Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

Posts

Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#1

Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi.

Pretty soon I'll be ready to apply some finish to the Walnut table I am making for my daughter.

Side note:

Last night I mortised the legs using my new Steel City mortising machine. First time I used it. Bought it several months ago. As I recall, it was about $300. More than the Delta/Jet counterparts, but much more machine in my opinion. Money well spent. Very nice machine. The chisels were very sharp out of the box too. Mortised the walnut without any problem. Then I tapered the legs on the cabinet saw. So I am getting close to finishing and glue up.

In the past I have just used some kind of varnish on anything I've made using Walnut.

For this project I would like to apply a finish (before glue up) that might darken the walnut slightly (I know it will lighten over time) and maybe fill the pores.

I would like to fill the pores in an attempt to make the top smoother. Maybe I won't have to fill the pores for the legs, aprons, and drawer front.



So what do you think about filling the pores, and how should I do that. And what about darkening it slightly?

Could I add a little Trans Tint to some thinned varnish/poly and sand it in creating a slurry to fill the pores? This isn't figured walnut by the way.

Suggestions? Thoughts?

Thank you.

Joe

P.S.

FWIW, I am liking finishing prior to glue up more and more when it's possible. Sure makes it easier.

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#2

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

Tony - Memphis

>I just finished a walnut lowboy. It was my first big project using walnut. I had some color variation to fix, so I used Van Dyke Crystals, which is a water based dye made with walnut shells. I used Lockwood brand. It really helped even the color. I wasn't happy with the color though, so I added some amber Trans Tint to my finish (wipe on varnish), and that "warmed" it up quite a bit. I've never done any grain filling, so I can't help you there. I'm not a fan of it, but I may try it on the next project I do with walnut. This particular wood was very coarse grained and the water based dye seems to exaggerate that.

Tony


img

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#3

The top

Tony - Memphis

>Here is a pic of the top. You can see the color a little better here. This one was taken in my shop with flourescent lights. The camera was set to make up for that, but it still affects the color a little...


img

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#4

Bart Goldberg

Waterlox is my favorite for Walnut

Bart Goldberg

>

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#5

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>A light wash of a red hahogany pigment stain will warm and darken it attractively. I would not fill.

Clint

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#6

Example 

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>


img

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#7

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>1. I always stain walnut. I like a pigmented stain for walnut, not a dye stain. Using this approach I know that the walnut will maintain its original color for 40 year and counting.

2. Filling walnut makes it look more formal looking. One can add pigment to the filler and thereby stain and fill in one operation.

3. I prefer a durable finish on a table. Some sort of cross linked varnish is ideal.

4. You are unique in trying to finish before assembly. As you develop your wood working experience keep questioning whether this approach is best. I do prefinish panels where expansion/contraction might reveal something not finished if finishing was done later.

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#8

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

howard

>I've gotten very nice results with spraying NC lacquer as long as the wood is generally the same color tone.

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#9

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

Jesse Cloud

>Good advice above. If you have some walnut scraps, try a few combinations and see which one you like best.

I usually use a red mahogany stain and Behlen's filler. I like the Rock Hard varnish product, but it needs a couple of weeks to cure.

BTW, Bill was off on one small point, you are not unique in finishing before glue up. I always try to do that, especially on something like a table that has corners that attract squeeze out and extra stain. For what its worth, thats the way they teach us to do it at the community college take classes at.

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#10

Two for One

David Yoho

>Joe, there are so many ways to attack this there isn't enough room here for it all. The absolute easiest way I've found to finish walnut and fill the pores at the same time is to start with Watco Danish oil. Your choice whether to use the clear or their walnut colored oil. There are other ways to color the walnut but I thought I'd throw it out there.

I flood the surface with the oil and start rubbing with 320-grit wet dry paper until a thick slurry develops. Wipe off the excess across the grain so the slurry files the pores. Check it in a couple of days to see if you need to do more filling. If so, repeat the process but with less oil this time.

Let the oil dry and apply your favorite oil-based topcoat or continue with more of the oil (thin coats) until satisfied, wait a few more days to a week, and wax and buff.

The picture is walnut with natural Watco, and wax. The slurry does a good job of filling the pores.

David


img

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#11

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

Fred Davis

>That is a eyecatcher for sure , you should really try filling at least the horizontal surfaces on Walnut, Maghogany, Ash, Oak, etc.

The time spent wil be rewarded in the ewws and ahhhs you will hear from viewers.

Some swear by Silca based fillers, I am a old fashioned, hard to change what works type of guy, so I use Sherwin-Wiliams oil based wood filler in its natural form and tint it with the dye stain I use.

FredD

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#12

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

Tony - Memphis

>Thanks. The top is actually three pieces. The two pieces I got in class had a bit of sap wood in them that I was afraid I wouldn't be able to match well enough for the top where they would be seen so well. They do have some nice figure that is hard to see in the pic. I was pretty pleased with the boards. In person, they really go together well. Funny though, it is more obvious on the end grain.

Yeah, I'm torn. I am really agianst filling on the one hand, but this top is pretty darn rough. I mostly work with mahogany and haven't experienced any this coarse before. Thansk for the suggestion. I'll have to get some of that and experiment with it. May just go for the fairly smooth vs glass feel. I'll post for some help with it when I start playing around with it.

Tony

Re: Finishing Walnut. Suggestions/ideas?

#13

Thanks. In regards to finishing first...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Thanks for the replies.

In regards to finishing before glue up, I find it very difficult to apply finish after glue up in areas such as where legs meet aprons and so on. You know, those areas where the pieces create 90 degree angles.

I've never been successful at rubbing those areas out and/or applying finish without some kind of noticeable defect in the final finish.

I find it is just easier.

Thanks.

Joe