Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

(OT) New Car for the Mrs.

Posts

(OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#1

(OT) New Car for the Mrs.

Brian in Brighton

>Well, I have to buy the Mrs. a new car.

The story:

Starter on her 97 Dodge went out last Sunday. Told the tow truck driver to drop it off at the dealer. He DID, off the last several feet of the truck and totaled it.

So we have been fighting with AAA and the tow insurance people to get the most for our car, since we put $4500 into it in the last 13 months we are expecting $6000 for it. $4500 value and $1500 compensation. Visible damages are $3600, but it landed on the drivers wheel so there is probably driveline damage. I am pushing to total it.

So we have been driving some cars. Don't bother me with Ford, Dodge or GM please, and I don't want to turn this into a battle of US vs. foreign. We have been looking at Honda Accord and Fit. Acura TL (used) and some other small SUV's, haven't driven Toyota yet. The one that shocked me is that she drove a Mini Clubman S and LOVED it. So much for anything that makes sense. My car is an F-150, so this will be our primary travel vehicle, so I am pushing for the Accord.

Any hybrid is out as they are on several month backorder and we don't have the time for it. Although she seems to have an idea about being able to wait 3 months for the Mini. :-( We are empty-nesters with no dogs to deal with, just us and plants that she buys.

So here is the big question. How do I get her to NOT want the Mini and buy something sensible like the Accord or a Camry? The reliability seems to be fairly close as far as I can find.

Thanks,

Brian in Brighton

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#2

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

Howard Norman

>I have a 05 Accord and it is a good car. Now how to get a women to act in a rational mode is beyond me so I won't even try to give you advise on that issue.

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#4

JL

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

JL

>I like most Subarus - they are made in Indiana. My wife has a Mazda 6 - from Flat Rock, MI.

We both like our vehicles.

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#5

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay Area

>So why is the Mini a bad idea? It's her car, right?

You still have the truck, so your boyz shouldn't give you any grief.

You know, Mini was, and may still be, owned by BMW...

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#6

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

Brian in Brighton

>Mini is still owned by BMW.

The reason it is not just her car is that it will become the primary vehicle for all the things we do. I don't like the car and will not ride with my wife driving as she is the poster child for agressive drivers and she makes me ill to drive with. So, I do all the driving when we are together. She does drive when we go long distance, like from Denver to SLC or STL, but not around town with me in the car.

She is stuck on the "fun" factor and has not really looked at snow, rain, not being able to see thru traffic ahead of her, etc.

Brian in Brighton

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#7

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

Glenn Madsen in the SF Bay Area

>So you do have a reason for not wanting the Mini. OK.

It's been 8 years ago, when we bought my wife a Volvo with the high performance turbo and suspension. She drives it cautiously around town. When we take it on the road, however, we seem to make really good time, IYKWIM.

Couples balance things out. I don't think the Mini is a more dangerous car, but then, what I think isn't all that important in your decisions, is it? ;-)

Have fun with this. If you're lucky, you don't have to do this all that often in life.

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#8

Re: Go With The Accord- It is Made in The U.S.

Brian in Brighton

>Assembled in the USA, but not with the design constraints placed on US manufacturing companies. I have been in Ford and Delphi plants and heard far too many stories about why designs are done the way they are. It's sad that the US automakers are going in the toilet, but the design engineer's hands are tied by a lot of other parts of the company that are not as concerned about quality. They are more concerned about jobs, costs, and origins than quality. So the engineers get to do the best they can with one hand tied behind their back.

Brian in Brighton. F150, at 42 months, paint failing, Ford "too bad you have 70,000 miles-it's your problem". Me "your paint is failing because it sucks and I want it fixed" Ford "crickets............."

No more Fords for me no matter if I get 500,000 miles from this one.

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#9

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

Brian in Brighton

>Actually the Mini has a very high safety rating, but Physics wins. Here in Colorado a lot of men have the need to compensate for something, that means they have to have the F350 with a 6 inch lift and it would run her over. :-(

Brian in Brighton, a small country town on the outskirts of Denver surrounded by 60mph roads.

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#10

Amen to the Accord

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>After two years of research, my wife narrowed down her choice to the Camry and the Accord. We got the Accord because we liked the handling better. She wanted the V-6 2007.

We just put on 3600 miles on a trip from MN to the great southwest, mostly Utah, elevations up to 12,000 ft. Twisty roads, superslabs, you name it we did it. Six inches of snow in the Big Horn mtns and Yellowstone, no problem. We averaged something between 29 and 30 mpg.

This is primarily my wife's car (mine is a Tundra) and it is fabulous. We highly recommend it.

Bruce

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#11

Yikes

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"... will not ride with my wife driving as she is the poster child for agressive drivers and she makes me ill to drive with...."

And you really want to buy her another vehicle???? :)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#12

went the other way.

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>My wife just picked up a new Pontiac Torrent SUV. She actually longed to get away from small low-slung cars and get into something higher off the ground. Visibility is better, feels safer.

We've only had it for a week, but she's very happy with it.

