>If that $10 filter is made "for" Sears, it's junk too.
That thing might be 1-1/4 horse, but the motor fans are tissue paper, will clog, and the motor will smoke. $18 means they're trying to unload them at actual cost.
>Contrary to what some may think that is a very good price on a wet/dry vacuum. I have a old Sears wet/dry unit that I have used for a long time. Of course I also have two Fein units also. People bash Sears products all of the time, usually because of prejudice rather than facts.
>I just picked it up at Sears and am looking at it and wondering how anything would get by the filter to the motor; which on this particular vac, appears to have a metal fan.
I think it will work just fine for the dry wall project I have coming up. I sure didn't want to subject my Fein to that abuse.
If this lasts for the year it's warranteed for... I'll be happy.
it's because of the facts that people are disinchanted with Sears products.
Of course people will believe what they want to regardless, but really, 6 H.P., just think a minute, thats twice as powerful as a 3 H.P. quality table saw rated for continous duty and running on 240 V. at that.
They are notorious for using the phrase "developes 3 horse power" or what ever.
>Don't believe I ever stated that I necessarily believed the claim of a conventional 6hp. I would think that today's society is accustom to these carefully worded claims.
However, being an electrical engineer, let me tell you that a purposefully designed electric motor, can easily achieve an inertial peak horsepower of 6 or more.
>Not. But know at least 2 who had them. "Them" being the 16gal "Crafts"man things. The fan unit is metal, but reported to me to be thin guage and prone to clog with fine dust. One guy had vanes break loose in the fan unit just [you guessed it] shortly after the warranty expired. Between parts and labor, Sears wanted more to repair it than a new vac cost at Lowes!!!
$18 for a year's use? Maybe you have a deal, and I don't mean to rain on your parade, but what used to be a proud American brand standing for quality and durability at a fair price has been transformed into a purveyor of junk. I'll happily pay more elsewhere.
"6 hp" . . . . Man, you don't want to even lift a real 6 horse power electric motor. That "Peak" BS or not, I don't buy lies, and since they're so willing to lie to and deceive their customers about such a simple thing, I'll infer that the rest of their product is likewise falacious.
>Believe what you want Fred but a lot of the Sears bashing is due to prejudices. Vacuum cleaners are notorious for being rated as "peak HP" or some such. You can't compare those ratings with more conventional HP ratings. Most people here realize that. The vacuums sold at the borgs and hardware stores use the same rating system as Sears. If you are saying that the mentioned Sears vacuum doesn't compare to a Fein you are absolutely correct but notice the difference in price before you start bashing the Sears unit.
The last Sears power tool that I purchased was their bench top mortiser which I purchased a couple of years ago. In performance it compares well with the other bench top machines and I saved about $50 by buying the Sears unit at the time.
>Get the bags. No joke. They will greatly extend the life of your vac. Fine dust, like from sanding drywall, will clog the plaited filter in seconds, and proceed to cause the motor to overspeed and burn up. Not to mention, trying to suck up the drywall dust will be agonizingly slow. Night and day difference with the bags (leave the plaited filter in the shop vac).
I agree with you. I use the bags in my Feins in addition to the paper filter. I don't think vacuums are ever the same after a drywall project so I'm viewing this one as disposable.
>Howard, as one who used to have a whole bunch of Craftsman equipment and Sears products, I will have to say it is not prejudice that caused me to replace them. The last refrigerator I purchased from Sears was less than 4 years old when shelf brackets and edges broke, and the drawers slide area cracked on 2 drawers. The Kenmore sweeper lasted about 3 years before the wand clips broke and the hose disintegrated - my wife said no more Kenmore. My Craftsman drill (industrial model) developed a loose bearing that supports the chuck. My Router depth stop didn't stop (moved during routing operations) and the chuck slipped. The many attachments I had for the router, saws & grinder didn't work as advertised (none were accurate). A Craftsman grinder I have is made of plastic (sure looked like metal when I bought it), and vibrates badly even with new trued wheels. My band saw (tilt head - top of the line that year) didn't have sufficient power and the blade tracking sucked. I purchased the 60 gal craftsman compressor, and it failed twice in less than a year - I got my money back after some arguments and purchased a CH. In my opinion the Craftsman name denoted professional quality products in the 1930 through the 1960's. After that time they joined Skill and Black and Decker seeking the low end consumer market. Low priced tools meant to be purchased by homeowners in the millions - not meant for the serious woodworker or hobbyist that heavily uses the tools and expects high accuracy. I'm sure they do have some tools that will meet expectations - but IMHO most won't meet mine. I don't really fault them for the marketing tactic they chose. There is far more money to be made in the market they chose then the high quality, high priced tools used by serious hobbyists and professionals as there is far less sold. If you want a real bargain, try going to a few estate auctions. I have seen craftsman table saw go for $5.00, 3/8" drills for $2 & routers for $10 - all looked fairly new. At the same sales Porter cable, Dewalt, Ridgid, etc. tools fetched over half the retail price.
