Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

Posts

OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

#1

OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi folks.

I just spent a while searching the archives for an answer to this. The only thing I could find was this thread by Barry.

I am wondering, if in an early 1900's home with knob and tube wiring, what issues are there with having foam insulation blown in?

I am guessing it's not a good idea to have foam blown in around the old wiring. Secondly I am guessing that with these old houses buttoning them up tight with insulation and new windows can cause other problems with moisture build up, radon gas issues, mold, and so on.

Some might say replace the old wiring with new (this in in regards to exterior walls btw). This I would guess, done properly-to code, would get very expensive. You'd probably have to upgrade the service panel and all kinds of stuff - just guessing, I'm not an electrical do-it-yourself kinda a guy. Maybe so much so that insulating isn't cost effective?

Somebody I know is considering this. I thought I'd check in with you pro's on the pro's and con's of doing this.

Thanks for any insight.

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

#2

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>My experience with knob & tube wiring is that it is basically undersized for most of today's uses. The insulation has degraded in many areas exposing bare wires. It can pose a significant fire risk. Some electricians won't even work on it.

I would recommend replacing it and removing all visible areas of the old wiring. Home inspectors and real estate appraisers will lower the value of houses they find with K&T wiring.

Lee

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

#3

DO NOT Insulate around Knob & Tube *LINK*

Dustmaker Mike

>Knob and tube used the air to dissipate heat. If you insulate around it then the heat has no place to go but into the insulation. This is a bad thing.


Knob and Tube info

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

#4

Should be replaced regardless . . .

steve mackay

>Eating the cost of replacing ancient, degraded, under-rated and dangerous knob & tube is nothing compared to plugging in that new microwave and haveing the house burn down. Once its identified its a "known problem/issue". It'll have to be disclosed to God and everybody. Kind of like that buried fuel oil tank you'd like to forget about. Ignoring old knob & tube is a "Bad Thing". Just my opinion but it goes directly to the top of the "MUST Do" list.

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

#5

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I wouldn't insulate until the K&T that runs to receptacles has been replaced. As has been stated most of the K&T is somewhat undersized for the current loads - usually it is 14 gage in this area. This can cause some heat buildup if it is covered in insulation. I do know of many homes where insulation has been blown in directly over the K&T without any future issues - however I would not recommend doing it. Someone may replace the fuse with a 30 amp and plug in a couple electric heaters and cause a dangerous heat buildup/fire. I have replaced a lot of K&T wiring as a contractor. I also have a 125+ year old home that was initially wired with K&T. I have replaced all the old wiring used for outlets, but left that used for lighting and light switches. This is due to the problems found when trying to replace a wire that runs between finished floors upstairs and ceilings down. I also upgraded my entrance many years ago from a 60 Amp to a 200 amp. It would be very expensive to hire an electrician to replace all the K&T in a home. A two story would be much higher than a single due to the replacement of the lighting and lower story wall outlets. A single story is not too hard - usually a sash chain or weighted line can be dropped in the outside walls and a new romax line pulled - still the cost for complete replace would probably run into several thousand. A lot of the final cost is determined by your location. In California or on the East coast the cost will probably be two or three times the cost for one of the heartland or southern states - large cities also cost far more for this type labor. Your best bet would to obtain quotes from reputable electricians in your area. Note I did not state Licensed - in Indiana and many other states - NO electrician is licensed, although I was bonded and insured as were many others. I often hear "hire only a licensed XXX" - in Indiana, the only professional state licenses I am aware of are Bartenders, Plumbers, Hairdressers, Doctors, Vets, Lawyers and Truck drivers. (They did license TV repairmen a few years ago).

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

#6

Ditto

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Several years ago my dentist lost his eldest son to this knob and tube wiring when his son got electrocuted in the attic of a recently purchased older home. While installing speaker wires, he laid across what he thought was just blown in insulation and instead was a live run of decayed knob and tube wiring underneath. He left a wife and two young kids. Get rid of that crap.

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

#7

Tritto - if that's how you say "I agree too"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I replaced the knob and tube (and other out of date wiring schemes) in our house some years back, with only one wall, in a closet, opened up. Granted, I've got a navigable crawl space, and full access to the attic, although one part of the attic challenges the concept of "full access" (lying on your stomach across two ceiling joists in a space where you can't raise your head without hurting it isn't exactly comfortable access). It also took a long time, and, if you're paying someone to do it, is likely to cost real dollars.

But: the insulation on much of the knob and tube wiring was gone, or crumbled when I touched it. Also, if the wiring's that old, there have been generations of homeowners who might have done something creative - I found one closet light that was wired by screwing the wires to the terminals on one of those ceramic bulb holders, with the bulb holder then screwed to some homasote (fluffy wood fibers - imagine masonite that's been left to rise before cooking). If one of those wires had started to arc, we'd have been, at least, replacing all our clothes; maybe trying to figure out how to replace our bodies.

Knob and tube is theoretically a great wiring system - those overhead power lines are basically knob and tube - but the technology available when knob and tube systems were installed is not durable enough to be trustworthy.

I'd spend money on the wiring before I spent it on the insulation; then start saving again.

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

#8

Based on my limited experience...

John in NM

>I would get rid of knob and tube as soon as humanly possible. Putting anything in contact with the wires would be insane in my book. I had one house that had this type of wiring, and there were burn marks on the lath when we took one of the walls apart. My theory is that the cloth insulation allows the wire to oxidize over its entire length rather than just at connections, increasing the resistance of the circuits significantly (but that is just a layman's theory).

At any rate, do yourself a favor - don't blow in insulation!

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

#9

Re: OT - Insulation and Knob & Tube

Barry Irby

>Sorry I did not see this sooner, buy, OTOH, I agree with all of the above.

Do not insulate over or around K&T. The heat build up will be worse and it becomes more of a contact hazard as mentioned. Also, If the wall cavities are empty now, it will be relatively easy, or at least possible to fish in new cables. Once you blow them full, it will be nearly impossible. In effect, you can do it now, but insulating will mean it probably will never happen.

K&T is grandfathered in under the newer codes, provided it is "properly maintained". It is not. The current generation of electricians often do not know how to maintain it and don't have access to the supplies that would be necessary. The installation was often Gutta Percha (sp?) or early rubber and it has dry rotted and fallen off. No way to fix that without replacing it. And As mentioned, it is under sized and offers no ground.

I might consider leaving it as a switch leg on a lighting circuit, but not much else.

I have seen it run down both sides of an attic. Hot on one side and neutral on the other, through the rafters. Owners mistook it for a clothes line and hung coat hangers on it. Just glad they did not pick up a metal one from each side at the same time. Not a speck of insulation left.

Tell your friends to do this in the right order.