Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

Posts

Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

#1

JL

Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

JL

>ment if I copy them??

The FWW #198 with the beautiful piece of furniture on the back - the one that showcased the Irion Company - sort of got me inspired and thinking. But nothing quite that large!

I've liked some of the furniture from Colonial Williamsburg. They have some nice pieces. I was thinking about copying some of the small pieces. I know that some companies such as Kittinger and Baker make reproductions of this furniture. If I make pieces that are "inspired" by Colonial Williamsburg pieces (or any other historic pieces) would I be infringing on copyrights? I understand that the Copyright Act of 1976 - extended term to either 75 years or life of author plus 50 years, eliminated renewal option and registration requirements. Which is why you can get in trouble duplicating Frank Lloyd Wright pieces (until maybe next year).

Basically what I am asking is - if I copy a historic (1700s-1800s) furniture piece that some company also copies - do I have to worry about copyrights?

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

#2

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infri

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I don't think they have copyrights for the reproduction furniture they make. What they have is license to call themselves "The Official Furniture of Williamsburg" or something like that. You would not refer to your project as that so you are ok.

Tom

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

#3

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infri

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hey Tommy,

I am going to copy everything you make Buddy,

LOL

take care,

Jim

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

#4

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infri

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Unless you plan on selling the copies you should have no problems. If you start selling them as "copies" then you can have problems.

Lee

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

#5

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infri

Mike Fitterling

>Any design from about the mid 1920s or earlier are in the public domain and you may copy freely. You may sell your copy if you want. It's a bit of a common misconception that if you don't sell a copy of something copywritten it is legal, but in this case it does not apply anyway.

On any reproductions done later (than the mid 1920s) the only copyright protection is on the copier's "intrepretation" of the object, that is any thing he or she did that deviates from the original. We republish public domain books and the only copyright we hold is for our changes to the originals, as in our page layout and design (trim size, binidng, type specs, etc.), additions to the originals like adding a glossary, new illustrations, etc. If someone wanted to republish the same book as we have they are free to do so, as long as they don't copy any thing specific to our editions and they work from original copies, rather than ours.

Written works' copyright protection is much more clear cut than that for furniture and the like. It would have to have some really unique construction to get any protection either from copyright or patent.

Cheers,

Mike

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

#6

Unless you're Chico Sakman, T.Skaggs or Maloof

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>.. then about any furniture you make is pretty much a copy of something that someone else made before. There are a few people who's creations are truly unique, but for the rest of us, we're pretty much making "traditional" things that have been made similarly forever.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

#7

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infri

Steve Schoene

>As was said, there is no copyright on anything produced in the 18th. century, even though museums often act as if ownership of the object gives them ownership of a copyright. It does not.

That said, museums do own two things. That is the right to use their name. You can reproduce just not call it a Colonial Williamsbury Reproduction.

The other thing the own is access. They can certainly say, we won't let you see or measure the objects unless you agree not to reproduce them. However, for non-commercial use it is probably possible to get special access to items for measurements and the like. That's particularly true if you are a donor.

Williamsburg and Winterthur seem to be relatively restrictive about access. The Boston Fine Arts Museum has been much more accessable in my experience, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art was very helpful.

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

#8

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infri

Steven Pollack in Chicago

>COPYRIGHTS - There is no copyright protection on useful articles. Furniture is a useful article. The Supreme Court has upheld this provision in the copyright statute disclaiming protection for useful articles.

TRADEMARK - Now there could be issues with a trademark look that the consumer has come to associate with a particular maker but you dont see that in furniture very much. A trademark design is fairly broad in that it protects variations that are likely to confuse the consumer.

DESIGN PATENT - If someone files a design patent on a particular design then they have rights to that design. Not much point filing for a design patent unless you are really going to market the heck out of something. And then the protection is for the specific design only.

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infring-

#9

Re: Furniture reproductions: is it copyright infri

Fred Davis

>No ,

like you said , Baker does it all the time , last I looked at them they were doing antigues from the Henry Ford museum in Dearborn and on average the Baker stuff was about 6 grand a copy.

FredD