Fuel economy seems to be good so far.

Norman ( always a bit different)

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#13

Get The Mini

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Why? Because it's entirely possible I'll own one myself later this year. The Clubman is awesome. I have been researching the Mini's for a year and I like everything I read. Even Consumer Reports gives it a good reliability rating. And what best of all, they are a blast to drive.

The Clubman isn't a whole lot bigger but it's enough of an improvement to give it decent cargo space. Run flat tires are nice. And we find the interior comfy.

It's a great car. Go for it!

Tom

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#14

Ditto Tom. Also...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>check out the Nissan Altima. Nice car. Good reviews and it isn't overpriced like the Honda's and Toyota's.

Nissan is giving them (Honda & Toyota) a run for their money with the newer Altima.

We were getting ready to replace my wife's Quest with an Altima until some recent problems came up. We have to wait on that now.

FWIW, I won't buy Ford/GM/Chrysler either.

Joe

328is driver.

You'd be surprised how many 2x4x8's you can fit in a BMW with the trunk closed!

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#15

Re: Ditto Tom. Also...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Nissan has the VQ engine. One of the best motors developed in the last decade. We have an Infiniti with a VQ....very reliable. You'd like that Altima. The coupe is nice too.

Tom

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#16

We've Been Pleased.

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Brian,

My wife bought a 2006 Accord with a 4 banger. Plenty of comfort and power for our needs. It replaced a Mazda 626, which was equally good, in my opinion. Several of my sons have Hondas and Nissons, and one Toyota. No problems with any of them, except they cost an arm and leg to buy.

George

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#17

Drive a Mazda

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>You'll love the handling and performance of the Mazda 6. Of course she might also fall in love with the Miata. My wife likes our Mazda Tribute for ease of handling and visability.

Lee


img

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#18

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.------WebKitFormBound

LRSmith in NC------WebKitFormBoundarykxtRJndnboIPS

>"The reliability seems to be fairly close as far as I can find."

The Consumer Reports 2008 Buying Guide lists Accord and Camry as "good bets" and most Mini's as "vehicles to avoid." One caveat, these rating were based on 2006 survey results and while the Mini continues to improve in quality it probably still in not the same league as Honda/Toyota. Fun it seems comes at a price. Also don't forget that you will also be paying BMW service rates and dealers are not that plentiful. You could also check some Mini owners blogs to see if there are any issues that stand out the latest models. The July 2008 issue of Road & Track has an article, "Used Car Classic: Mini, 2002-2006," that you might want to check out.

Happy motoring in any case.

Lynn

------WebKitFormBoundarykxtRJndnboIPSD+H

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#19

You can take this to the bank, and Ellis..........

Art Silva

>can verify this.

I am presently back working for the area's Honda, Acura dealership, although no longer in Acura sales. Ten days ago I had to retire my 1988 Acura LS coupe after only 316,460 miles. I had planned on driving it to 500,000 and then putting it back in the showroom, but a few years back when the Jackasses in the Penn. DOT decided to spray Brine on the roads to combat icing, all Pa. cars have been subject to all types of designer holes in their sheetmetal, and HOLES do not pass inspection. I now have a 1998 Acura RL with only 88,400 miles.

FYI: My daughter traded her 1990 Acura Integra GS with 189,000 miles for 2001 Accord, which now has 150,100 miles. She wants Daddy to find her nice Acura or Accord off-lease car by October.

My son Peter traded his 1993 Acura Integra LS with 212,000 miles for a new 2003 Accord LX which currently has 143,765 miles.

My lovely wife Ruth currently has 122,789 miles on her 1997 Honda CRV. She is making noises about a Honda Pilot off-lease vehicle before the end of the year. I gave her half of my Acura RL for her birthday on the 26TH., but she complained that her half does not have

a steering wheel.

I guess by now you have gotten the message about reliability of Honda products. Good luck with your shopping. Art

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#20

Yes, the Clubman

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Rode in one last week that had the "S" package, but no "Sport" suspension. Turned out that was a good combo as the sport suspension doesn't do it in my age group. The car drives well and can carry stuff and people with no problem. Premium fuel though.... Chicks like it!

Another one is the Scion Xb wagon. Man, I can't believe how easy it is to get in and out of one.

Trying to convince wife that we need a Smart car. Not working so far.

I really like the monogrammed bod, uh, err, air bag option. Ooops...

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#21

I Am So Glad, Art.....

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>that you take all those "designer holes" with a grain of salt! I have to admit that the two latest Hondas my wife bought seem substantially better mechanically than the two I used in the 80's. But I am not easily pleased. Little things bug me, like the driver's door won't remain open on our inclined driveway. Or, when open fully, the door's handle is almost out of my arthritic reach.

George

Re: (OT) New Car for the Mrs.

#22

Re: It's a Honda!

Brian in Brighton

>She made up her mind and came around!!!!

The insurance company is going to look at the car today and we will see what they say. We'll be getting a Mystic Green Accord EX-V6 if all goes well.

Thanks for the support, we won this one!

Brian in Brighton