Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Reading your boards- Growth Rings

Posts

Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#1

Reading your boards- Growth Rings

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Reading your boards Growth Rings

Growth rings tell a story beyond how long the tree lived. How fast a tree grows strongly affects the appearance of boards sawed from it, especially so for ring porous woods like oak, ash and walnut. In the spring these species grow quickly and add a porous layer of wood. Late in the year growth slows and a dense layer of wood is added to this porous layer. The sum of these layers is one growth ring, or one year�s growth. The density and color of these layers are different. The growth rings show up on the surface of the board as alternating bands of light and dark color and alternating bands of porous and nonporous wood. If a tree grows slowly these bands will be more closely spaced than for a fast growing tree. This difference in spacing will change the appearance as show in the picture.

The tree that produced the left board grew about �� per year compared to the right where the growth was a scant 1/16� per year. In fact, the growth rings on the right are so closely spaced they can not be see in this reduced resolution picture. Note the difference in appearance of the two boards. Veneer log buyers used to be very picky about the growth ring spacing of the logs they bought because they were buying longs to yield a particular appearance in the veneer. I once bought some very fine oak white oak logs that had been rejected for veneer because the growth rings were too close.

Less apparent is the difference in working properties. Rapid growth ring porous wood will be substantially more dense than slow growth, as well as harder. I have seen white oak boards where the growth rings are less than 1/16�and it is as light as poplar and as soft to work. I am currently working some very slow growth walnut that is less dense than average poplar lumber. Slow growth wood shrinks less upon drying. Slow growth wood will not be as strong as faster growing wood because the cells formed in the spring are thinner and larger than the cells that form later in the growth season.

Of all these factors that differentiate faster growth from slow growth wood, appearance is the most important in building furniture. When matching pieces it may be important to choose boards that have grown at approximately the same rate to get a good match in a panel or table top.


img

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#2

PS

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the obvious lines you see in the end grain piece on the right are not the growth rings, which are perpendicular to these "lines". These lines are the rays. They are cell that transport material radially in the tree. They are very prominent in oak and they form the flakes when oak is quarter sawn.

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#3

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

Adam Cherubini

>Is the end grain cut for the left sample flipped left to right?

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#4

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>Very interesting, Bill. This puts paid to what I was taught, obviously erroneously, that slow growth made better timber because eit was stronger. What we learn in school, or perhaps "remember", is often "interesting".

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#5

Very interesting post. Thanks!

Jesse Cloud

>

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#6

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

Barry Irby

>Very interesting and the paragraph about the characteristics is exactly the opposite of what I thought and seems counter intuitive. I would have thought slow growth timber would be heavier, stronger and denser, having what I would have thought to be a larger percentage of late wood.

This seems opposite to the fast grown pine used for framing lumber. The lumber that has as few as two or three growth rings per inch is light and soft. Wonder if this is different for soft woods/conifers?

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#7

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>the end grain slices are properly on top of what they were cut from, but they are not oriented as they came from their respective boards as you observed.

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#8

explanation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>in the spring trees put on a burst of growth...give it all they got. If that is most all the growing they do for the year, because of lack of water, nutrients, light, etc, the bulk of the wood made for the year will be "spring wood". In the case of the ring porous woods-oak, ash, walnut- this spring wood has large thin-walled cells and leads to light, soft relatively weaker lumber.

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#9

Re: explanation

Fred Davis

>While doing about thirty years of buying in CA from J. E. Higgins Hardwood Lumber which is the leading chain of wholesale yards in CA. and Nev. that cater to cabinets shops, contractors etc., I observed the following.

If White Ash, a semi-ring porous wood which I used the most was grown in the southern parts of the country like Texas , it was soft, relatively weak and light compared to the White Ash grown in the Northern woods.

This according to Higgins, Bruce Hoadley and others is due to the fast growing of the tree because of temperate climate and longer growing season.

The Harsher climate in the North woods produced much denser, harder, and darker wood.

