Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Dealing with wood movement question..

Posts

Dealing with wood movement question..

#1

JL

Dealing with wood movement question..

JL

>I would like to make a table that consists of a "butler's tray" that you set into a base frame. I've usually used buttons to fasten a table top to an apron. Obviously with this style, I just have to rout the bottom so that it fits into the base frame and disguise the join with a lip. I just have to make the lip large enough. The top may move as much as 0.5" across the width.

The tray top will have sides - which shouldn't be fixed to the tray top. I was figuring on using a screw slot bit on the underside of the table top and screwing the sides to the top from below the table. Any other good ways to approach this?

A picture of the prospective top is shown below.


img

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#2

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

Dan Donaldson

>I would be tempted to make the top from plywood or mdf and veneer it to eliminate the wood movement problem. It looks like it is contained pretty much all the way around and the laminated top looks like a good solution to this problem.

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#3

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>First, I wonder what conditions you are using to get that the top will shrink up to 1/2"? That seems like an awful lot. I have a red oak coffee table with a solid wood top. It is 20" or so wide, and I have never seen it over +/-0.25". I would look at that again if I were you.

Now, if it were me I would make it out of solid wood, but I would leave 1/2 of the extra room needed on each side. So, if I needed a 3/4 rabbet on each side (across the grain), and if I were expecting 1/2" movement, I would make the grooves about 1-1/16 on each side.

Remember, the grooves are going to be on the bottom and inside the frame. No one will ever know that they are there unless you show them, and then since this table is supposed to have things like that, it will not look wierd.

Just my $0.02. Go back and check that 1/2" movement. Post the details here and I will see what my calculation comes out to.

Good luck,

Rob Hix

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#4

JL

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

JL

>I thought about that - then I realized that I would have to edge band everything to get a decent edge that I could rout into shape. I figured what the heck, go ahead and make it a solid top. Besides, I already have some nice pieces of walnut :).

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#5

JL

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

JL

>I was planning on using black walnut - because I have it and I think it would look nice.

I used Larry Marker's wood movement calculator. The resulting graph is shown below.


img

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#6

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

Sgian Dubh

>I'd be surprised if you got even as much as 2 mm (~3/32") change in width in a top the width your photo suggests in a typical seasonal wood MC range of 7%- 12% using mahogany similar to that in the photograph. Mahogany is one of the world's most stable woods and exhibits just about the lowest shrinkage factor of all woods.

A 1/2" width change is more appropriate in something like European beech in a table top about 50- 55" wide. Slainte.

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#7

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

Sgian Dubh

>The graph confuses me. There's no indication what the numbers on the left scale represent. Are they inches, millimetres or are they a percentage change in dimension? There is also regular mention of length, yet there is a box indicating the curved lines represent tangential and radial movement which are changes in width, not length. Slainte.

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#8

JL

Re: Dealing with wood movement question.. *LINK*

JL

>As I said, I used Larry Marker's Wood Movement Calculator.

The download is available in the Badger Pond Articles Archive, down in the download section. He uses "length" in his program.

I checked it against The Shrinkulator from WoodBin (http://www.woodbin.com/calcs/shrinkulator.htm) - and I got the following values.

Species Black Walnut Mahogany

Initial MC 9.2 9.2

Final MC 16.0 16

Initial Dim 20 20

Final Dim Radial 20.28 20.15

Final Dim Tangent. 20.40 20.2

Change Radial 0.28 0.15

Change Tangent. 0.40 0.20

MC = Moisture Content

I used values going from 50 to 80% humidity - which isn't that unusual in Georgia in fact it's somewhat on the low side :). That's why I run dehumidifiers in my shop.


Wood Central Badger Pond Articles and Downloads

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#9

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>The shrikulator shows a 1" shrinkage when the wood acclimates at 90% relative humidity and is moved into an environment with 30% relative humidity, this is for a 20" wide board. That really surprised me. Anyway those number are a little off track for me. If I go with something a little more like I would see this time of year I would say it acclimated at 85% and moved int 45%. This gives me a shrinkage of just over 1/2" this is what I would plan on.

That being said, I do not know where you live, and you should be looking at conditions that are reasonable for your area. I would think 1/2" shrinkage would be enough to plan on. Also, remember that once it is built and inside the house you will not see a change this big because the relative humidity will not swing that much. Finishing will also have a little effect on it.

If it were me, I think I would make the tray (and finish it) for the table and take it inside and measure the shrinkage. In a couple of weeks or less it will probably stop shrinking. Take measurements and go build the base. The design of the base tells me it will not change size at all. Design for a little leeway, but if you built the base to exact size of the top this time of year you would likely be ok. Thing will only shrink in the winter.

When I build drawers this time of year, I build them as tight as possible for them to still work. Then, they still look and work beautifully in the winter.

I wish you the best of luck,

Rob Hix

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#10

For reference...

Tony - Memphis

>I built a 36" wide cherry dining table. I get probbaly around 3/16" total movement. never measured it, but I'm guessing based on the breadboard ends that get exposed in the winter. I live in Memphis. While we do get a broad range of RH, the RH in my house never gets too high - 60% maybe? I have measured it with an inexpensive device and it was in that range in the summer. Gets pretty dry in the winter though. My kitchen cabinet panels are solid maple and they barely move at all. 1/2" seems like an awful lot to me too.

Tony

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#11

Re: For reference...

Jesse Cloud

>For what its worth, I built our dining table out of walnut. Its 40 inches wide and moves about 3/8 inch max. We live in the desert and use a swamp cooler for cooling, so humidity ranges from 3% to 80%.

Anyhow, I would use mdf or baltic as a substrate. Especially mdf should route well to your shape. If you saw your own veneer, you can cover the edge first and cover that will the top veneer so it really looks like solid wood, but won't mov.

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#12

Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

Sgian Dubh

>"I used values going from 50 to 80% humidity - which isn't that unusual in Georgia in fact it's somewhat on the low side :). That's why I run dehumidifiers in my shop."

I obviously don't know what sort of climate control you have in your workshop, but your house probably wouldn't typically experience those sorts of RH numbers. RH numbers for a house with pretty good climate control are more likely to run between about 40% RH in the winter and 60% in the summer. This was the typical RH range I experienced in Houston when I lived there. Perhaps you'll find it surprising but the RH range of my current house here in Great Britain are very similar, ie, roughly 40%, winter, to 60%RH in the summer.

So, using those RH numbers and assuming internal temperatures hover pretty close to 20�C (68�F) for most of the year I used my spreadsheet to come up with some movement factors. 40% RH results in most wood species reaching an equilibrium moisture content (EMC) of about 7.5%, and 60%RH gives an EMC of approximately 11.5%.

I went a bit on the generous side and assumed you might see your walnut go up to about 12% MC. Anyway, I punched in the relevant shrinkage factors for 20" wide pieces of radially sawn and tangentially sawn Juglans nigra from 30% MC (fibre saturation point[FSP]) and 0% MC and come up with a maximum movement of ~1/4" for wood cut tangentially. Radial dimensional change is a maximum of 3/16". With polish on the job, and factors such as hysteresis I'd be surprised to see anything much greater than a 3/16" range of movement in a 20" wide plank of walnut, whatever the the cut. Slainte.


Re: Dealing with wood movement question..

#13

JL

Re:Thanks...

JL

>I'll go with a very small slot then. I suppose I could do the sides with a sliding dovetail and secure the back also. That way I could leave the front "floating" and attach it with some brass clips like in the photograph.