Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

pondering a new workshop

Posts

pondering a new workshop

#1

pondering a new workshop

John Foster

>Hi all; we are starting to put together ideas a home, hobby, semi-retirement whatever workshop to be built in 2009 or 2010. We are thinking 400-600 sq feet of workshop area and 1000-1500 sq feet for tractor and equipment storage. For the workshop portion we are contemplating cordwood (stackwall) construction. Does anyone have any experience with this type of construction? We have Rob L.Roy's book ; are there any other resources we should look into? Also I had always planned to just have a concrete floor, but I have been reading several opinions that a wood floor is superior. This does make some sense to me as I have bad knees and ankles. Does a wood floor make a big difference? Thanks for the opinions; John.

Re: pondering a new workshop

#2

Ellis Walentine

Wood floors

Ellis Walentine

>I can't speak to the construction question, but I know, as a former back-pain sufferer, that concrete floors are murder on backs, and probably knees. Mats help a lot, as do duck boards or flooring that is glued to the 'crete. I suspect there are low-impact flooring alternatives that would hold up to woodshop use, but I don't know what they are.

Ellis

Re: pondering a new workshop

#3

Re: pondering a new workshop

Fred Davis

>John,

Wood floors are like nite and day , do your body and edge tools a favor and consider a floor of wood which I did for my shop and since it sounds like you are going to have a slab floor common to all the different areas , it is very easy to do.

I started my shop building with a six inch slab of three thousand pound concrete , also known as a six sack mix.

Over this I glued and nailed 2x4 sleepers flat side down on 24" centers for the 1 1/8th inch 2 for 1 plywood that followed, which is also T @ G .

Over this I used 1/8th inch tempered Masonite cut into 16" squares minus a saw cut, glued down with the same PL 500 construction adhesive I put the 2 x 4 sleepers down with.

I slightly beveled the edges of the Masonite tiles on the router table.

For the finish I talked to the lab manager of Porter Paints in their Louisville , Kentucky factory and he sent me a two part Epoxy paint which is as hard as glass and still looks new after ten years down with no discernible wear.

This will create a sandwich of wood and Masonite 2 3/4 inches thick and the 24" spacing of the 2/4 sleepers makes the floor firm enough not to sag under common shop stationary tools while it gives your legs , back and feet a much longer and more comfortable life.

Let me know how this works for you.

FredD

Re: pondering a new workshop

#4

Re: pondering a new workshop

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I laid 5/4 (1" actual) by 6 PTYP sleepers on 24" centers over the poly covered concrete slab. 1" styrofoam insulation between the sleepers, and 3/4" 4x8 T&G AdvanTech decking on top, finished with floor paint. The styrofoam provides firm support as well as insulation. Makes a very foot-leg-knee-back friendly floor.

Clint

Re: pondering a new workshop

#5

could someone explain.....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>how your body could possible know whether it was standing on concrete or wood? To further contemplate, a shoe is compressible while neither the wood nor concrete is under the tiny load of the foot. So, it would seem that the shoe is vastly more a factor than the surface under it.

Re: pondering a new workshop

#6

Re: could someone explain.....

Dan Donaldson

>Not sure exactly why (referring to the shoe issue), but there is definitely a difference between standing on a concrete floor or on a wood one (at least if it is on sleepers etc. as mentioned in another post). It also makes a difference with the hard rubber mats on concrete. I have had jobs where I was on my feet all day long and at the end of the day, there is no question that in concrete vs wood, there is a difference.

Re: pondering a new workshop

#7

Re: could someone explain.....

Barry Irby

>Bill, I have read the above responses and am struck with wonder. I have heard of the advantages of wood floors many times and always wonder if it is really true. Especially the ones that must be sturdy enough to hold shop equipment.

As a former Builder, now Home Inspector I understand that floors that are supported on floor joists do respond to people walking on them. When you foot strikes the floor a shock wave emanates through the floor somewhat like the pebble in the pond ripple. Some say its the returning ripple that gives you the "sense" of whether the floor is "solid" or not.

On a floor supported directly on a slab you would not have the deflection of the joists and if the plywood were directly on the foam, you would not have he deflection of the plywood either.

I am wondering if anyone has done any sort of "double blind" study on this. If you did not know whether you were on a slab or wooden floor, could you tell? Would your knees and back know? Could it be a placebo effect?

Barry, debating and new shop floor or new shoes

Re: pondering a new workshop

#8

It could be a placebo effect........

Basil

>...but if it keeps your feet, knees and back from hurting, who cares.

My thoughts are that a well insulated foundation and shop building moderates the inside temperture, making heating and cooling easier and cheaper. .....but with my butter fingers and tendence to drop things, I believe I'd go with the wood floor.

Re: pondering a new workshop

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

A little different perspective.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>As for standing on concrete vs. wood, I can't really tell a difference yet. I also wear thick-soled, steel-toed boots 6 days a week.

One thing I have noticed is that there is a BIG difference in kneeling on the different surfaces. The ironic part is that without kneepads, it is far more comfortable to kneel on concrete or tile than any wood or wood product. I think it may be that the non-wood surfaces have a cooling, "ice-pack" effect on the knees, but I can't say for sure. Either way, though, the older I get, the less time I spend on my knees without running out to the truck for the pads.

Jason

Re: pondering a new workshop

#10

Re: Temperature effects

Kneale Brownson Dreaming of the Snow in N. MI

>I'm just guessing, having spent half my youth living in a house with a heated slab floor (my dad had polio, so they built the first house in our area to have heat plumbed into the slab), that it's a temperature difference rather than a hardness difference. I'd expect concrete to suck the heat out of your feet or knees.

