Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

Posts

Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#1

Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>My son is looking into buying a fairly upscale home that has been forclosed and on the market for a while. Neighbors say the house has been flooded three times. Latest time was when the house was uninhabited, pipes froze and the when thawed, caused water damage in first floor from pipes above and roughly 12" deep in basement for an extended period. All drywall has been removed in basement. Sump still running and no rain here for some time. Water heater is leaking very slowly so small area on basement floor is damp. Grading around the house is obviously pitched TO the house, not away from it. That's my assessment as to why the sump is still running.

When you walk into the house, you instantly smell the musty odor from what I believe is the basement. Kind of like an old damp barn or warehouse. The home has been treated for mold resulting from the water damage. But the odor is still pervasive. No dehumidifier in basement. AC not running. Cold air return registers have little rust spots on them.

My son is extremely handy and is capable of performing all repairs needed, as long as there's a defined list of things to be done. The big mystery factor to me is the musty odor. I know Barry Irby is a home inspector and hope he weighs in here. Is ther a sure fire way to kill that odor after an extended period of dampness? I know I've done it on old furniture with a thorough coating of shellac inside and out. But we're talking an entire home here. I recall Nalco Chemical sending a mobile ozone generator to disinfect and deodorize homes after floods, but that was after short term flooding.

This house is potentially a $600,000 home based on comparables in the neighborhood. The bank owns it and is selling as-is. Buyer negotiates whatever deal they can get. How do you verify that mold is not growing in the ductwork? Or should he just walk away? The house has Dryvit exterior too. But that can definitely be inspected and repaired if moisture is an issue.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#2

Sounds like . . .

steve mackay

>a gut from here. At least the basement, first floor and HVAC systems. Was damp / wet WAY to long. You mentioned that its graded TO the house wich might as well be adressed FIRST. AND, as long as we're doing that, better re-seal the enitire foundation with a VERY good seal / drainage system. If its flooded three (?) times its gonna do it again. Pretty big project. I'd say that unless he can get it from the bank for pennies on the dollar its better left for the big boys. A do-it-yourselfer might be walking into a money pit WAY bigger than he counted on.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#3

Sounds like a tear-down

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#4

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

Barry Irby

>Without seeing it, it is difficult to tell what you should you do.

If the conditions are severe, tearing it down and starting over may not be out of the question.

Inspect it carefully. Mold needs four things, Oxygen, warmth, a food source and water. So do we. The one we can control is the moisture. Having allowed the house to get wet allowed the mold to get started. It turns out that you must let the moisture get exceptionally high for a number of weeks to burst the spores and let it get going. Once it is growing, it is difficult (nearly impossible) to dry out the house enough to actually kill the mold.

The current wisdom seems to be to dry out the house and clean it thoroughly to remove the mold. Just took some training on this. The company that was explaining the technique used baking soda in a sand blaster and blasted the mold off the surfaces. This process also includes a vacuum system to suck up the soda and debris and then a separate vacuuming with a HEPA vac. There are others that use frozen carbon dioxide to blast the mold off the surfaces.

I failed to mention that the first thing is to remove and throw away anything like carpet and drywall etc.

There are companies that can come in and clean the interior of ducts.

The problem is that the industry is fraught with con men and wild unsubstantiated claims. We are very much in the snake oil phase.

The cleaning above is very expensive, and does nothing to assure you the mold will not simply re-establish itself. To prevent it returning, you must modify the habitat. Lower the moisture content below the level that will sustain the mold and keep it low.

You are right about the exterior. The grading must slope away from the house, preferably about an inch (or more) to the foot for about ten feet. As mentioned by others, the real deal here is to dig up the exterior and do it right. (Install excellent waterproofing and drainage at the footing level) Doing exterior water proofing on a finished house is expensive and very disruptive. You can try removing some of the topsoil around the perimeter and replace it with a foot or more of clay soil (called Clay Capping) and make sure the clay slopes away form the house, but once the water has established paths into the house, it is difficult to convince it to go elsewhere. The difficulty and expense of doing this well and on the exterior is the genesis of the interior systems such as B-Dry. (The only people that really promote the interior systems are the people selling them.)

We used to suggest you treat the interior with a bleach solution. This is now frowned upon. The bleach does usually kill the existing crop of mold, but does nothing to prevent it reoccurring. It also may break down or weakening the structure of the molds and allow them to float out into the air, where you inhale them. Apparently your system can not tell the difference between live mold and dead mold, so the bleach may be a bad idea.

