewer defects. (Don't try looking that up, it's my personal theory). I buy 2 x 12's and bust them down to 2 x 4's. I buy 16 foot stuff and cut it down to shorter pieces. I select pieces that don't have heart wood or juvenile wood if I can.

I just built a deck/porch and told the guy to get me 5/4X6 deck boards 16 feet long and I would cut them in half. He got eight footers because they were easier to haul and it saved me the trouble of cutting them. It was a mistake. Nearly every board had the pith of the tree in it and many were split on the ends. The ends were not milled accurately and they were narrower on the ends than in the center. We used them anyway and ran out. Got the last twenty or so in 16's. They were clearly better. Not a lot better, but better.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#6

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

John McGaw

>My experience with PT lumber in general is that it is 1) wet and 2) sawn from parts of logs that are most stressed when drying (I've often found the actual pith of the tree included). The best luck I've had when using it was achieved by being very selective about the grain orientation and then stickering it in the shop under weights and allowing it to dry for an extended period.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#7

Ah the pool deck

Wayne Carson "TX"

>been there done that ended up taking it apart building a steel frame and putting down plastic wood. Cut the treated stuff up and put it in the dumpster as it isn't any good for fire wood either. Put up some fence with 4x4's two years later I had a nice bow all I needed was a rope for the string. If you can really pin it down on the ends and every 16" mid span predrill the holes and screw it down you have a better chance. Except for the shrinkage really bad. The plastic wood "Trex" is better just gets very hot in the summer I can't hardly stand on it so I let my grand kids play in the pool until they get it nice and wet and cooler.

Good luck

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#8

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

John E in SC

>Mostly clipped-head, ring shank, pneumatically-driven nails on the deck, (with a few deck screws, mostly at corners of railings, etc.) All screws on the picnic table. Really didn't seem to make a difference, except that more of the nails have pulled out with wood movement, but even a few of the screws have pulled loose.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#9

Interesting theory...

John E in SC

>I think your theory about bigger boards being better might be right to a point, except that I used only 5/4" 16 footers for the pool deck, and several of these had pulled the nails up to the point that the ends were sticking up 3/4" or so. I went through a month or so and drilled / screwed them down again so they wouldn't be a tripping hazard. The railings are warped much worse than the deck, though, and I think I used 12' 2x4s and 2x6s there, so your theory might have some vailidity.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#10

I think Barry's got it...

John in New Mexico

>Most PT I've ever used was green, not just in color. Some of it has been so wet that it sounded soggy when impacted. Not sure if any oozed when struck with a hammer, but I wouldn't have been surprised with one batch. So any wood that wet is going to move a lot when drying. Put it out in the sun where only one side is exposed and its even worse. Your's may not have been that wet, may not have even been particularly noticable, but I bet it does a lot of its moving between 25 and 15 %MC.

So buy dried lumber if at all possible. If not, stack you wood with stickers and weights and let it dry a bit.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#11

Re:I'm with Wayne

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>I wouldn't use that poisoned stuff for anything anyone is going to walk, sit or eat a meal on. My idea of appropriate use for PT lumber is between concrete and whatever surface I want to use or in the ground to hold something up so it'll be covered. Use the plastic wood or one of the exotics for decking, seating, tabling, etc.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#12

Try this..

John E in SC

>This is a picture of the picnic table. Hope you can see what I'm talking about - it's tough to take a good picture.


img

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#13

The lumberyard guy responds

John Foster

>Here are some of my observations from working at a retail building centre.

1. most pt lumber is shipped from the treating plant soaking wet. I have heard that some of the lumber treaters have sprinkler systems similar to golf courses, to keep the wood wet until it is shipped to the retailers.

2. pt lumber is not sold by grade, and is selected for looks only, one batch of pt may be stud grade and the next from the same supplier may be MSR.

3. from experience, I know that if we don't keep our pt lifts tarped in the summer they will warp in no time, as the sun dries the top sides.

4. I have beautiful pt stockpiled for years in my bush, and under my deck. If you have a place to store your wood for the long term to let it dry down to equilibrium with your local environment, that will help.

5. as others have said use as narrow a width as possible, and as many screws as possible.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#14

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I think the only way to be sure it won't (badly) warp is to purchase kiln dried pressure treated. One option - at least here in Indiana - is to buy Black or Honey Locust and use it instead. The yard I have purchased from (Hollingsworth) carries it at a pretty reasonable price. It was about $1.40 /bf for KD last I bought a couple years ago. The salesman at the yard told me several people had planed it and used it for decks. As I recall he said some didn't use the KD but just had the green wood planed and fastened it down. Don't know if I would do this but I sure would use the KD anywhere outside. It is, IMHO a pretty good wood for furniture and is an extremely durable wood. In a wet environment, I expect it to last 30 to 50 years. As farmers used to say a locust post will outlast 2 post holes.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#15

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

del schisler

>also i belive if you put the growth rings all down or up I forgot which Some one may chime in on this Been a while sence i built tables now But that will help But most lumber like from the borgs are not the best

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#16

So should we use untreated wood ...

