Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT - Living Trust Question - Long

Posts

OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#1

OT - Living Trust Question - Long

Joe Pack

>I convinced my in-laws to create a Living Trust years ago, which they did through an attorney affiliated with a prominent trust writing corporation. When they passed away, the transfer of assets to the beneficiaries was all but painless. Because there was nothing to go through probate proceedings, the costs were less than $50 to do all the paperwork involved, which included filing estate taxes (yes, Ohio still has them...you have to pay to die in Ohio, one of only 7 states to still tax the dead), and the paperwork was simple enough that I did the forms myself by following the on-line instructions after a 10 minute conversation with our tax guy. The savings by avoiding probate were considerable, in the mid 4 figure range, plus assets were not tied up for a year or more.

As one of the successor trustees, and as an advisor to my mother-in-law prior to her passing, I read and learned the Trust document inside out. I don't pretend to be a legal expert, but I took the time to read and learn. I think I have a decent understanding of a simple Living Trust designed through this corporation.

Any number of local attorneys are advertising their services to create Living Trusts. I have checked with some, and find that the vast majority are affiliated with a corporation of some sort, i.e., they use the format and forms provided by this corporation. One of my good friends took advantage of their services and asked me to be the witness/signee for all of the various forms he and his wife had to sign to validate their trust. Obviously, I was in a position to at least scan the forms (with my friend's permission). As I did so, I found that the forms provided by the corporation he was doing business with were all but identical to the forms in my mother-in-law's trust.

Because of the many benefits we experienced in dealing with my in-law's Trust, my wife and I are considering creating our own. Actually, we are not just considering it, we will do it. My only consideration now is whether or not it is necessary to hire an attorney to do all the work.

Understand that I am NOT attorney bashing here! Attorneys get a bad rap sometimes about charging "just for talking to you" as my m-i-l used to say. But their product is knowledge, and their time is just like a woodworker's shop time. They sell knowledge and advice, both of which I have no problem paying for when it is needed. I am NOT attorney bashing here! I am questioning, however, whether it is necessary to spend $2500+ (attorney's quote) to prepare a simple trust when what seem to be the exact same forms used by the corporate Trust systems are available through NOLO Press and other sources.

The NOLO documents, along with the forms available on CD with Living Trust guides written by attorneys, are represented as being legal in 49 states (not Louisiana, where French common law is involved as opposed to English common law). Comparing the documents on the CD I have, there is almost no difference between those and my mother-in-law's Trust documents. It seems that the corporate Trust documents were the same "fill in the blank" documents that the CD uses. In fact, we still have the "fill in the blank" documents that were provided as worksheets for my in-laws to use. The attorney's office simply filled in the blanks on the final forms as my in-laws did on the worksheets. Along with the final formal document, the attorney provided instructions, forms and addresses to transfer all assets formally to the Trust, which my in-laws mailed, along with any associated transfer fees, to the proper places. Voila...the Trust was created and funded.

Finally, my questions to be answered or responded to considering your individual experiences and/or expertise...

Am I correct in assuming that trusts created using the corporate trust mill forms are essentially the same?

Am I correct in assuming that most attorneys will use a stock format as a beginning point in creating a trust (corporate form or otherwise), one that will cover most or all of the points necessary to accomplish the needs of the Trust?

Am I on solid ground to assume that a Trust that I create myself using forms, format and language 95% the same as an existing Trust that was created by an attorney/corporation would be as serviceable as one created by an attorney using a corporate trust service?

You get the idea by now...Is it necessary to pay an attorney $2500+ to prepare a document that seems to be the same as I can prepare using forms and computer programs available to me for less than $100? Everything I read says a qualified "yes." The qualification from all sources I have read is that a more complicated Trust, one involving minor children, disabled individuals, divorcees, mixed families (and mixed UP families), business interests, etc. need legal advice and guidance. None of these apply in our case. Ours would be as simple as they come...literally like the fill in the blank forms seem designed to accomplish.

I have prepared deeds to transfer property within my family by filling in approved forms, and once by typing word for word from an older deed, that have been accepted by Courts in NY and Ohio. I have prepared wills and living wills for family that have been accepted by Courts in Ohio. In doing so, I paid an attorney for a total of three hours of his time to advise me. I paid for his time and knowledge, not for his secretary's time at the computer. I am strongly considering doing the same in creating a Living Trust.

What is your experience or opinion? (Apologies if I don't respond immediately...will be away for several days beginning tomorrow a.m. Thanks for your input.)

(Related sites/information)

http://www.nolo.com/

http://www.bigeye.com/henryabts.htm

http://www.amazon.com/Living-Trust-Henry-W-Abts/dp/0809230313

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#2

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

Frank Orfanello

>OK, for the record i am not an attaorney and I don't play one on TV. I am an accountant and a CPA, and have been around a lot of trusts, wills, and other legal documents.