The other rule of thumb is that if there is less than ten square feet of mold, you can clean it up yourself, more than that and you should bring in the pro's.

The professional you want to deal with on this is and Industrial Hygienist. Not some local Home Inspector who took one day of training and are working as shills for the mold industry.

Check out the web site at BuildingScience.com. Joe Lstiburek is the guy behind it and he may be the best building scientist in the country.

The Home Inspection business has seen a number of things over the years that generated huge excitement. Aluminum wire, lead paint, PB pipe, Treated Wood, Etc. etc, and now Mold. In my opinion we are a bit over the top on it, but the reason I stay out of it is that it affects each of us differently. I have been going in wet moldy basements and dank crawls spaces almost every day for over twenty years, with no apparent ill effects, other than I used to be taller and better looking. OTOH, some people are severely affected.

Your son needs to take his family to the house and let them spend an hour or two. If no one is bothered, then he might want to take the house. If someone sniffles or sneezes, or their eyes water or swell, some reaction to the mold, then get out and don't do it.

Its a brutal process. Stripping out/cleaning, and fixing the water problem. An early step is to get the place dehumidified, either by getting the AC going or renting big dehumidifiers or both.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#5

Barry Convinced Me

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>to run away from it real fast. Perhaps that mold problem/solutions is why it has been on the market for so long.

George

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#6

Me? You mean me?

Barry Irby

>If you could buy this house for a substantial discount, say 50% and get it for $300,000 and spend $100,000 to 150,000 to put it right, it might be a bargain. The situation in the economy has an impact. If it were in perfect shape would it really sell for $600K? And once it is fixed, is there a stigma? Will it always be the "Mold House". If you believe the house would really sell for more like $500K and it's going to cost over $150K to fix it then you should probably run away fast. But if you think it will not be stigmatised and you plan to live in it long enough for the market to recover and the memory of the problem to fade away, go for it.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#7

Look for another house.

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca,

>Not sure how fat your son's wallet is, but there are going to be other houses on the market that won't require near as much work or worry. He could very well be stepping into some unforeseen health issues, from the mold, that could get him bedridden, further delaying the work, and depleting funds.

That house sounds like it was built wrong from the get go. Pass on it.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#8

Beat Feet

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>There are too many such "deals" around to get snagged on such a questionable opportunity.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#9

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

Fred Davis

>Barry was doing good until the next to last sentence.

Using the family for Guinea pigs won't fix all of the drainage problems, HVAC problems, drywalling the interior etc.

That is analogous to the old practice of coal miners using Canaries to check for Methane.

I and my pardner used to enter into partnership if you will with Banks who were overloaded with REO portfolios and this is what we did.

We would purchase the residence on a 100% construction loan which was converted to a thirty year mortgage after ninety days had elapsed , which we figured would let my partner and me get the work done and turn it over to a real estate agent to sell.

Because the economy was like now and the housing market even worse then now, this worked out very well for two carpenters who were eager beavers and a lot more frisky then now . ;-))

The two main points your son needs to consider very carefully is what the purchase price should be and what a realistic assessment of the cost to bring the house into compliance will be .

If he can do the major portion of the cosmetic work to be done, that's all to the good, mechanical trades, plumbing, electrical and mold control is a job for those that do it every day.

That all being said, there is probably a better deal house wise and money wise , then this one.

Look around some more, good deals are being made everyday because of the mess the economy is in .

Good Luck,

FredD

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#10

Fred's right, but.....

Barry Irby

>using the family for Guinea Pigs will answer the otherwise unanswered half of the question.

There are many thousands of types of mold. Of those, about thirty have been identified as being harmful to humans. Humans are very different in their reactions, even to the harmful ones. You can go in and clean the house and dry it out as thoroughly as possible, even to an extreme, but you will not know you have been successful until the family gives it the sniff test. Some people's reactions are more sensitive than our abilities to detect or clean the mold. (OTOH, if anyone in your family were highly allergic to mold, you would know that and would not be considering this at all.)

Using the family as Guinea Pigs is somewhat risky. If any of them react severely, it could be a real problem. Of course, it would be better to know that up front than when you move into your supposedly mold free home. And, some of it could be psychosomatic, but that is important to know, too. If the reaction is real or imagined, run away fast.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#11

Thanks, but the odor question is still unanswered.

