Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Wood cross-sectional strength?

Posts

Wood cross-sectional strength?

#1

JL

Wood cross-sectional strength?

JL

>I've got a downloaded copy of "Wood Handbook -- Wood as an Engineering Material Information on engineering with wood, properties of wood and designing with wood."

I'm trying to get a feel for how thin I can go for leg and stretcher diameters with certain types of wood. I usually use hard maple and white oak for my legs and stretchers. I can take the legs down to ~3/4" with hard maple and white oak and I can take the stretchers down to 5/8" or less.

I'm making some chairs on spec and I was thinking of using something other than maple or white oak for the legs. I figure I would do some book work first and try to get a feel for how thin I could make the legs and stretchers.

Would the "Compression strength perpendicular to the grain" be a reasonable measure of the cross-sectional strength or would I be better off using the "Static Bending Modulus of Rupture"? Or a combination of the two? I've turned some dowels out of some of the candidate woods and I've got a feel for how much force it takes to break the dowels. So I'm trying to relate all of this to what loads the chair undercarriage will take.

It would not be a good thing to have legs or stretchers breaking under load :). (And you definitely can't tell a potential client to lose weight:).)

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#2

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

Kneale Brownson Dreaming of the Snow in N. MI

>I have no knowledge, but if I were making chairs in today's society, with current adult weight averages seeming to increase every decade, I'd be wanting to have capacities at least twice today's average adult male weight of about 190 pounds.

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#3

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I'd make a prototype and test it to destruction - heavy loads, tipping back, falling over etc.

Ed

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#4

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>FWIW, and not to be an alarmist, but...

when I was building custom furniture for sale, I discovered the product liability insurance premiums were highest for manufacturers of seating products. The second highest were for manufacturers of toys.

And given the fact that American in particular are tipping the scales higher each year, I'd err on the side of over-engineering if I was determined to do this. We humans are such a litigious lot, you know.

BTW, the insurance information caused me to decline orders for seating and discontinue building toys.

It isn't just the losing of a lawsuit that ruins you. Its the defending yourself that will leave just as broke. It is a no win situation.

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#5

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

Tony - Memphis

>Gosh, your asking me to go waaaay back! I'm a mechanical engineer by day, but I've been turned into a "systems engineer" (think handheld pda type devices and barcode scanning equipment), so my mechanical engineering skills are pretty lax. I'm not familiar with either of those values. Maybe they are particular to wood. What I would typically do is find the simple equation of bending and do some calcs using the same sample size (ie a 1" diameter rod 14" long) and compare the results of each wood. That will give you some idea of the relative strength. As for calculating the proper size to use, that would get very complicated. Especially with wood, given that it is not consistent. I think at best, you'll get a good guess with all this. It amazes me when I look at the thin cross sections that are gotten away with. Look at Queen Ann furniture - a highboy on those long skinny legs! I don't think I have any reference material on wood. Bending formulas are pretty common and simple though (all over the web). You might even find a web sight with a built in calculator. You'll probably need modulus of elasticity values and such though. Let us know what you figure out.

Tony

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#6

JL

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

JL

>I'd rather do the calculations first :). At 40+ hours per chair, I don't want to invest too much time (not to mention the material cost).

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#7

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

Sgian Dubh

>There's an old saying that's sometimes useful:

'If it doesn't look strong enough ... it probably isn't.'

There is the natural corollary to that:

'If it looks strong enough ... it probably is.'

Not a perfect method of assessing strength obviously, but they are a pair of useful maxims all the same. Slainte.

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#8

Good to hear that your are doing your homework

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>I have a paper copy of that, and I have spent quite a bit of time looking at those charts.

Actually for your purpose, you should look and consider all of those properties, and understand what they each mean. The compression perpendicular to the grain is a good measure of hardness, or how easily it dents, which may be more important for a hardwood floor.

Since you are familiar with maple and WO, you might just use their other strength, and use a ratio relative to them for the proportions of the new wood. Thus if you use 3/4' of these, but your new wood is only 2/3 as strong, then you should increase your dimensions up to ~1". I would look at those other values for structural values, Chair legs are not a place to use a brash wood.

There is an awful lot of good information in those charts, and well worth studying them regularly. Every time I look at them, I learn something new.

Care to share what wood you are considering? I am facing a similar situation where I have a customer wanting me to build one of my "Arborescent Tables", using knotty alder. First, I will have to have the alder shipped half way across the country, and I already know that it is only about half as strong as what I would like, and throwing knots into the equation only weakens it too much for my liking. Soooooo, I need to decide whether to take the job, or can I just veneer something better with a cheaper knotty wood, to satisfy the client?

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#9

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

Larry Marker

>Looks to me like the data in Chapter 4 and the equations in Chapter 8 of the Wood Handbook will give you the answer with a bit of digging. I haven't tried to study those chapters in detail, but I think it's all there.

That's a good book. It was my primary reference source for the Wood Shrinkage Calculator program.

Larry

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#10

JL

Re: Good to hear that your are doing your homework

JL

>I want to do a chair in cherry (cherry legs and seat and white oak hoop and spindles) and see what it looks like. If it looks good, I'll do more matching chairs and possibly a table.

I'd rather do baluster style legs - I usually take those down to 3/4" or 5/8" in the coves below the bulbs.

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#11

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Wood strength tables are a very rough guideline - They are taken from an average of breaking strengths. IE: Old growth wood that has been grown on a windy hillside and rived to obtain the desired rung may have 4 to 5 times the strength of a young tree with the rung sawn out of a board. As you have concluded, today most adults weigh much heavier than those of a few generations ago. Due to liability, I certainly wouldn't push the limits. If someone is injured due to a chair breaking - a litigation attorney would certainly try to make it look as if you didn't follow existing "safe" standards. It is unfortunate, but the litigation costs - even if you can prove you did do proper research & calculations - may put you out of business.

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

#12

Re: Wood cross-sectional strength?

Sgian Dubh

>Expanding on your theme Larry, it's reckoned that a riven plank of oak 1" thick is as strong as a 2" thick sawn piece.

Viking longboats, extremely tough and durable and made largely out of riven oak planking, managed to sail from northern Europe via Iceland, Greenland and Nova Scotia to about as far south as the Carolinas or thereabouts-- if my memory serves me correctly. Perhaps it was as far as Florida, but I'm not sure of that. Slainte.