Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Red Oak price drop story on NPR this evening.

Posts

Red Oak price drop story on NPR this evening.

#1

Red Oak price drop story on NPR this evening.

marc rosen

>I'm going to stock up- I still love working with it!

Marc

Here's the link;

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=91986050

Pasted for your reading convenience;

Black Times for W.Va. Red Oak Loggers

by Noah Adams

Audio for this story will be available at approx. 7:00 p.m. ET

Noah Adams/NPR

A fresh-cut West Virginia red oak shows a distinctive pink hue. These logs will be cut into lumber and shipped to China.

All Things Considered, June 29, 2008 � If you own timberland in West Virginia, you've most likely got an investment in red oak and the value of your tree portfolio is falling fast. There's been a slide in prices, and now, locals say, they're "dropping off a cliff." A red oak tree � the predominant species � is worth 40 percent less than it was three years ago.

It's a fashion issue. Oak was popular in the 1980s for cabinets, flooring, furniture. Cat Caperton of Gat Creek Furniture in Berkeley Springs, W.Va., says, "Oak had the connotation of strength, longevity, country values. Nowadays, it doesn't come across as sturdy; it comes across as busy."

Cherry has become the new oak, with maple and walnut also in favor. That's why Duane Clemons, who runs a sawmill in the town of Smoot, has enough of the old favorite on hand to sell you 250,000 board feet. He has about 4,000 red oak logs in the mill yard, not to mention the oak he owns that's still standing on various tracts around the state. It's also why Clemons sells oak to China � even though he knows it's used to make inexpensive laminated furniture that's shipped right back to stores in West Virginia. Sawmills in the state have been shutting down, and Clemons says, "If you don't sell to China, you'll be out of business."

With red oak prices down and fuel costs to cut timber on the rise, lots of landowners will surely say, "Let's just let those trees keep on growing."

Re: Red Oak price drop story on NPR this evening.

#2

Ellis Walentine

Time to get creative

Ellis Walentine

>That furniture manufacturer who was talking about red oak being "busy" is right, but it doesn't have to be that way if you match the grain tastefully. Kitchen cabinet manufacturers and flooring contractors aren't famous for doing that, so red oak gets a bad rap.

I think that if the red oak purveyors would saw more quartersawn lumber, they could create a new market for their wood. Save the best flatsawn stuff for matched panels, and use the rift and quartered material for frames, flooring, trim, etc.

An educational program for consumers and contractors might include avoiding pigment-based stains, which over-accentuate the grain patterns in coarse, ring-porous woods like red oak.

The good news for us woodworkers is that, until the fashion pendulum swings back to red oak, we can have a wider selection at lower costs.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Red Oak price drop story on NPR this evening.

#3

NPR a little late with this news

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Log prices dropped 50% last summer from about $1.00 a foot to $0.50.

Re: Red Oak price drop story on NPR this evening.

#4

Re: Red Oak price drop story on NPR this evening.

Dick Coers

>If you get rift sawn red oak, it can be very easy on the eye. Not agressive at all. Years ago, I shot a light coat of primer, then two coats of satin black lacquer on red oak and was really pleased with the finish. Across the room is has that asian design look and you don't see the open pore finish. But if you get up close, it's fun to see that it is oak.

Re: Red Oak price drop story on NPR this evening.

#5

Re: Red Oak price drop story on NPR this evening.

Scott Banbury

>This story is a little late in breaking.

The sad thing is that the dependancy on the the Oak market is a result of misguided management recommendations by State Foresters. Since the '50s, landowners have been encouraged to practice even aged forestry, utilizing clearcuts or group selection to create conditions favorable to Oak regeneration to the exclusion of other species.

It's hit us really hard here in the Midsouth where we've seen several failures among the biggest multigeneration hardwood flooring manufacturers and the logging outfits supplying them.

Unfortunately, Ellis, very few landowners are advised to or choose to practice rotations longer than 30-40 years. This results in smaller diameter logs that produce some plainsawn better than common and a railroad tie or pallet cant.

It takes a log at least 20" and preferably better than 24" in diameter to produce decent quartersawn lumber and logs that size require letting the tree grow 50-60 years and logs this large generally fetch more money for veneer or plywood.

The majority of Oak that is being harvested in my area--W TN, E AR, and N MS--is going to chipmills to feed the magazine and printer paper mills.