I gotta hand to you guy , first time I ever heard lying and deceptive advertising called "carefully worded claims " That would easily qualify you as a "spin doctor " for any politician that comes to mind ;-))
on the old American Woodworker forum, they were routinely referred to as Crapsmen tools and the rule of thumb that was applied to a prospective purchase was "if it has moveing parts or a motor ,don't buy it"
>Actually Howard I was not bashing Sears per Se, I will get to that in a minute tho Mark was right on in his assessment.
Couple of factotums to consider and I don' care which brand we are talking about , Harbor Freight, Grizzly,Sears, formerly Trendlines etc. if they advertised a six horse power small vacuum and by some miracle it could draw the current of a true 6 H.P. unit , it would catch on fire immediately.
It would also if it was a true 3 H.P. unit.
Secondly the suction rating of vacuums are measured by the height of a column of water they raise measured in inches, not Horse Power.
I wasn't aware of "conventional horse power ratings", but if I was a wife or girl friend buying one of those and it said 6 H.P. then it must be true , right?
About Sears per se, on the old American Woodworker Forum, their tools were know as "Crapsman" and the rule of thumb one observed when buying one was "if it had a moving part or a motor don't".
>One of the great functions of a forum is the dissemination of information like this.
I'm neutral about Sears products, myself. If they are good, I'm happy; if not, I'm not, and they usually replace defective items, especially tools, without any questions. I recently returned a tree-branch lopper and a shovel, both of which broke in normal use and got refunds in both cases. I like their house paint, although it's probably not worth what I pay for it. I like a lot of their tools and hardware, too. My point is that you need to have a critical eye when you're buying something and know a bargain when you see one.
I've owned a couple of Sears wet/dry shop vacs over the years, including a 16-gal model, though I think that was in the days when they were still calling it 4.5 HP. Nobody believes the horsepower ratings on universal motors, so I refuse to get up in arms about that. They're only competing with the other hucksters; dog-eat-dog-eat-dog. You don't depend on the horsepower rating anyhow.
My biggest gripe with my shop vac was the noise. Sears universal motors are famous for their noisiness and inefficiency. We tested routers on a dynamometer once, to try to get to the bottom of the horsepower issue, and found out some pretty interesting things, one of which was that the Sears 3HP router was the most powerful one on the market. (This was in 1993 or so, but not that much has changed in the guts of routers since then.) It developed all this power very inefficiently, so it ran loud and hot. We panned the router for other reasons (like the collet socket machined directly into the arbor), but we couldn't argue with the way the RPMs held up under increasing loads. We actually stalled the big PC router with similar maximum loads.
It's a gnarly, complicated issue: do you always get what you pay for? I don't think it can be reduced to anything that simple. But, I refuse to get impassioned about vendors. If they screw up one time too many, I vote with my feet. So far, I still shop at Sears. They have a lot of good prices on some good brands. At their volume levels and their target market's price point, it doesn't surprise me that they outsource to China and have some quality issues with a lot of products. I can't hold that against them; I just have to buy carefully. Personally, if an $18 vac lasted me a year, I'd be a happy camper.
>It appears to be an on-line thing only. Sale ending today.
A friend told me that while waiting to pick his vacuum up at the store he saw the exact model on the sales floor for $99 but with $25 worth of free attachments.
>I guess it was a one day only kind of thing. They still have them at $99 with $25 worth of accessories for free, but that's a long way from eighteen bucks.
>I went to the store and they had 2 of them. It usually sells for $79.99, it does not come with a bunch of attachments, those are extra. They gave me the price with a hassle. Went ahead and got the replacement warranty too. I seldom have any problems with Sears and/or Craftsman. My 2�.