Re: pondering a new workshop

#11

Well explain this

jeff

>My shop is 1/2 poured concrete and the other half plywood.

I have 1/2 in foam padding over everything and carpet on top of that.

Standing all day on the concrete half makes my feet hurt, but not the wood half.

Yet, my house is all wood floors.

I can stand all day barefoot in the house and my feet don't hurt at all. (or with shoes on)

Jeff

Re: pondering a new workshop

#12

I believe

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>the issue is "reflection." The denser the floor, the less vibration it transmits and the more it reflects. Dense materials make better soundproofing for the same reason. A wood floor spreads the footfall vibrations out away from the point of contact but the concrete reflects much more back into the shoe and, to a greater or lesser degree, onward to the skeletal structure. Padded shoes do make a difference (ask any food server or nurse), but they are not a cure-all. The joint cartilage and tendons in the foot, knee, hips, and lower spine are the natural recipients of the vibrations.

I have fatigue pads at my tools, but it made much more difference when I put a "sleeper" platform around my lathe.

mm

Re: pondering a new workshop

#13

My Floor

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I have plain old concrete slab floors. I find it to be a practical solution. My shop is not large so my tools are on mobile bases. Concrete provides a durable surface for moving 1/2 ton tools around.

And in my shop, spills happen...not a worry with concrete. Easy to sweep too.

I just find it to be a practical surface for the abuse that my tools and my work creates.

As for my old creeky knees...I have well placed matts at my work stations and I wear good insoles and socks.

Tom

Re: pondering a new workshop

#14

Re: It could be a placebo effect........

Barry Irby

>I'm not arguing one way or the other. I really do want to know. And I agree, if it is the placebo effect, but it works, let it be.

I had not considered the temperature situation. Perhaps the coldness of the slab is part of it.

Re: pondering a new workshop

#15

Re: pondering a new workshop

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Hi John. When I built my shop, I thought that a 25X25 sq ft. shop with 10 ft. ceilings would be the correct size. WRONG. After you get your stationary equipment in place, you will be running out of room.

My recommendation is to make your shop size around 25% larger than you think you will ever need. IF you think 600 sq ft. is right, then make it 750 to 800, for example. In the long run, you will be glad you did.

Have fun with your new home/shop project,

Ken

Re: pondering a new workshop

#16

Suggestion No. 2

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Make the narrow dimension 24" so that you will be able to clear-span the space with standard materials. Way cheaper to do.

Re: pondering a new workshop

#17

Use the force Luke... err Bill

Curly Smith

>It's simple physics. When you're standing on your shop floor you exert a downward force on the floor and the floor exerts an equal upward force. Since concrete is much less compressible, or less flexible if you prefer, the upward force exerted by the concrete is greater than that exerted by the wood floor. The remaining upward forces (concrete - wood) is stored as potential energy in the more compressible wood.

Since pressure is force per unit area, you'll have less pressure exerted on the load bearing body parts (feet/knees/back) if you go with a wooden floor.

Re: pondering a new workshop

#18

Re: pondering a new workshop

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I have a concrete floor in my shop. Wish it was wood, but I manage with rubber pads wherever I stand - like in front of machines.

Try to include as much natural north light as possible. It's much more eye-friendly than electric lights.

I don't know what kind of projects you'll be undertaking, but 625 sf seems small for a wood shop. Consider space for plywood, solid wood, fasteners, hand tools, finishing items etc. One thing I often see missing in personal shop layouts is space for the thing you are making. Get as much shop space as you can afford.

Ed

Re: pondering a new workshop

#19

Re: pondering a new workshop

John Veerkamp, Western Mo.

>In my experience( I work on concrete floors on my feet 8 hrs per day three days a week.) It is the footwerar that makes the difference. good shoes with proper support make a world of difference. Bad shoes will make your feet hurt whether on concrete or wood. I do have a dense rubber mat in front of my lathe on concerete. I can turn for ten hours in good shoes and my back or knees don't complain.

My two cents.

John

Re: pondering a new workshop

#20

Re: could someone explain.....

Fred Davis

>well not to put fine a point on it , but the body and my feet know this.

wood floors suspended by any method over concrete slabs are RESILENT.

THAT IS A CLASSIFICATION.

That means the floor deflects slightly when walked or stood upon and rebounds when the pressure is gone.

A dead air space between the floor and concrete that I mentioned insulates from the cold of the concrete in contact with earth or sand.

A wood floor is user friendly and considered a upgrade and more valuable, concrete is not.

Drop a edge tool on concrete and you get to resharpen the edge.

Drop a power tool on concrete and in most cases it will be damaged or ruined.

Many will upgrade to a wood floor when the opportunity presents itself. I have never met someone who had worked on wood floors wish he had a concrete one instead.

Concrete does this for floors above it, it is great rat proofing, highly fire resistant and much cheaper then wood alone or combined with it.

FredD

Re: pondering a new workshop

#21

Re: Get bigger

Peter Gregory

>Before I built, I would layout the shop on graph paper and make sure it was big enough. It is much cheaper to build it big enough the first time, than to add on. I like the idea of a 48X24 sized shop. You would thank me later. :)

Re: pondering a new workshop

#22

After reading all the responses, John

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>I'm learning to levitate.

George

Re: pondering a new workshop

#23

Learning?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>George, you've always been high on the levity.

[If I get a rise out of him, I'm sure to get a comeupence]