Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

A small John Hall type mirror

Posts

A small John Hall type mirror

#1

A small John Hall type mirror

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Earlier this year I we were fortunate to be able to take Greene & Green class with Darrell Peart at William Ng's show in Southern Cal. During the class week Darrell was able to pull a few strings and have the great grandson of John Hall visit and bring in that famous almost 100 yr. old mirror that is featured on pg. 19 of Darrell's book "Greene & Greene Design Elements for the Workshop". The guy put the mirror in his car and drove L.A. freeways to get to William's shop---that's gutsy. Anyway, while all of us were drooling over this mirror and taking pictures, non of us took any measurements of the darn thing. Lucky for me it was sitting on the bench I was using, and based on some of the tools and project pieces lying around, I was able to, I think, get a good approximation on the size of the mirror and create some drawings so that I could make one for our house. I scaled them down to make this prototype. The original is walnut and has small square plugs at the joints. For this scaled down version I omitted the plugs as they would be too small. Here's my finished little mirror in mahogany with a Potassium Dichromate stain and Waterlox topcoat. I was gonna send it to my sister, but I'm kinda rethinkin' it now.


img

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#2

Close up of the bottom joint

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>The original used hand cut joints and I didn't want to polish my hand too skills. (sorry Handtool msg. brd. guys) I had to make the joint such that I had room to get a small spiral cutter through. I plan on making a few more of these in picture frame size for the family. I'm also going to "pillow" or soften the edges more in keeping with the John Hall style.


img

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#3

Re: Close up of the bottom joint

Fred Davis

>That's a attention getter for sure Eddie, you are giving my wife ideas, and I can't keep up the mowing the way it is now ;-))

FredD

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#4

Re: A small John Hall type mirror *LINK*

Darrell Peart

>Hi Eddie - Nice job on the John Hall frame!

The image I have posted with this message is the original John Hall frame.

One small correction - John Hall was Gary Hall's great uncle - Peter Hall was Gary's grandfatner.

Darrell Peart


img

Darrell Peart Furnituremaker

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#5

Re: A small John Hall type mirror *LINK*

Darrell Peart

>Close up of John Hall frame


img

Darrell Peart Furnituremaker

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#6

Re: A small John Hall type mirror *LINK*

Darrell Peart

>Another close up of John Hall's 1909 original frame.


img

Darrell Peart Furnituremaker

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#7

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

Jim Dillon

>Eddie,

That is really a neat mirror and I love the design. One question. Are those "dovetails" single-lapped or through? On my monitor, they look like they are single-lapped. I'll get out Darrell's book tonight and have a look at that mirror, especially in the context of the other works in Darrell's book. Thanks for posting.

Jim

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#8

Re: A small John Hall type mirror *LINK*

Darrell Peart

>Hi Jim,

The joint on the original frame is a half lap. If the "finger" went all the way through it would be a very weak joint. This photo is of the back side of the joint.

Darrell


img

Darrell Peart Furnituremaker

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#9

Thanks, Jim.

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>The dovetails are single lapped with the tails being at a depth of .260"and the pins at .300" to make them .040" proud.

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#10

Thanks, Darrell!

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Thanks for taking the time from your day to post these informative pictures of the original mirror. You know, I GOOGLE'd on Peter and John Hall and I came up empty with anything else out there on these two. Did I not look enough?

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#11

Re: Thanks, Darrell! *LINK*

Darrell Peart

>There is the Chiptsone article:

http://www.chipstone.org/publications/1993/Cooke93/article.html

click on the links to the images - this is where I first saw the G&G x-rays.

There might be a little about them at the G&G virtual archives:

http://cwis.usc.edu/dept/architecture/greeneandgreene/

The archives have lots of stuff - worth a look - the zoom feature on the images is really neat.

Gary Hall told me that Fine Homebuilding is working on an article about Peter and John - not sure when it is due to be published.

Darrell


Darrell Peart Furnituremaker

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#12

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

Jim Dillon

>Thanks Eddie and Darrell,

As I was walking the dogs this morning, I was thinking about that joint (yeah, I gotta get a life 8-)) and reached the conclusion it was not a through "dovetail". Then I read your posts and saw the answer. I am currently making the Stickley Art Nouveau table as described by Bob Lang in Popular Woodworking. He uses half-lapped dovetails for their strength; hence the question. I next want to try the Aurora nightstand in Darrell's book as another skill builder. Great book Darrell!

Jim

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#13

VERY nice Eddy!

Mike Farinella

>

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

#14

Re: A small John Hall type mirror

HC Sakman

>Eddie, it's absolutely very cute & gorgeous!

Excellent work indeed.

Chico...