The Oak lumber they furnished also followed that track and they got much more for the Northern Oak then Southern because of the ideal working characteristics of wood grown in deep winter country.

The Oaks , Walnut, Maples on the west coast are used very little , all for the above reasons.

The Oak is used for firewood and the Juglans Nigra walnut is a pale version of that family , that until they started making flooring and some paneling from it was totally ignored.

Anyhow that's what I learned from dealers , scientists, and actually using the stuff.

FredD

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#10

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Interesting discussion, but your selection of sample boards is a bit confusing. The problem is that the piece of end grain on the right was cut from the quarter/rift sawn part of the board, while the piece on the left is from a flat sawn section.

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#11

follow up

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I did not think that statements about working properties and growth rate would be controversial. While there can be substantial differences in the properties and appearance of lumber from trees grown in different climates, this discussion was on the effects of growth rate for trees grown in the same climate. Given the interest,I will post at some time in the future how climate affects the appearance of lumber, especially cherry and oak.

The following will not be news to any one who has nailed oak flooring. You dread having to deal with fast growth boards, ones with the growth rings 1/4" or greater. They can bend flooring nails, while the slow growth boards are easily nailed. In the original picture the board on the right is 50 or more percent spring wood. This is the wood that has thin, big cell walls. This board has a lot of empty space in it and it is easily nailed as a result. The board on the left is more than 80% summer late wood which is essentially non porous and hard as, well, oak.

In the picture below I have easily driven a #6 finish nail into this white oak with growth rings less than 1/16". It saws as easily as poplar, all because it has a large fraction of spring wood. It grew somewhere nearby in E. TN. But it grew slowly, probably in a dense shaded woods.


img

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#12

I'm still baffled..........

Barry Irby

>Bill, I enjoy and appreciate your posts on lumber tremendously. But I am struggling with this one. Tell me where I am going wrong. It seems to me that the spring wood is the lighter and often thicker part of the ring. Light in color that is. And I thought it was lighter in weight and not as dense and hard as the darker summer wood. The summer or late season wood is darker, denser and harder and I thought heavier. So, it seems to me that fast grown wood would have a larger percentage of the lighter spring wood and less of the late season wood and would therefore be lighter in weight over all and less dense and tough than slow growth timber that has growth rings composed of nearly equal amounts of spring wood and late season wood.

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#13

Re: that is true for softwoods

Dave Mount

>What Bill said isn't necessarily in conflict with what you were taught. Note that Bill said "for ring porous woods" like oak and ash. For softwoods the densities of the earlywood and latewood are reversed, so slowly growing softwoods are harder than those that grow fast. Some tables of wood properties actually give different properties for old growth (aka slowly growing in this context) and second growth wood. Redwood is a great example -- a piece of old growth redwood is actually pretty dense and heavy, but one of second growth putting on 3/8" in radius per year is practically cork by comparison.

I once did some work for a RR tie treating facility. They told me that there are standards for different wood species for use as RR ties. In accordance with what Bill said, for ring porous species like oak and ash there was a minimum growth rate that had to be met. For softwoods, there was a maximum growth rate. Both of these standards were intended to regulate the properties of the wood so softer, weaker wood wouldn't be used.

Red oak from up in these parts (northeastern MN), what little there is, has a very delicate figure because the porous rings are not only frequent, they are also thin. Gives oak a whole different character than the bold arches you see in most commercial oak.

Best,

Dave

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#14

Please explain the term . . .

Paul Leuba

>. . . "ring pourous wood".

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#15

Re: I'm still baffled..........

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>" It seems to me that the spring wood is the lighter (and often thicker part of the ring......no). Light in color that is. And I thought it was lighter in weight and not as dense and hard as the darker summer wood. The summer or late season wood is darker, denser and harder and I thought heavier." ........... Correct, except in the original post where I stained the end grain to unsuccessfully make things clearer.

