hardwood floor finish
vance hough
>which finish is better for hardwood floors-oilbase or waterbase?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
hardwood floor finish
vance hough
>which finish is better for hardwood floors-oilbase or waterbase?
Re: hardwood floor finish
Nat Robison
>It's not really a question of which is better but more what are your needs and concerns.
Waterbased finishes dry faster and have less odor to them.
Oil-based finishes (in my opinion) are tougher than waterbased and do more to enhance the wood. They take longer to dry, however, and there's more odor.
I'm not a professional floor guy but I have rooms in my house that have both types of finishes and, in my opinion, the waterbased finish looks more plasticky. Also, the finish has worn down/scratched where the dog launches herself from the floor to a bed. I like the way the oil-based finish enhances the oak floor so I can't say how any other finish looks on anything but oak. Personally, I would not choose a water-based finish for my floors.
I'm sure you will get varying opinions and experiences.
Re: hardwood floor finish
Chuck Jurvelin
>If you want the best, go with BonaKemi Traffic. It is a waterbourne finish with an additive for hardening. It is a super tough commercial finish and well worth the cost.
Re: hardwood floor finish
Fred Davis
>Vance,
If your looking for a finish that is easy to apply with little prior experience in laying down a lap mark free coating and one that is easy to repair scratches , furniture marks , dings, then that lets out waterbased finish and poly based finish regardless of how much they claim for "super tough, long lasting and other hype.
The tougher and hareder finishes will show the same traffic wear and tear eventually and because of their formulations will resist attempts
to repair them.
Water based will never give a warm glow to the Oak like Shellac or a Swedish finish called Glitza which is every bit as tough as those you see advertised and has the added advantage of touch up of traffic wear with a aerosol can of their product made for that purpose.
Because Shellac was the first sucessful floor finish that was used for many years after the oil finish went out and because of the afore mentioned ease of application and restoration and because I am older then most , I like it for low traffic areas like bedrooms and Glitza for dogs, teenagers, and harried housewives who didn't know that a wood floor is a high maintenence item for the home.
Do that help any ?
FredD
Re: hardwood floor finish
Kevin Mac Luskie
>I'm a big fan of Waterlox. And it's really easy to apply. I put down 2 coats of sealer/finish, and 2 coats of satin. Hasn't been down long, so I don't have personal experience on longevity and durability, but I've heard/read good things.
-Kevin
Re: hardwood floor finish
Lee Schierer - McKean, PA
>I was very impressed with the Varathane Diamond Floor Finish when I used it on the vanity I made for my son and his wife for their bathroom. I chose a floor type finish because it would have greater durability than a standard furniture finish. It was easy to apply and made a very nice finish. It is also non-yellowing like most other waterborne finishes.
Lee
Used it on my floor
Grant in Iowa
>I used Varathane on my 550 square feet of ash flooring in my new home. I am satisfied with it in every way EXCEPT:
Don't use the Varathane brand fake labswool mop thing. It self destructed during use and there are many little fuzzies in the floor. I am planning to lightly sand it and recoat it with a disposable foam squeegie that has a mouse fur like brush on the surface.
The finish has been very durable so far.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa
Re: hardwood floor finish
Jim Dillon
>Vance,
I used Parks oil-based floor finish about 6 years ago and it has done fine and makes the wood (locust, oak, pine) look nice IMHO. I diluted the first coat to give better penetration, then applied 3 additional coats IIRC using either a lambswool pad or brush. I decided the brush (though slower) was just as good and I didn't have quite the mess of cleaning up the pad. I've used Varathane Diamond finish on vertical surfaces and it has done well. But there has been a lot of progress in water-borne finishes as well. I think Fine Homebuilding did a review of floor finishes awhile back, but it is likely out-of-date by now. One caveat here. I was able to NOT be in the house as the finish cured. It is smelly, and I can imagine a few brain cells being damaged - and I can't afford to lose any more 8-). So that might be a consideration, especially if you have small children in the house and can't keep the windows open. My 2 cents.
Jim