IMHO you need an attorney. The secret to these documents is not the forms but the knowledge that lets you decide which clauses belong in the document or not. it also tells you where in the document certian sections should go and why.

If you fill in the blanks on these forms your document may well be legal but it may not do what you want it to, and when that becomes apparent you may not be in a position to do anything about it.

Hope this helps.

Frank

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#3

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

Steven Pollack in Chicago

>I am an attorney, although I have never practiced in this area. You do need an attorney because 1) state laws are all different 2) the law makes subtle distinctions between facts that a practitioner will be aware of and you may not and 3)this is the most archaic area of law in any class I took in law school and the terms were not always defined in common sense ways.

Steve

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#4

Where did the savings go

C. Pearson

>At one time I worked as an estate planner. It has been over ten years since I practiced in this area so please take the following advice with a grain of salt:

1. Where did the savings on probate go - If it costs you $2500 to set up the trust how much cheaper is that than a simple probate proceeding? A living trust MAY result in an easier transition to the beneficiaries. A well planned estate might not be any more difficult.

2. If you want to set up a trust I would recommend the attorney, and a well-experienced one at that. You may wind up with the identical document that your cheap computer program produced however the value of the attorney is in knowing the circumstances where one option might work better than another (or may not apply at all). Furthermore, an experienced estate planner should be able to anticipate problems that may arise after your death and make sure that you address them in the trust (e.g. anticipating potential conflicts between beneficiaries). The cheapy program might work just fine... but it might not.... and you may not know until it is too late.

3. My personal view is that a living trust has its greatest value when the primary goal is to hide an estate from the public view of a probate proceeding. A rich or prominant client may place a lot of value on not having his laundry published in the local paper.

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#5

Re: Where did the savings go

Joe Pack

>According to the published rules of our county probate court, probate fees are set at 4.5% of the value of the estate. As an example, an estate of $100,000 would result in a fee of $4,500. Given a cost of $2500 to set up a Trust, there is an immediate savings of $2,000. Assuming a modest estate, including house value, of $300,000, the probate fee at the Court established rate of 4.5% would be $13,500. Quite a saving over the cost of a trust.

I imagine this could be negotiated with an attorney, but I found out why the fellow who prepared a will for us years ago repeatedly kept answering my question of "How much do you charge to handle a will proceeding?" with "That fee is set by the court." I found out just last year when I researched handling my mother-in-law's estate why he would not answer my question. Attorney Henry Abts writes in one of his estate planning books about an attorney who, when asked about his retirement planning, pulled out a file drawer full of wills and said (paraphrased), "Here is my retirement account."

My wife served as executrix of her aunt's estate (about $80,000), working with an attorney (picked by her aunt before she passed away) in Jamestown, NY. His fee was $2000 up front, plus expenses. My wife spent an ungodly number of hours over the space of a year filling out Court required paperwork and contacting distant relatives with paperwork that I thought she was paying the attorney to do. It ended up that he did file all the required paperwork, much of which my wife completed and returned to him, but the final bill was in excess of $3,000. This may have been negotiable in a different setting, but my wife honored her aunt's wishes and used this firm because "...they have always been the family's attorney."

An attorney setting up a Living Trust may well earn his money if he/she prevents problems down the road. As I said, I never begrudge anybody making a living, whether they sell cabinets or knowledge. It seems that an attorney writing a well constructed trust for even a modest estate would well earn his or her fee compared to probate costs in our county and in Jamestown, NY.

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#6

Appreciate the input, Steven. Thanks.

Joe Pack

>

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#7

Thanks Frank.

Joe Pack

>

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#8

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

Peter Gregory

>I use boiler plate legal agreements all the time, the agreements aren't where the real value is, no matter where you get them. Your idea that you can do as well by buying them from Nolo Press (or the like) might be right. But, the advice you get from an experienced attorney is likely worth it, on this first deal. If you were going to churn through dozens of deals like this, you would get a real idea of the angles. I'm not sure if I would be willing to risk a large percentage of my estate, against $2500. Of course, this means you need to find someone truly excellent to help you, so start networking. :)

Might think of it as buying insurance? What percentage of the estate is $2500? If it is 1%, I would pass on the lawyers. If it is 0.0001%, I would pay the money.

Personally, I don't think my kids should inherit the money I have made without taxes. Only by living in the USA could I have made that money. Putting some, or all, of it back into the government makes sense to me. I respect anyone goals to play the game, as best they can, but I don't want to play that game.

Good luck, I hope you keep as much as you can, in the family.

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#9

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

North of the Border

>"Personally, I don't think my kids should inherit the money I have made without taxes. Only by living in the USA could I have made that money. Putting some, or all, of it back into the government makes sense to me."