So, it seems to me that fast grown wood would have a larger percentage of the lighter spring wood and less of the late season wood...... Not correct

on the left side of this board the tree was young and growing rapidly, probably because it had not gotten competition for light and nutrients. As it grew the growth rate slowed. Note that in its slow growth phase the spring and late wood are about equal while the late wood predominates in the fast growth phase.

When I am selecting poplar for drawer sides (where I will be hand planing it to fit) I will select the slowest growth log I can find. It will have a butttery texture and plane sooo nice) Fast growth (what we call field poplar) will be much harder and heavier.

Now I think mahogany is just the opposite. The plantation mahogany, which I presume is gown quickly, is soft and light and not very attractive.

Dang, all this picture taking is keeping me from the 56 dovetails I need to saw for the domed lidded trunk project. (14 done so far, over 15' of total sawing!)


img

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#16

Ring porous explained

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Examples of ring porous woods are walnut, oak, ash and hickory. These species are characterized by making a layer of porous wood during the initial part of their yearly growth followed by a layer of nonporous wood during the remainder of the growing season. So each growth ring (1 year of growth)has a porous portion followed by a nonporous portion. Look at the picture in the reply to Barry to see an example, in this case red oak.

In contrast, wood like maple and cherry do not lay down a porous layer of wood in the spring growth phase. Except for the darker color of the late growth wood there is not clear distinction between the early and late wood made each year.

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#17

Re: Ring porous explained

Fred Davis

>What Bill said in his explanation of "Ring Porous wood" was mostly right with a couple of corrections.

Walnut is not a Ring Porus wood.

Maple is a Diffuse Porous wood like birch basswood , willow etc. which is a more scattered construction across the log .

Cherry and Walnut form a intermediate group between Ring Porus and Diffuse Porus woods.

I can direct you to Bruce Hoadley's treatise online which is a good long and understandable article by a renowned wood scientist.

FredD

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#18

Dale Lenz

Re: Please explain the term . . . *LINK*

Dale Lenz

>Check out the site below, does a good job of explaining the difference lay down of wood types plus a lot of other good info.


Wood info

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#19

Dale Lenz

Re: Opps

Dale Lenz

>Near the bottom of the linked page above clink on: U Tenn Wood ID Publication, very good information.

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#21

Ring-porous, etc

John K Jordan

>Here's a picture I posted a while back showing the ring-porous nature of elm. I took it by holding a small digital camera up to the eyepiece of a low-power microscope.

Note that it's not that the latewood is non-porous but the pores are just very small compared to the band of larger pores in the earlywood. While the photo is not very good, you can easily see the distinct band of large pores and the wavy bands of tiny pores characteristic of elm.

If you are interested in this subject, it's hard to do better than get couple of books by R. Bruce Hoadley, "Understanding Wood" and "Identifying Wood". Hoadley describes the categories that help organize various wood species for identification, noting that ring porous woods are classified by both the size and location of pores in a distinct band.

Hoadley notes that although cherry, for example, "has a distinct row of pores, they are quite small", moving it into the diffuse-porous category. He describes species like walnut and persimmon as "semi-ring-porous", where pores in the early wood are large but show a gradual decrease in size towards the latewood. He notes that individual samples can show wide variability, making these classifications fuzzy at times. To confuse things further, not all experts agree on the names of the groups!

JKJ


img

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#22

Re: Ring-porous, etc

Fred Davis

>The pores in the latewood appear to be small because the sidewall of the pores are thicker then the early or spring wood.

It is this thickness of the Summer wood that gives the strength and density, therefore hardness to the wood.

Your right about Hoadley , but in the article I quoted him from, he describes Cherry and Walnut as being in a intermediate group between Diffuse and ring porous.

All of that learned discourse is good to read , but in a practical sense of wood use, after handling and looking at tens of thousands of board feet of hardwood, you get a feel for what your looking for , just by handling it, no hand lens or electron scanning microscope being handy just at the moment.

FredD

Re: Reading your boards- Growth Rings

#23

Great Explanations! - Thanks

Paul Leuba

>