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Has anyone found a way to rid the home of it? I'm pretty much convinced the house probably has no active mold remaining. But it still smells musty, kinda like old furniture that's been in storage too long. Asuming we get all other issues resolved, that is still a concern. Nobody wants to live in a home that is always gonna smell like grandma's cellar.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#12

Re: Thanks, but the odor question is still unanswe

Barry Irby

>Tim, The odor is most probably moisture related. Wet things tend to stink and dry things tend not to. If you get he dehumidifiers and AC going the air movement, drying and filtering of the air should reduce it. Removing the mold and moldy materials will help also.

The ozone generators mentioned may also help, but I am a little sceptical. You can rent them, but you need a fairly high dose of it to be effective. Or maybe my nose is burnt out form being in too many crawl spaces.

It is also possible to buy air filters that have activated charcoal in them and you can buy systems that have UV light in them as well. Again, I am scheptical. I have no idea how much air you can pass through activated charcoal before it is "used up", but I suspect its not a months worth. As for the UV stuff, I did a little research and could not fain any definitive data indicating that passing air and a thousand CFM through a duct with a UV light in it would actually kill the air borne spores and mold.

If the house is not really nasty, I think just getting the systems running and cleaning it thoroughly will help a lot. You needs some air movement and some air exchange or fresh air.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#13

Re: Thanks, but the odor question is still unanswe

steve mackay

>The odor remains, probably, because it has ( with three floods )permeated the drywall, insulation,wood, concrete and every other porous material and surface in the house. For most materials this means removal. No matter the treatment, the next time it gets damp, or even hummid, the problem will recure.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#14

It'll be perpetual ambiance

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#15

Re: Thanks, but the odor question is still unanswe

Curly Smith

>Modern homes tend to be very air-tight. They have very little to no air exchange so odors will linger for an extraordinarily long time. Have you ever visited a friend on Friday and known what they had to eat Monday?

To get rid of the odor you need to:

- remove any currently wet/moist material

- remove any carpet or padding that was wet (or cover with liberal amounts of baking soda - you can also buy a carpet product that's designed to remove odors (apply it and then vacuum))

- exchange the interior air several thousand times (put box fans in some windows to pull air in, put fans in other windows to exhaust the air (a whole house fan would be a good alternative)) ==> the key is air circulation

- put fans in the basement to circulate that air as well

---> note that this will take several days (at least)

- install an activated charcoal filter unit in the basement like Barry mentioned once you get the odor levels down to more manageable levels

FWIW, I think you're right about the problem. It sounds like more of mildew problem from a damp basement than a serious mold issue. However, the dirt work and landscaping needed to fix the issue might be prohibitively expensive. I'd get an estimate from a hydrologist/landscape architect and, as a minimum, double the cost estimate.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#16

Two other things

Curly Smith

>Mop the basement floor with a weak bleach solution to kill any mold/mildew that might be growing. Keep the floor damp with the bleach solution for at least 30 minutes.

Check to see if the sump pump has the option for adding chlorine tablets and add some if it does. Otherwise, get some pool tablets and drop one in the every few days to kill anything that might be growing in the sump.

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#17

Re: Thanks, but the odor question is still unanswe

Fred Davis

>That would be my thinking and it reminded me of the worst case of pollution I ran across in Castro valley , CA.

A Dentist called me out on a weekend to see if I could help him put a developer in jail, he was that mad.

He and his wife along with about five other families had bought new semi-custion built split-level homes in a area that was below the street above where the sewage pipe was.

The developer had bought off the planning commission and they let him use a 12 thousand gallon septic tank between the homes and the street above with a float actuated check valve that would pump up to the next level all of the sewage above two feet in the tank.

Needless to say the back flow check portion of the valve failed and everybody had two feet of sewage in the bottom story of their split level type homes.

Long story short , when I got there it had been about a week since the drywall had been stripped four feet up the studs.

He had a professional cleaning crew in there and I could not detect any foul order and it was a hot summer day.

Of course the humidity was about 5 percent.

So it's probably one of those , "you don't know until after you lived there awhile" situations which is a risky investment anyway you look at it.

FredD

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#18

Trust your nose, forget that house.

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca,

>

Re: Very OT - home musty odor after extended flood

#19

Re: Here's the deal...

Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay Area

>Can your guy take the risk?

Not just the money. The time. The flack from the wife that comes when stuff takes longer than everyone wants it to. The potential that you don't get it all, and have to go back and redo all of it.

I worked for a guy who did this with a house on a California hill that had slipped. He paid the engineers, did what they told him, rebuilt everything that needed rebuilding. Lived there for 6 or 8 years, and it slipped again. In another place. He couldn't fix it, and bankruptcy was in the game then. It was a good deal, right up until the driveway went sliding...

It takes the right situation to take on these challenges. Make sure you're up to it.