>I guess this is OT, but not entirely. I need to get a bow window replaced. Live in Iowa. Have had one replaced a couple years ago, had a vinyl clad put in. My question ? Are solid vinyl windows any good ? More dollars, I assume. But it would never rot, need paint, etc. Would look at Pella or Andersen/American Craftsman ( made by Andersen ). Opinions ? Thoughts ?
>I don't have a clear or definitive answer for you but as a Home Inspector I have some thoughts and observations.
I see hundred year old wooden windows. I also see "new" wooden windows that rot in less than five years. The older windows were made from tight grained old growth timber that apparently more decay resistant that the second or third growth or plantation grown stuff they are using today. Also they used to be treated with pentachlorophenol and primed and painted with lead based paint. Also, houses often had wider overhangs and gutters that kept the rain off the windows better than the newer houses with narrow overhangs and lacking gutters.
Vinyl windows won't rot, but that does not mean they don't deteriorate. I see some of the early ones that are now ten or fifteen years old and they are degrading from exposure to sunlight (UV). The frames and attachments break easily.
Also, they are also flimsy and plastic or sort of rubbery. The vinyl windows must be supported very carefully or they will deform.
So, How's that for a non-answer? The new wooden ones rot and the vinyl ones may deteriorate in the sun. The manufacturer's claim the new vinyl windows have better UV protection, but only time will tell. If you buy vinyl and it holds up well, they are right, but if they are wrong, your windows will gradually turn tan and fail, probably after the guarantee expires.
No one will ever see hundred year old plastic windows.
>WE have a vinylclad bow window we had installed just 3 years ago. All the exposed surfaces are vinyl including the inside parts of the sash and frame. So far it has been great. The inside is finished in a wood grain pattern so realistic that most folks, including woodworkers have to touch it to verify that it isn't wood. I don't recall the brand window it is, but it came with a lifetime warranty (assumes the company will still exist). The two double hund sashes open and close easily and the entire assembly is draft free.
>I live in Arizona so UV damage to vinyl windows is of considerable concern here. For use in this climate I would not consider vinyl or vinyl clad windows. When I built this house ten years ago I went with Marvin metal clad windows. They have held up very well with no problems and no detectable deterioration of the finish on the metal which is on the outside of the windows.