OT - hydrogen post made me think of this
Howard In Toronto
>How feasible does this seem?
www.engineair.com.au/
This guy seems to have come up with the best system but he's only interested in licensing not manufacturing anything.......
Howard
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
OT - hydrogen post made me think of this
Howard In Toronto
>How feasible does this seem?
www.engineair.com.au/
This guy seems to have come up with the best system but he's only interested in licensing not manufacturing anything.......
Howard
Re: OT - hydrogen post made me think of this
Basil
>Well, if it has the low consumption and high torque he claims, maybe they'll try air starters on trucks again. That was a dud first time around.
I'm not familiar with air starters on trucks
Howard In Toronto
>what were its problems?
when were they on the market?
did a few mfrs offer them? just one?
fill me in pleae - I'm genuinely interested.
thanks
Howard
Re: I'm not familiar with air starters on trucks
John McGaw
>It used to be common for large diesel engines to use compressed air to spin the engine for starting rather than an electric motor. IIRC there is a separate set of valves which compressed air into the "up" pistons forcing them down and spinning the engine.
It is still common to start jet and turbine engines using a huge volume of compressed air. In the USAF we had "starter carts" which contained a powerful turbine, IIRC the equivalent of what is used in a C-130, mounted in a towable cart. The bleed air from the turbine could be valved through a large hose and coupling into the engine of the aircraft being started. The cart also produced electrical power for the aircraft. And the air from the cart could be routed through a separate unit which used the air to power a refrigeration unit to cool aircraft interiors and avionics. The refrigeration cart was a favorite on the Nellis AFB flightline (in Las Vegas, NV) during the summer -- blowing large volumes if frigid air up your pants leg really can take the sting out of a 115-degree day...
Still have to compress the air....
John in New Mexico
>Which is not very efficient. Air motors have their uses or they wouldn't be made, but all our equipment uses electricity for a very good reason - efficiency.
Re: How about the compressed air engine car? *LINK*
Kneale Brownson Dreaming of the Snow in N. MI
>See the link:
compressed air engine car
Kneale - that's it
Howard In Toronto
>it's my understanding the Australian guy's version competes with the french-engineered India-assembled version
I asked about the Australian version because it SEEMS (read that in italics) more simple and less maintenance required.
Howard
A little different on trucks.
Basil
>Air starters on trucks were just air motors much like a large air wrench. They were about the size and wieght of a regular electric starter and bolted on to the engine in the same place as an electric starter. The truck had compressed air for the brakes so it used the same compressor to produce compressed air for the starter. Most trucks had an extra air tank to store a larger volume of air for the starter but did also use the air in the air brake tanks. Everything was fine as long as the engine started quickly, if it didn't, you were in a mess. If it didn't start, there you sat with the brakes locked due to low air pressure so you couldn't pull it off and you couldn't start the engine because of low air pressure. Usually had to get another trucker to hook gladhands with you and build air pressure to try again or at least release the brakes so you could pull it off.....and when you hit the starter button on air starter, everyone within a half a mile knew you had an air starter. I can't even begin to think of a combination of letters that would appoximate the sound of one. Just loud is all I can say.
Air starters weren't around long. You had to have a battery and gen. or alt. anyway for the lights, heater fan, etc., so you might as well add a couple more batteries and stay with the electric starter.
Basil
Aha!
John in New Mexico
>I missed the bit on the original link that said it was for transportation (the applications page). Given its size it looked like an air motor for replacing electrics.
Now if you lived in a really windy place - like I do - you could set up a windmill compressor and a big buried tank and re-fill your car for "free" (after you paid for the fiddly bits).
I saw one once...
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>I worked in a Whirlpool replacement parts packaging warehouse in my college days, in Quality Control/Inbound-Outbound. One time a truck driver there to pick up a trailer came in and said he couldn't get his truck started, so we tried to hook up a pigtail from a shop air drop. Didn't work--he ended up having to call a service truck.
Jason
Re: I'm not familiar with air starters on trucks
Rob Stokes in North Vancouver
>A lot of the older ships/tugboats used air start as well. You fired up the genny to provide power for the air compressor and when the compressor was full you used the air to roll the engine over.
The compressor was kept full during docking/tight quarters manuevering too because a lot of earlier ships did not have a reverse gear. Instead they had a second cam or set of lobes on the one cam that could be indexed on demand and allowed the engine to run backwards.
On a call for reverse, the engine had to be shut down, the cam indexed (or the second cam pulled into place) and the engine fired back up again (same process from reverse to forward again)
This is one reason for using air start - the starter actually had to overcome the effort being applied to the power train by a forward moving vessel (the prop was still turning due to drag). Elec. motors don't like going backwards and then being told to go forwards. Pneumatic motors don't care - they just do it, as long as there's enough air!
Rob
air and Hydraulic starters
Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon
>The hospital my dad worked at had air starters on their emergency gensets. I don' remember if they were air motors or shot air straight into the cylinders. I do remember they were relatively large 2 stroke Jimmy's and they picked up the emergency power circut load while still in start mode, I do remember huge air storage flasks. About hydraulic starters, I worked with a 10 ton hydraulic rough terrain crane in the Navy, it started 19 out of 20 times by pressure stored in the hydraulic accumulator. The up side of the whole thing was it did have a hand pump to recharge the pressure tank, the down side was it had a hand pump to recharge the pressure tank,it took 120 strokes.
glc
Re: I'm not familiar with air starters on trucks
John in Calgary
>We still use the equivalent of an air starter in the oil & gas industry to start our natural gas compressors, except we use natural gas instead of air since the natural gas operates at a higher operating pressure and hence packs a larger kick. From what I remember, air start went away due to the huge number of storage vessels required to ensure you had enough for a start.
The starter on the last 1500 hp compressor I installed was about the size of the 1 1/2 hp motor on the back of my table saw. Air starters, the same as air tools, pack a lot of torque into a pretty compact package.
John