- Patriotism comes in many different forms; this, in my view, can be one of them.

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#10

Interesting billing structure

C. Pearson

>In the area I practiced we generally billed by the hour for our time, not by the value of the estate. My recollection was that a simple estate (and most were not simple in my practice) could be completed for about the same 2500 dollars. Court fees were a few hundred dollars. Of course that was 10 years ago.

Your story about chasing down all the paperwork reminds me of another point I should have mentioned. A living trust by its nature requirees people to keep track of their assets and this makes it easier for the next generation. If a decedant made the same effort in listing their assets and where they are located it usually greatly reduces the difficulty and stress of probate.

I am not opposed to living trusts at all, I just don't think they are necessarily less work in the long run. The difference seems to be when the work is accomplished (before death or after).

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#11

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

Jim Dillon

>Joe,

We went through this 6 years or so ago trying to get our affairs in order. In our case, it was a very satisfactory experience working through a local lawyer. And the state laws have changed several times since then whereupon he notified us and made changes to sections of the wills and trusts. Yes, for a fee, but we think it is worth it. I think a good lawyer will listen closely to your needs/wishes, anticipate what could go wrong, and try to protect your interests. You are paying for experience, and not just the cost of a "form". It is not a perfect system, but can give you some piece of mind if done right. We got the name of the lawyer from our local bank who gave us 3 names to choose from. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#12

Not a tax avoidance procedure

Joe Pack

>For the most part, a Living Trust is not a tax avoidance procedure. Taxes are filed just like with any other arrangement. This is one of the myths of this type of trust. For multi-millionaires there might be another type of trust available. For multi-thousandaires, there is no such thing! :-)

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#13

thanks Jim.

Joe Pack

>

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#14

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

Curly Smith

>I'd go with the lawyer. This article should give you a good idea about what the legal community thinks about do-it-yourselfers Texas Suppresses Do-It-Yourself Legal Software.

Wills and Trusts are generally standard boilerplate forms... the trick is in knowing which boilerplate to use. If a lawyer uses the wrong one then there's an good chance that the matter would still be decided in a manner favorable to the client. If you use the wrong form then there's an excellent chance that the matter will be decided according to the form. In other words, if you make a mistake then you'll be penalized, if the lawyer makes a mistake then you may not be penalized. It's just professionals protecting their turf.

Pull out the phone book and shop around. Find a local family lawyer and you should be able to get what you need for a more competitive price.

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#15

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

Howard Norman

>>I'd go with the lawyer. This article should give you a good idea about what the legal community thinks about do-it-yourselfers Texas Suppresses Do-It-Yourself Legal Software. <

I would say that this article is just another case of a profession protecting its "bread and butter". You see it in building codes that require certain things to be done only by "licensed contractors".

As someone else noted I see it as a % of the value of the estate. If the lawyers fees are a significant percentage of the estate use the forms, if it is small hire a lawyer.

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#16

I DISAGREE 10000%

Mark J Valsi

>PETER GREGORY WRITES,

"Personally, I don't think my kids should inherit the money I have made without taxes. Only by living in the USA could I have made that money. Putting some, or all, of it back into the government makes sense to me."

I DISAGREE 10000000%

You paid INCOME TAX on that money when you made it. and YOU earned that money for your labors, and it is YOUR money and the money of YOUR FAMILY. Not for the government to give away !!!

Why, pray tell, would you want YOUR MONEY taxed two times ??

I loathe the "death tax"!!!!! I'm not rich enuff, nor is my father to have to pay any, but I hate that tax !! the money will end up going to people who don't do a damn thing to EARN THEIR OWN MONEY.

The Death Tax is socialistic, bordering on communistic !!

I hope you will do a little research and re-think your desire to have YOUR MONEY taxed twice !

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

#17

Re: OT - Living Trust Question - Long

NickB in Easter Mass.

>I'll echo the comments of many of the above - go with a lawyer. A lawyer that does wills and trusts on a regular basis will be up to date on peculiarities and changes in your state laws, and generally makes it much easier to get the appropriate documents signed, notarized, or whatever needs to be done (and also should give you appropriate advice on whom to designate as the beneficiary for insurance, IRAs, etc.).

Truth in advertising - I'm a lawyer (patent attorney), but I took all the wills & trusts classes I could in law school, so I could understand the system. I used a Nolo Press book to write a wills for my wife and I when we had our first child, but we went to a lawyer to have our trusts & pourover wills set up.

BTW, on tax savings - if set up properly, an "a-b-c" trust will minimize the potential for estate taxes, assuming you're not giving everything to your spouse, but when your spouse passes, the tax man will get his shot.

Hope this helps,

Nick