Hamish

>Having read through all the threads, I wonder if a better solution would be to build your outside projects out of untreated wood, ie drier wod, and then treat them at the end. After all, PT wood when cut becomes exposed, revealing a white core with a green ring around the outside.

I have been told that using varnishes with a colour tint in them are good protection against uv light and that these varnishes should be the type that soak in to the wood and not form a film on the surface.

What do you guys think?

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#17

doesn't show much

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>Now can you show what is going on underneath?

The first board on the left looks like it should be ok, the next on in may have been cut from a tree with a bit of butt flair, but not bad. The next one over was cut from a fairly crooked stem.

Probably most of your problem is underneath. If your plan only has little cross members to screw the top boards to, with nothing up on edge running in the direction with the deck boards, then that is your problem.

As the Sun hits and warms up the top surface, then naturally the top will dry faster than the rest. It will dry and shrink while the bottom half is still has a much higher MC. Then it rains, and everything gets saturated again, and the cycle is repeated over and over.

Add to the tendency to warp up on the ends, is the across grain cupping action. This is what is really hard on fasteners. If you were to fasten the boards tight against each other, they would likely have close to a 3/8" space between them when they dry down to the driest they will get. That is equivalent to about 1/16" for each 1".

As for fasteners, it is good to keep the above statement in mind. Rather than spacing the nails or screws wide across the face, and drive straight through, I like to move them in a little, then angle them in toward the center about 15 ~ 20�, which brings the exit hole even closer at the interface with the joist member by even less. THis does a couple of things which I think are beneficial. First, is reduces the shrinkage between the fasteners by 1/16", and because of the angle between the two fasteners, the wedging action pulls them tighter to the joist.

When the next rain wets the deck boards from top down, the compression of the swelling on the aforementioned cupped top, reverses the action, which is better in this configuration than when they are wider and straight in, which is what causes fasteners to back out.

Sorry for getting so long here.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#18

NO, forget trying that.

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>You can not even start to treat lumber yourself as good as pt.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#19

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

John K Jordan

>>...Is this related to the "new" treatments they're using for PT lumber now?

I think it's more related to the individual pressure treatment facility. When buying boards and fence posts at a local facility recently, the owner said some treaters don't dry the wood properly. They kiln dry boards before treatment. He said some treat boards when they are not quite dry, causing problems with the chemical saturation as well as with stability. Note that all PT boards come out of the treatment soaking wet so you can't tell if a board was put in green or just came out wet.

Given the sad state of almost everything else in almost every industry these days, if I had the time and the space I would consider air-drying new pressure treated lumber before use. Stack it and weight it just like green wood and let it sit under a cover for as long as possible. This cuts down significantly on the shrinkage as well.

That said, I've built a lot of decks and I think the best defense against warping is in the support and fastening. If well constrained, even a green board will tend to remain flat as it dries. I always used at least three deck screws at every joist for 6" boards with carriage bolts for all understructure. The extensive decking I built at my last house doesn't have one visible warped board. The deck already here when we moved to the farm was put together with nails (and too few of them) and it is in pitiful shape. I would design something like a picnic table with wood or steel constraints under the free ends of the boards.

JKJ

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#20

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

Pat Barber

>1. All pressure treated wood should be dried in a

sheltered environment for as many days as possible

prior to use. They should be stickered and fully

supported the entire length.

2. Use maximum supporting structure for any pt project.

That picture shows boards bowing from lack of support.

3. I don't care for 5/4 boards as flooring. They tend

to cup and warp at the same time.

The KDAT grade would be great if you could find it.

Using syp pt lumber requires patience and practice.

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#21

Ditto that

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>PT is horrible and I hate working with it. Termites love to eat through it. It's toxic. It's heavy. Wet. and it pretzels.

I just built some 6' fence and while the 4x4 were good everything else either came crooked or it twisted before, duering or after it was nailed up.

And the fence section I built last year is covered with a dark black mold growing on it. What the heck is PT lumber good for if termites and black mold lover it so much.

I hate the stuff and feel like an idiot for using it. I would never use it for a table, won't use it again for a desk and really don't have much choice for a fence.

The tree house I built from untreated pine, which I the old fashioned way, is doing better than the new PT junk.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: How to keep PT lumber from warping?

#22

Re: So should we use untreated wood ...

Kneale Brownson dreaming of snow in N. MI

>My parents had a picnic table made from pine 2X8s that had very straight and tight grain. Kind of stuff you'd use for structural members. It had a spar varnish on it. It sat outside summer and winter. I bet I sanded and reapplied spar varnish on that table and its companion bench seats four or five times in the 30 years before they stopped using it. I think my brother had it at his cottage another 10 years before he lost the cottage through divorce. Don't know if it's still in use today, but if I'd had it I'm sure it still would be. Other than occasional refinishing, the only precautions were the legs sat on some sort of paver rather than directly on the ground, and there was always a tin top from a coffee can between the wood and the stone. The benches were overturned onto the top of the table during winter months.

I might use PT as legs for such a table today, but I sure wouldn't use it for seat and table tops. Ever get a PT splinter? Ever read the cautions that you should wash your hands after handling it? Why would you eat off it?