Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

Posts

Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

#1

Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

George W. Dart-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Friends,

I planned on wet sanding The new double dresser today, and armed myself with some oil, naptha, felt block, paper towels, and sandpaper. The dresser is out of the shop and on our screened in back porch where its out of the sun, relatively cool, and light enough to work in quiet comfort. It has rested in place for several days while the shellac Seal Coat dried and hardened. I usually give it a couple coats, wetsand, inspect, and begin the wiping poly top coats. After wetsanding the top, I wet a towel with naptha and got rid of the residue. Then I noted someone had attacked the right rear of the top with repeated strikes of a pointed instrument, putting shallow dents and gouges perpendicular to the grain. Several times the pock marks went deep enough to expose the raw cherry. The area is about 18 inches long and perhaps 2 inches wide. I "lifted" the residue out of the depressions. In about a third of the damaged area, the wood fibers were severed, and the rest are dents which may be too deep to steam. In any event, I'd have to sand it all out, feather, and blend into the undamaged portion of the top. Fortunately, Seal coat only has thus been used in the finishing schedule. No poly has yet been applied. However, I had set the piece out in direct sunlight for a week or more to darken. Now that red color will be sanded away. Or, maybe I should sand down the entire 48"X18" top and start over as before. My wife suspects my oldest grandson because she noticed he was playing with a pen on the back porch a day or so ago. His Mom, my #1 daughter will find out. But now I have to figure how best to salvage the once perfect top. What do you think?

George

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

#2

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

Ralph Turney

>I'd sand out the whole top and get it over with. I was doing what I thought was the final rubbing out, when I noticed a dull spot...I had cut through the varnish. It's been a real PIA blending the new varnish with the old and I might have been better off sanding the entire top and starting over also. You're in a position to do just that; you have wood damage, I think you'd be much more satisfied with the over all look it you started over and got the dents out. It won't take very long, at all, for the cherry to take on the color you want, it might take a little longer under the finish, but not that much.

On the other hand, leave it as is, as a reminder of your wonderful grand children!

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

#3

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

Glenn Madsen, SF Bay Area

>Underneath my wife's desk, in the knee hole, is some vintage, custom 'Sharpie Art' from a couple of our sons. They're in their 30's now. At least the art is hidden.

One of them has a daughter, 3 yo last April, who has done similar on the walls with her father's Sharpies. Up and down the stair case. And I returned a couple of weeks back to find that the paperwork on my desk had all been customized by some of my grandchildren.

You should repair it if you feel you can do it reasonably. And, of course, teach the child(ren) appropriately. I'd rather have the stories. YMMV.

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

#4

Ellis Walentine

Maybe not too bad

Ellis Walentine

>George, it sounds like these dings and gouges don't go terribly deep. I think I would remove the Seal Coat in that area with some solvent alcohol and try hand-planing the damaged surface. See how far you get with a few thin shavings. If there are just a couple deeper blemishes, leave them for the touch-up phase or take a few more thin passes with your plane. If there are more or deeper scratches, consider flattening the entire top to bare wood and start your finishing over. In any case, you haven't lost much time or wood in making it perfect.

Ellis

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

#5

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>There was a small article in a recent issue of either FWW or Popwood that used thin plane shavings to salvage plywood tear-outs. I used it to almost flawlessly repair some dings in a white oak faceframe. Basically, you glue several layers of shavings (of the same wood) over the ding and force them into the ding using a clamp. After drying, plane and sand them flat. It'd be worth a try, especially if you're planing the top and find the dings are too deep to remove. Just save some of the shavings.

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

#6

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

Ralph Turney

>That's in the latest issue of FWW. Great tip, that sure looks like it would work in this case!

Ralph

Re: Defaced Double Dresser Top-BUMMER

#7

Repair Completed-THANKS

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Friends,

I removed the finish from the area as Ellis suggested and carefully dressed the stripped cherry with a cabinet scraper. I was able to remove a slight amount of surface material which made the surviving impressions more shallow. There were three of them left, and I decided to fill them and turn them into sap pockets. They leveled out pretty well. I have one remauining defect which is almost at the profiled edge., I'll leave that alone. Tghanks for your help.

George